Fumoto Oil Drain Valve Yes or No!
#46
Well we had a NO GO on the Fumoto install attempt.
The old plug was not leaking but it was torqued to 5 pounds or less. As soon as I backed it off one round a stream of oil developed and the plug fit was a very very loose fit in the threads. When I cleaned it off after getting it out I saw it had a very thick black plastic looking washer on it and I was thinking it was near stripped or had an over size plug as a "fix" in the past.
Sure enough the Fumoto valve threads did not even attempt to bite.
I went back with the old plug and tighened it as much as I dared. Instead of the normal 70% thread bite I am guessing we are more at a 20% bite.
It had the long version filter on it and some really thick stuff finally drained out of the bottom of it. If it is a by pass filter it may have been by passing. The oil out of the pan was dirty but thin even before I added 16 oz of Sea Foam and gave it 30 minutes of run time before the drain.
After finding the plug issue I am going to skip the Fumoto valve on this engine until after I check with them and see if the deep pan truck engines used a different size drain that the standard 429 drain plug. Since the truck may only see a couple thousand miles a year I may just change the long filter every year and that will be 2 new quarts of oil. I will just see how it looks and plan to use the Wal-Mart 10W-30 synthtic oil which I had not picked up yet. The only keys are in another vehicle to help insure it is not started without oil. We got the down and dirty part finished just as it started to rain so that worked out nicely and will pour in the oil tomorrow.
The old plug was not leaking but it was torqued to 5 pounds or less. As soon as I backed it off one round a stream of oil developed and the plug fit was a very very loose fit in the threads. When I cleaned it off after getting it out I saw it had a very thick black plastic looking washer on it and I was thinking it was near stripped or had an over size plug as a "fix" in the past.
Sure enough the Fumoto valve threads did not even attempt to bite.
I went back with the old plug and tighened it as much as I dared. Instead of the normal 70% thread bite I am guessing we are more at a 20% bite.
It had the long version filter on it and some really thick stuff finally drained out of the bottom of it. If it is a by pass filter it may have been by passing. The oil out of the pan was dirty but thin even before I added 16 oz of Sea Foam and gave it 30 minutes of run time before the drain.
After finding the plug issue I am going to skip the Fumoto valve on this engine until after I check with them and see if the deep pan truck engines used a different size drain that the standard 429 drain plug. Since the truck may only see a couple thousand miles a year I may just change the long filter every year and that will be 2 new quarts of oil. I will just see how it looks and plan to use the Wal-Mart 10W-30 synthtic oil which I had not picked up yet. The only keys are in another vehicle to help insure it is not started without oil. We got the down and dirty part finished just as it started to rain so that worked out nicely and will pour in the oil tomorrow.
#47
#48
#50
I really was just talking about Fumoto valves in a direct sense.
I did go ahead and picked up and put in the 5W-40 Rotella Syn after your post since it was only $18 more than the WM 10W-30 syn as I plan to use it in the MH and diesel tractor (the three vehicles we service at home) counting the dump truck.
The damaged drain plug threads was a let down but at least the black mess is ready to return to WM and we have the best oil money can buy locally in the crankcase. My guess the old oil was about 5 years old (when the last owner purchased it).
I did go ahead and picked up and put in the 5W-40 Rotella Syn after your post since it was only $18 more than the WM 10W-30 syn as I plan to use it in the MH and diesel tractor (the three vehicles we service at home) counting the dump truck.
The damaged drain plug threads was a let down but at least the black mess is ready to return to WM and we have the best oil money can buy locally in the crankcase. My guess the old oil was about 5 years old (when the last owner purchased it).
#52
#54
My last UOA I split the sample into two bottles. One I sent in just as it was taken. The other I inserted a STRONG magnet in it for quite awhile. The anaytical results were essentially identical. I wonder how much good the magnet is under normal circumstances ..........
#55
#58
If your oil is warm and has been mixed up prior to draining, then "stuff" is suspended and will drain out. As well, "heavy particulate" will settle to the bottom anyways and drain out.
Most oil drain plugs on gas or diesel motors are NOT magnatized and there not wholesale problems... the Fumoto valve is just for convenience and eliminates the possibly of stripping the drain plug and having the replace the copper/crush gasket each time.
But hey... if it works, stay with it... it worked for me until I got my Fumoto Valve.
Happy Thanksgiving.
#60
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: The Great State of Texas
Posts: 6,133
Received 1,449 Likes
on
894 Posts
It keeps popping up for a good reason. Some people are on the fence to whether go with convenience (fumoto valve) vs magnetic filtering (oem drain plug). I'm personally on the magneted filtering because I remember when I changed the oil for the first time the magnet had some metal particles stuck to it that never made it to the oil filter. Maybe the magnet is there for the break-in period, but provides a peace of mind.