lucas oil Stablizer
Did you even click the links I posted? Lucas has sulpher. Sulpher is used in EP additives in gear oil. I know of no other use for it in an oil product. Same with phosphorus. Now if sulpher is the only point of contention of why gear oil will hurt an engine, then lucas will hurt it too. Period.
That said, I dont believe that EITHER belong in an engine. I tried the gear oil as a stopgap measure, and a test. It worked good. It did make my engine quieter. However, I dont run it every oil change, as I think the piston slap is minimal enough to not cause a problem. Besides, it's getting a rebuild at 200,000 anyway.
BTW, I never said that it definately was repackaged gear oil. I said that was the going theory. I've heard it before elsewhere, and read it on this board before.
I also spent the first 5 years of my professional life as a formulator of lubricants. Motor oil and gear oil both may contain sulfur and phosphorus.
A common EP (extreme Pressure) additive used in motor oil is zinc dialkyldithiophosphate. It has both sulfur and phosphorus in it. BTW, most oil has SOME sulfur in it naturally. It's refined out to make cleaner-burning gasoline. In fact, crude oil from differing areas has differing native sulfur content, but I digress.
Gear lubes typically use higher amounts of sulfur-containing additives, such as molybdenum disulfide, but newer compounds that are less corrosive, are also used in higher priced lubes. For a good general description on some of the better additives, I recommend reading:
http://www.rtvanderbilt.com/petro_2.htm
Now, my guess is that Lucas Oil Stabilizer is a mixture of polybutene and some EP, anti-wear and antioxidant additives. The statement that it is incompatible with bromine leads me to believe that it has some degree on unsaturation in the carbon chain. (That's chemist jargon for C=C double bonds).
I have a bottle of Lucas Oil Treatment sitting in my garage waiting to be put into my 91 clattering Club Wagon as soon as the oil level drops ~1 quart below full. Advanced Auto has a neat little display that shows Lucas' ability to remain on gears as you turn a crank that in turn turns two more gears. There is clearly a more viscuos film clinging to the oil treated gears. My guess is that this film helps prevent metal to metal contact of pushrod to lifter or pushrod to rocker arm, hence the quieting.
For what it's worth, polybutenes are routinely used as Viscosity Index enhancers, so putting them in your engine oil makes oil "thicker" at higher temperatures. It isn't cheap stuff, though, which is probably why Lucas is fairly expensive. (That and all the advertising they do in Drag racing).






