Gas vs PSD
Do me a favor, and quit responding to my posts. This will be my last to you.
Why can't ya'll v10 guys live with that?
How does the PSD drive better? It's noisy and smells and somehow it drives better? Are going to tell me the truck drives down the road better? Because that has quite a bit more to do with the truck than just the engine.
Truth is though, if you look back 20 years ago, people were pulling the same size trailers they pull today, and doing it with gas engine trucks that had 255 hp and 385lb-ft (like my old 454 Chevy). In that respect even the 5.4L is better engine, specially since most of those older trucks had 3 speeds and the 5.4 comes with 5 speeds.
How much excessive power do you really need? I know I don't need to spend $7k on an engine that doesn't increase the towing capacity of my truck or help it in anyway other maybe get better mpg on more costly fuel. Heck for the money I saved from NOT buying a PSD, I can buy a nice used car and get WAY better mpg than any PSD.
It seems more like you can't live with the fact that a V10 CAN do what a PSD can do. And for those of us that use our truck 90% of time as a normal vehicle (i.e. not a truck) the V10 actually makes quite a bit of since.
Many smaller, personal aircraft's do run on gas though. Of course it's 101 octane leaded gasoline, but it's gasoline. They are generally turbo charged though to help compensate for altitude changes.
Even those of us that do use our truck as a truck 90% of the time the V10 makes sense! My truck weighs almost 7 tons empty, and routinely pulls 6-8 tons behind it with no problems. Something my 6.0 could only dream of. A 6.4 or 6.7 may get up the hill first, but I'll get up that hill every time, and without a struggle. Sometimes it will downshift a gear, but I've never had to push the rpm to get up the hills either. I remember my dads old 460 trucks pulling trailers up big hills as low as 40 MPH, foot flat to the floor. That is not the case with the V10's. They are way better than the old 460's ever were. Stock for stock, both my V10's are quicker than my 7.3's were. I remember really liking my 94.5 PSD's power. Back then it seemed like a lot. The V10's are very capable and most of all RELIABLE!
How does the PSD drive better? It's noisy and smells and somehow it drives better? Are going to tell me the truck drives down the road better? Because that has quite a bit more to do with the truck than just the engine.
Truth is though, if you look back 20 years ago, people were pulling the same size trailers they pull today, and doing it with gas engine trucks that had 255 hp and 385lb-ft (like my old 454 Chevy). In that respect even the 5.4L is better engine, specially since most of those older trucks had 3 speeds and the 5.4 comes with 5 speeds.
How much excessive power do you really need? I know I don't need to spend $7k on an engine that doesn't increase the towing capacity of my truck or help it in anyway other maybe get better mpg on more costly fuel. Heck for the money I saved from NOT buying a PSD, I can buy a nice used car and get WAY better mpg than any PSD.
It seems more like you can't live with the fact that a V10 CAN do what a PSD can do. And for those of us that use our truck 90% of time as a normal vehicle (i.e. not a truck) the V10 actually makes quite a bit of since.
And you want a good reason to regret from your purchase is mpg. Empty or towing the psd will get better mpg.
And has far as maintance goes. I can go to walmart and get 3 5 quart jugs of fordmotor craft oil for 36 bucks and a oil filter for 18. That is pretty close to what I was spending on my 08 5.4 with mobil 1.
Most of the 6.4 guys I talk to say they get around 15 mpg, which is pretty close to what a lot of v10 say they get too. With diesel costing 40 cents more per gallon that actually makes the v10 cheaper to drive.
Seriously? Comparing the least expensive conventional oil you can buy for your diesel to one of the most expensive synthetic oils you can get for your 5.4? Compare conventional to conventional or synthetic to synthetic if you want a fair comparison. I can get 7 quarts of conventional and a filter for my 5.4 for about the same as what your oil filter costs.

You want a comparison:
His 6.4 costs him over $7,000 more
His 6.4 gets 2 mpg better than me in the stop an go slow traffic, his fuel costs $0.30 more than mine, he spends $0.02 more per mile in fuel than I do.
His 6.4 is louder than my 6.8
His 6.4 can tow far easier than my 6.8, for the whole 1,000 miles a year I tow...
His 6.4 costs more in maintenance, there is more to maintaining a diesel than just oil
In the 1 year since we have owned our trucks, mine was in the shop for 2 hours because the stupid tech that did the oil change put 13 quarts of oil in the engine it (it's suppose to have 6.5), his 6.4 was in the shop for 2 weeks for an injector (granted most of that time was the dealers fault for ordering the wrong injector).
Yes, your 6.4 is quieter than the 7.3, but it's still loud compared to any normal running gas engine. The 6.7 is much better than any previous PSD, but still not as quite as a gasser. Yes they smell better too, but even the 7.3's smell better now that low sulfur diesel is out. But again, you're just saying your truck smells better than a 7.3, compare that to a gas engine.
Seem to me you're the one comparing your engine to the 7.3, not us...
I didn't mention maintance, but since you brought it up, you spend $54 on an oil change that you do, I spend $22 and have someone else do it. If you put Mobil 1 full synthetic in your 5.4, that's your fault.
Finally: STOP PUTTING WORDS IN MY MOUTH! I never said this engine was "badass" contrary to what you think, I (and almost everyone here) has consistently said the PSD is a better engine, it doesn't justify the extra cost in our case.
Plain and simple truth is that a PSD doesn't meet every single super duty owner's needs.
Many smaller, personal aircraft's do run on gas though. Of course it's 101 octane leaded gasoline, but it's gasoline. They are generally turbo charged though to help compensate for altitude changes.
Ford Trucks for Ford Truck Enthusiasts
Most of the 6.4 guys I talk to say they get around 15 mpg, which is pretty close to what a lot of v10 say they get too. With diesel costing 40 cents more per gallon that actually makes the v10 cheaper to drive.
Seriously? Comparing the least expensive conventional oil you can buy for your diesel to one of the most expensive synthetic oils you can get for your 5.4? Compare conventional to conventional or synthetic to synthetic if you want a fair comparison. I can get 7 quarts of conventional and a filter for my 5.4 for about the same as what your oil filter costs.
edit: others might get 1 more mpg because of a 4.10 rear end.
Most of the 6.4 guys I talk to say they get around 15 mpg, which is pretty close to what a lot of v10 say they get too. With diesel costing 40 cents more per gallon that actually makes the v10 cheaper to drive.
Seriously? Comparing the least expensive conventional oil you can buy for your diesel to one of the most expensive synthetic oils you can get for your 5.4? Compare conventional to conventional or synthetic to synthetic if you want a fair comparison. I can get 7 quarts of conventional and a filter for my 5.4 for about the same as what your oil filter costs.
edit: others might get 1 more mpg because of a 4.10 rear end.
However, after working with JP8 on a very small and limited basis, I'm not so sure I would want to use consistently in a diesel truck. Despite the fact that stuff sticks to everything, I think it might ware out some parts of the truck faster than normal. Specifically rubber and plastic parts. It might also pose a problem with carbon deposition in the engine it's self IMO. But most military trucks have very low miles compared to civilian trucks, so this might not be an issue for them.

You want a comparison:
His 6.4 costs him over $7,000 more
His 6.4 gets 2 mpg better than me in the stop an go slow traffic, his fuel costs $0.30 more than mine, he spends $0.02 more per mile in fuel than I do.
His 6.4 is louder than my 6.8
His 6.4 can tow far easier than my 6.8, for the whole 1,000 miles a year I tow...
His 6.4 costs more in maintenance, there is more to maintaining a diesel than just oil
In the 1 year since we have owned our trucks, mine was in the shop for 2 hours because the stupid tech that did the oil change put 13 quarts of oil in the engine it (it's suppose to have 6.5), his 6.4 was in the shop for 2 weeks for an injector (granted most of that time was the dealers fault for ordering the wrong injector).
Yes, your 6.4 is quieter than the 7.3, but it's still loud compared to any normal running gas engine. The 6.7 is much better than any previous PSD, but still not as quite as a gasser. Yes they smell better too, but even the 7.3's smell better now that low sulfur diesel is out. But again, you're just saying your truck smells better than a 7.3, compare that to a gas engine.
Seem to me you're the one comparing your engine to the 7.3, not us...
I didn't mention maintance, but since you brought it up, you spend $54 on an oil change that you do, I spend $22 and have someone else do it. If you put Mobil 1 full synthetic in your 5.4, that's your fault.
Finally: STOP PUTTING WORDS IN MY MOUTH! I never said this engine was "badass" contrary to what you think, I (and almost everyone here) has consistently said the PSD is a better engine, it doesn't justify the extra cost in our case.
Plain and simple truth is that a PSD doesn't meet every single super duty owner's needs.
Gassers don't have to do a stupid regen for the DPF or have urea pissed into your exhaust. How sissy.
There is nothing about the regen process that is good for the engine. The new diesels are just slaves to the environmentalists.
Gassers don't have to do a stupid regen for the DPF or have urea pissed into your exhaust. How sissy.
There is nothing about the regen process that is good for the engine. The new diesels are just slaves to the environmentalists.


