To rebuild or not to rebuild... That is the question.
#1
To rebuild or not to rebuild... That is the question.
I don't think it needs it, there was zero blow by but... I have completely torn down my motor for an oil pan gasket except for removing the heads, pistons, cam shaft, crank shaft etc.
Sense I have torn it down this far should I go ahead and take it to a machine shop and have them put in a gear head cam shaft (suggestion from Bonanza 35) and do the piston rings, have it honed, main/rod bearings, freeze plugs etc.
Here is my teardown thread if you have not seen it. More pics here Pg7.
https://www.ford-trucks.com/forums/1...al-w-pics.html
Sense I have torn it down this far should I go ahead and take it to a machine shop and have them put in a gear head cam shaft (suggestion from Bonanza 35) and do the piston rings, have it honed, main/rod bearings, freeze plugs etc.
Here is my teardown thread if you have not seen it. More pics here Pg7.
https://www.ford-trucks.com/forums/1...al-w-pics.html
#2
I would...You've come this far, why not! It's only money!
Your cam looks like mine did, I had one lobe that just didn't look right. I bought a 2002 with 160k no cylinder ridge and its at the machine shop now. When its done I'll pull my 99 apart to get the coveted forged rods out...
If you got the money, do it.
Your cam looks like mine did, I had one lobe that just didn't look right. I bought a 2002 with 160k no cylinder ridge and its at the machine shop now. When its done I'll pull my 99 apart to get the coveted forged rods out...
If you got the money, do it.
#4
I'm not the expert here - so this is just what would go through my mind in your situation: If there is significant wear on the lobes, I'm this far into it and I don't want to do it twice. If the lobes are just discolored, but all else is well - I don't want to do unnecessary work. I'd install an oil bypass filter to slow down the wear, though.
#7
Thanks for the opinions. Money is tight as I have spent most of what I have saved at this point and may need to borrow some (hint mom and dad)
I can't find the gear head site to see what a cam will cost.
If all is good from machine shop, am I able to reuse pistons or is that just dumb? I have forged rods in the block already from factory.
Rough estimated cost???
Also is ARP a good decision? Not planning for 500hp just reliability as I will keep this truck for a very long time.
Thoughts on oil cooler? Mine looks real clean.
Note: truck has 215K miles
I can't find the gear head site to see what a cam will cost.
If all is good from machine shop, am I able to reuse pistons or is that just dumb? I have forged rods in the block already from factory.
Rough estimated cost???
Also is ARP a good decision? Not planning for 500hp just reliability as I will keep this truck for a very long time.
Thoughts on oil cooler? Mine looks real clean.
Note: truck has 215K miles
Trending Topics
#8
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: Asheville-where weird is
Posts: 2,404
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Hi Scott! I am with the people that say bite the bullet now. I have tried to enhance the photo to get more detail and included it. As JetDoc said, the lobe to the left of the connecting rod does not look good based upon what I see; however, these are tough old engines. As Tugly suggested, an oil bypass filter or equivalent would not be a bad idea now or at any point for you and anyone reading this.
Could you post a couple of pics of the rest of the cam with as many lifters as possible so we can see the overall condition.
Could you post a couple of pics of the rest of the cam with as many lifters as possible so we can see the overall condition.
#9
Good job on blowing up that pic! I will get more and turn the motor over for better visibility.
So, today I went to a highly reputable powerstroke stroke diesel shop here in Reno T&A Performance to get a recommendation for a machine shop and after talking to them and telling them it's all apart for a pan gasket yet I'm this far the new stuff I'm putting in it They told me in the trucks that they have done with 800hp have never touched a cam shaft. Told me to leave it alone no need to go any further and said "if it aint broke don't fix it." You have done everything right and call it good. I just would hate to not go the extra mile, but I'm looking at another 2-3K dollars. IDK
So, today I went to a highly reputable powerstroke stroke diesel shop here in Reno T&A Performance to get a recommendation for a machine shop and after talking to them and telling them it's all apart for a pan gasket yet I'm this far the new stuff I'm putting in it They told me in the trucks that they have done with 800hp have never touched a cam shaft. Told me to leave it alone no need to go any further and said "if it aint broke don't fix it." You have done everything right and call it good. I just would hate to not go the extra mile, but I'm looking at another 2-3K dollars. IDK
#10
Join Date: Sep 2014
Location: Asheville-where weird is
Posts: 2,404
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Good job on blowing up that pic! I will get more and turn the motor over for better visibility.
So, today I went to a highly reputable powerstroke stroke diesel shop here in Reno T&A Performance to get a recommendation for a machine shop and after talking to them and telling them it's all apart for a pan gasket yet I'm this far the new stuff I'm putting in it They told me in the trucks that they have done with 800hp have never touched a cam shaft. Told me to leave it alone no need to go any further and said "if it aint broke don't fix it." You have done everything right and call it good. I just would hate to not go the extra mile, but I'm looking at another 2-3K dollars. IDK
So, today I went to a highly reputable powerstroke stroke diesel shop here in Reno T&A Performance to get a recommendation for a machine shop and after talking to them and telling them it's all apart for a pan gasket yet I'm this far the new stuff I'm putting in it They told me in the trucks that they have done with 800hp have never touched a cam shaft. Told me to leave it alone no need to go any further and said "if it aint broke don't fix it." You have done everything right and call it good. I just would hate to not go the extra mile, but I'm looking at another 2-3K dollars. IDK
That may be good advice. I don't know if the 800 hp statement is applicable. To me it is a wear issue....
When you take the new pics, send them to us and let us see them. Some of the experts on here will eventually weigh in. Also, show them, the reputable powerstroke folks, the picture above and any that we highlight in the future.
#11
#12
I would polish the crank and rods, and have everything balanced. Balancing is one area where nearly all stock mass produced engines leave a lot on the table. Balancing won't nessecarily make more power, but it will make the engine smoother, and increase longevity.
It might also be a good time to investigate the benefits of various coatings, such as thermal barrier coatings on the piston tops, and a friftion reduction/anti-scuff coating on the skirts.
Also is ARP a good decision? Not planning for 500hp just reliability as I will keep this truck for a very long time.
Note: truck has 215K miles
.......... They told me in the trucks that they have done with 800hp have never touched a cam shaft. Told me to leave it alone no need to go any further and said "if it aint broke don't fix it." You have done everything right and call it good. I just would hate to not go the extra mile, but I'm looking at another 2-3K dollars. IDK
#13