E4OD or Gear Vendors for C6 ? - 1989 F250 5.8L
#1
E4OD or Gear Vendors for C6 ? - 1989 F250 5.8L
I have a 1989 Ford F250 / 5.8L with a 3 speed Auto in it. I like the trans and have read that it is a great one to keep (bulletproof) but I need to start driving between states and will be putting some highway miles on the truck. I don't want to do these miles at 3000 RPM so I'm looking for an OD solution (truck only has 50,000 miles on it and I want to keep it in good shape).
That's the background, here are the questions....
- Is the E4OD Trans a simple bolt up replacement to my 3 speed ?
- Will I suffer in any way replacing my 3 speed with the E4OD ? (I have heard the E4OD has had it's problems mechanically)
- How does the E4OD overdirve compare to using the Gear Vendors with my 3 speed ? I'm reading that with the Gear Vendors OD, my 60 mph / 3000 rpm will change to 60 mph / 2300 rpm. IS this comperable to the E4OD ?
- Since my 3 speed seems to be so highly reviewed, is the better option the 3 speed with the Gear Vendors ? I do work the truck, plowing, moving equipment etc.
Thanks for your advice !
- Mark
That's the background, here are the questions....
- Is the E4OD Trans a simple bolt up replacement to my 3 speed ?
- Will I suffer in any way replacing my 3 speed with the E4OD ? (I have heard the E4OD has had it's problems mechanically)
- How does the E4OD overdirve compare to using the Gear Vendors with my 3 speed ? I'm reading that with the Gear Vendors OD, my 60 mph / 3000 rpm will change to 60 mph / 2300 rpm. IS this comperable to the E4OD ?
- Since my 3 speed seems to be so highly reviewed, is the better option the 3 speed with the Gear Vendors ? I do work the truck, plowing, moving equipment etc.
Thanks for your advice !
- Mark
#2
Re: E4OD or Gear Vendors for C6 ? - 1989 F250 5.8L
Originally posted by MGiven
I have a 1989 Ford F250 / 5.8L with a 3 speed Auto in it. I like the trans and have read that it is a great one to keep (bulletproof) but I need to start driving between states and will be putting some highway miles on the truck. I don't want to do these miles at 3000 RPM so I'm looking for an OD solution (truck only has 50,000 miles on it and I want to keep it in good shape).
That's the background, here are the questions....
- Is the E4OD Trans a simple bolt up replacement to my 3 speed ?
- Will I suffer in any way replacing my 3 speed with the E4OD ? (I have heard the E4OD has had it's problems mechanically)
- How does the E4OD overdirve compare to using the Gear Vendors with my 3 speed ? I'm reading that with the Gear Vendors OD, my 60 mph / 3000 rpm will change to 60 mph / 2300 rpm. IS this comperable to the E4OD ?
- Since my 3 speed seems to be so highly reviewed, is the better option the 3 speed with the Gear Vendors ? I do work the truck, plowing, moving equipment etc.
Thanks for your advice !
- Mark
I have a 1989 Ford F250 / 5.8L with a 3 speed Auto in it. I like the trans and have read that it is a great one to keep (bulletproof) but I need to start driving between states and will be putting some highway miles on the truck. I don't want to do these miles at 3000 RPM so I'm looking for an OD solution (truck only has 50,000 miles on it and I want to keep it in good shape).
That's the background, here are the questions....
- Is the E4OD Trans a simple bolt up replacement to my 3 speed ?
- Will I suffer in any way replacing my 3 speed with the E4OD ? (I have heard the E4OD has had it's problems mechanically)
- How does the E4OD overdirve compare to using the Gear Vendors with my 3 speed ? I'm reading that with the Gear Vendors OD, my 60 mph / 3000 rpm will change to 60 mph / 2300 rpm. IS this comperable to the E4OD ?
- Since my 3 speed seems to be so highly reviewed, is the better option the 3 speed with the Gear Vendors ? I do work the truck, plowing, moving equipment etc.
Thanks for your advice !
- Mark
E4OD's aren't too strong in stock form here is what they need:
1. Full TransGo shift kit ($100)
2. Upgrade to the 45 element intermiediate sprag ($50)
3. 6 Pinion front and rear planetaries ($325)
4. Stuff 8 clutches in the direct drum of 3rd gear
5. 20000gvw+ Trans Cooler ($40)
That trans will then be ready for action. It will shift far, far faster with the TransGo but still be streetable and not neck snapping...but can be if you want.
The GV unit is an aux OD unit, the E4OD has OD built in. The E4OD is basically an electronically operated C6 with OD.
A properly built C6 will take the same abuse as the C6. I'd say TCI is the only company who will set you up with a standalone PCM for the shifts of the trans. If my fully built AOD can't hold a 408 I have planned I am going to go with an E4OD in my truck.
#3
#4
Originally posted by MGiven
Hit Man,
Thanks for the input. What is you opinion of the GV unit versus the E4OD ? After the mod's you outlined it looks to be about the same price either way I go. The GV looks like less work.
- Mark
Hit Man,
Thanks for the input. What is you opinion of the GV unit versus the E4OD ? After the mod's you outlined it looks to be about the same price either way I go. The GV looks like less work.
- Mark
Exactly pricewise...they are both close to the same when all said and done. I'd say the C6+GV is going to be the easiest to install.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Rocky Mountain F150
1987 - 1996 F150 & Larger F-Series Trucks
19
10-04-2013 12:59 PM
wildstang
1994.5 - 1997 7.3L Power Stroke Diesel
5
09-17-2008 07:56 AM