When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
@Garbageman 134
To be clear, does this happen when your foot is standing on the gas, using a good amout of power, just before shifting from 1st to 2nd?
Or is it right during the shift? Then after the shift you can stand on the gas and all is smooth?
Mild throttle. I am accelerating and then it starts shuddering and then it shifts into second gear and then it is smooth
It is possible that it is the shift valve stuttering during the shift. I will be interested in hearing what it does in a manual shift with a heavy load. (When you test, also test the shift with the transmission in normal mode to compare)
I did try it in normal mode while pulling the trailer and it was the same result
Mild throttle. I am accelerating and then it starts shuddering and then it shifts into second gear and then it is smooth
OK. Think about this. 1st gear = maximum torque to drive line/ differential. When you apply throttle and there is resistance (pulling a trailer) so when the rear wheels are rotating forward, the rear diff housing is trying to rotate backward. Also, with some tongue weight the rear end has squatted some, pushing the carrier bearing and front end of the rear drive shaft down some. Now combine the lowered front of the drive shaft along with the nose of the diff pointing more upward you have the u-joint out of alignment just enough to cause a vibration.
It is called “axle wrap”.
This seems to be most prevalent in the F 250’s (lightest springs in the Super Duty line). And it seems to be more prevalent in the diesels, happening in more than just 1st gear.
Of course, this is just a guess on my part; but my logic tells me this is what is happening.
Best of luck getting this sorted out. Keep us posted if you find a solution, especially if it is not axle wrap……inquiring minds want to know.
OK. Think about this. 1st gear = maximum torque to drive line/ differential. When you apply throttle and there is resistance (pulling a trailer) so when the rear wheels are rotating forward, the rear diff housing is trying to rotate backward. Also, with some tongue weight the rear end has squatted some, pushing the carrier bearing and front end of the rear drive shaft down some. Now combine the lowered front of the drive shaft along with the nose of the diff pointing more upward you have the u-joint out of alignment just enough to cause a vibration.
It is called “axle wrap”.
This seems to be most prevalent in the F 250’s (lightest springs in the Super Duty line). And it seems to be more prevalent in the diesels, happening in more than just 1st gear.
Of course, this is just a guess on my part; but my logic tells me this is what is happening.
Best of luck getting this sorted out. Keep us posted if you find a solution, especially if it is not axle wrap……inquiring minds want to know.
most of the weight in the trailer was loaded in the front half so in front of the Dual rear axles which would lead to more tongue weight so I guess your theory is plausible
The 10 speeds do this. There is even a footnote in the owners manual about some shutter.
Mine does it (6.7) and I don't like it so I baby the start until I get to 3rd gear then apply more throttle. I've tried Tow/Haul and normal - it does it when towing. If I try a jack rabbit start with the RV (15k) it is sort of bad so I try to take it easy.
There are other threads on this site about this too.
Here is the note in my owner's manual......TRAILER TOWING HINTS
Towing a trailer places an extra load on your vehicle's engine, transmission, axle, brakes, tires and suspension. Periodically inspect these components during and after any towing operation.
When driving with a trailer or payload, a slight takeoff vibration or shudder may be present due to the increased payload weight.
Yup, while I didn't notice it on my 2019, and haven't felt it on the 23 yet, my 2004 Ram 2500 Cummins did this when I was towing. Unless the shuddering is violently shaking the truck, I believe what the OP is noticing is 100% normal.
Yup, while I didn't notice it on my 2019, and haven't felt it on the 23 yet, my 2004 Ram 2500 Cummins did this when I was towing. Unless the shuddering is violently shaking the truck, I believe what the OP is noticing is 100% normal.
I'm surprised this does not come up more often from people who are pulling trailers, travel trailers, Etc. I got to wonder if there's any negative consequences long-term
I'm surprised this does not come up more often from people who are pulling trailers, travel trailers, Etc. I got to wonder if there's any negative consequences long-term
To answer your question, no, I don't think there are any long-term negative consequences from the shudder. As to why it doesn't come up all that much is anyone's guess... either a lot of folks don't pay that much attention, or the affected drivers are familiar with the shudder and don't worry too much about it.