brake controller types???
My rationale about the P3 being worth the small $$$ over the Prodigy is for ONE feature that the P3 has that I WISH the Prodigy did...
Sourced CURRENT readout.
Here's why.
When I hook up my camper I have my wife check the lights as I go thru the brakes, turn signals and tail...
Once we hit the road in the campground or neighborhood...I go 5mph and MANUALLY apply the brake controller and do a drag test to ensure that my TT brakes are working. When I do this the Prodigy reads out VOLTAGE on the display. Well VOLTAGE is not a good indication of MAGNET health.
As brake magnets wear you will draw a different amount of current and they are less and less effective.
Doing that test with the P3...I would know the 'nominal' CURRENT sourced for my drag test. Each brake magnet draws up to 3.25 AMPS. CURRENT is cummulative...meaning 4 brakes drawing say 2.5 AMPS in my drag test would result in 10 AMPS on the P3 display. As magnets wear...or better yet say one is wearing much quicker than the others...over time I will see my 'nominal' CURRENT during the drag test go from 10 AMPS to 8 or 7...or maybe they draw more current?...I'm not sure actually since I have never trended CURRENT on brakes since my Prodigy doesn't give me that information...but once you hit 3.25AMPS you can't draw any more...but I would KNOW I need to adjust my brakes since sourced current has CHANGED 20 or 30% over my 'nominal'...at least I would INVESTIGATE to understand the change in 'nominal'...
With the Prodigy...VOLTAGE will be the SAME. Ohms law tells us that. But CURRENT tells a much more informed story.
So for me...yeah...the P3 is slightly more (maybe $30 these days)...and $30 is not insignificant for many...myself included...but I feel you get much more information for that $30 than you could ever imagine. It may just save your bacon one day when you have to make a panic stop and you should have adjusted your trailer brakes the previous week during your drag test...
Just my rationale...that's all...
I still have my Prodigy and don't plan on dumping her...but if I were in the market today or had the P3 been available three years ago when I purchased my Prodigy...I would have easily popped for the P3 for that ONE feature of sourced CURRENT readout.
Joe.
I'll give you that the P3 menus make for a more involved interface.
But to be honest...the ONLY thing I have EVER adjusted on my Prodigy is cycling thru the Boost. Different roads/grades require different boost levels...
I don't fiddle with anything else on my Prodigy...once I've determined the voltage level I needed for my trailer...I haven't adjusted that once...
One thing that is also nice about the P3 display...is that simply looking at the screen tells you if you are in boost1, boost2, boost3 or boostoff...with the Prodigy...you only get that second 'DOT' that tells you that you have SOME boost set...you must toggle thru them to figure out which you have currently set...
Each has pluses and minuses for sure...but for me...I'd really like to have knowledge of sourced CURRENT that my Prodigy simply does not provide...that's all...and I really do think it is worth the small extra $ and possibly a somewhat more involved interface...especially since I don't really need that interface all that often...
So I'm not sure what folks are adjusting on the fly...other than boost...and the Prodigy one button toggle interface can't get any easier...that is for sure...
Joe.
I'll give you that the P3 menus make for a more involved interface.
But to be honest...the ONLY thing I have EVER adjusted on my Prodigy is cycling thru the Boost. Different roads/grades require different boost levels...
I don't fiddle with anything else on my Prodigy...once I've determined the voltage level I needed for my trailer...I haven't adjusted that once...
One thing that is also nice about the P3 display...is that simply looking at the screen tells you if you are in boost1, boost2, boost3 or boostoff...with the Prodigy...you only get that second 'DOT' that tells you that you have SOME boost set...you must toggle thru them to figure out which you have currently set...
Each has pluses and minuses for sure...but for me...I'd really like to have knowledge of sourced CURRENT that my Prodigy simply does not provide...that's all...and I really do think it is worth the small extra $ and possibly a somewhat more involved interface...especially since I don't really need that interface all that often...
So I'm not sure what folks are adjusting on the fly...other than boost...and the Prodigy one button toggle interface can't get any easier...that is for sure...
Joe.
SET IT, AND FORGET IT.
Ford Trucks for Ford Truck Enthusiasts
Here is a picture of the install and the trailer.









