Transmission replacement

Reply Subscribe

Thread Tools

Search this Thread

Oct 17, 2012 | 04:47 PM

zottyzot

Thread Starter

Junior User

Joined: Nov 2009

Posts: 78

Likes: 0

Transmission replacement

I have a '96 F250 4x4, 5.8L w/ an E4OD.
The trans had been slipping pretty badly, so I changed the fluid, improved things for awhile. Today, I think it finally pooped out on me...

Is another e4od my only/best option or are there other transmissions available that will be a direct swap?

Thanks.

I don't drive the truck daily, it's used for occasional hauling and plowing.

Oct 17, 2012 | 04:55 PM

rla2005

Fleet Owner

Joined: Oct 2005

Posts: 20,789

Likes: 1,753

From: Kentucky

Check for codes before tossing in the towel or spending more money. These transmissions are completely electronic controlled. You can have a code without turning on the Check Engine Light (CEL).

Oct 17, 2012 | 04:58 PM

White 97 xlt

Postmaster

Joined: Aug 2005

Posts: 4,728

Likes: 8

From: Cleveland, TN

Quote:

Originally Posted by zottyzot

I have a '96 F250 4x4, 5.8L w/ an E4OD.
The trans had been slipping pretty badly, so I changed the fluid, improved things for awhile. Today, I think it finally pooped out on me...

Is another e4od my only/best option or are there other transmissions available that will be a direct swap?

Thanks.

I don't drive the truck daily, it's used for occasional hauling and plowing.

There is really no other trans that will direct swap.... If you go to a C6 you will loose overdrive and have computer problems unless you change out the computer for one for a manual.. The EOD is not a robust (Ford never put them behind a 351 for a reason) as the E4OD and it would also require a computer change..

So unless you are wanting to convert to a manual (still requires a computer change) the E4OD is going to be your best option... and least work and worries!!!

Others may not agree with this, but it is my opinion......

Oct 17, 2012 | 05:18 PM

zottyzot

Thread Starter

Junior User

Joined: Nov 2009

Posts: 78

Likes: 0

Quote:

Originally Posted by rla2005

Check for codes before tossing in the towel or spending more money. These transmissions are completely electronic controlled. You can have a code without turning on the Check Engine Light (CEL).

The grinding, groaning and inability to reverse lead me to believe it's a pretty serious mechanical failure.

White 97, thanks for the info. that makes my decision simple.

Oct 17, 2012 | 06:56 PM

rla2005

Fleet Owner

Joined: Oct 2005

Posts: 20,789

Likes: 1,753

From: Kentucky

Quote:

Originally Posted by zottyzot

The grinding, groaning and inability to reverse lead me to believe it's a pretty serious mechanical failure.

White 97, thanks for the info. that makes my decision simple.

Now that you have added more details to your situation, I would agree a new/rebuilt trans. may be in order.

There have been more than a few posts where someone has replace/rebuilt an E4OD to find out they have the same problem as before. I cannot read your mind or listen to the problem from the internet. Thanks for giving us more details. Your initial problem statement of "slipping" did not indicate there were other noises/symptoms with your issue.

Good luck

Oct 17, 2012 | 07:04 PM

zottyzot

Thread Starter

Junior User

Joined: Nov 2009

Posts: 78

Likes: 0

Quote:

Originally Posted by rla2005

I appreciate your advice (didn't intend to come off like a wise *** with my prior comment) while I have your attention is there a specific range the E4OD that will fit my specific Model year and configuration truck? From what I've read so far, those trans from diesels or big blocks will not work. How do I determine what a particular trans was attached to?

Oct 17, 2012 | 07:33 PM

rla2005

Fleet Owner

Joined: Oct 2005

Posts: 20,789

Likes: 1,753

From: Kentucky

Your best bet is a 95+ E4OD from F250/F350 series 4x4. You are correct, the diesel and 7.5L version will not fit. You can use a 4.9/5.0/5.8L version from that era. You could use an earlier version (89-94) if you swap the solenoid block and MLPS from your existing trans. But be aware Ford made internal, as well as electrical, changes along the way. You want the 95+ version if at all possible.