When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Okay guys. Since I'm going the toothless Jake route in my engine rehab I looked up a new oil pump. Rock Auto offers a standard volume / standard pressure, Standard volume / high pressure, and a high volume version.
What should I go with?
Wouldn't high volume create higher pressure as well?
So what's the gain with standard volume / high pressure?
Also, it said to make sure of crank and pan clearance for the high volume model?
If I had to make the decision w/o any other input I would go with the standard volume/pressure one.
What? Are you advising that he overfill the crankcase?
Yes. That's exactly right. A high volume pump puts more oil up in the engine, (especially at higher RPM) and has the possibility of sucking the pan dry in some circumstances. One extra quart of oil ensures that there will always be plenty of supply for the pump. And one extra won't harm anything.
351, a low-volume oil pump and a high-volume oil pump have a preset pressure in the relief spring. Once you reach that pressure, the oil is dumped back into the crankcase.
A high-volume pump will increase pressure at idle, all things equal, and get you up quicker to the relief pressure. After that, you are increasing the entropy of the universe, blowing oil back into the crankcase at a higher temperature than it would otherwise be.
Parasitic loss.
351, a low-volume oil pump and a high-volume oil pump have a preset pressure in the relief spring. Once you reach that pressure, the oil is dumped back into the crankcase.
A high-volume pump will increase pressure at idle, all things equal, and get you up quicker to the relief pressure. After that, you are increasing the entropy of the universe, blowing oil back into the crankcase at a higher temperature than it would otherwise be.
Parasitic loss.
Understood John, but when the pump is ABLE to push that extra oil up into the engine, it doesn't drain back any faster.
Most of the time, the oil level isn't an issue. But it can be when going around a corner, or hard acceleration, when it will slosh away from the pickup tube. An extra quart helps prevent that from happening. Not to mention the other benefits of more oil. Like extra cooling ability, possible extended oil change intervals, and so on.
On the pressure side of it, yes a high volume pump will run the pressure up more quickly and hold it higher, because it is pumping more oil. But since when is oil pressure a bad thing? I get concerned when my oil pressure drops below 25psi....
I like the idea of the screens too. Anyone running end supports on the rocker assemblies?
The rocker shaft supports are recommended when running a high lift cam and stiffer valve springs. I don't think too many of us have cams of more than .550 lift. Some day......
I went with high volume as the rpm my motor will see is in the low range. Also, I am using stock sized bearings. No machine work to block, rods or crank. They all mic'ed fine, but did lean to the loose side. I also put the restrictors (Holley jets drilled to 90) in the heads. Still kicking around an external electric oil pump so it never starts dry. Low duty cycle for this vehicle. It's going to sit around most of the time.
And I had to chuckle picturing my dump truck in 'hard acceleration.' Yeah, accelerating will still be hard...
If you have new bearings or more than about 5-8psi of idle oil pressure, a high volume pump can cause more headaches than anything. I once had a 78 F150 with a built 400, and the previous owner put in a high volume pump as part of a rebuild. The truck stripped the teeth off the cam gear more than once before we sorted out that is was the oil pump's fault. Once the pump was changed it stopped doing that.
If you have the pan off, do the right fix and throw in new bearings along with a regular pump.