When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
So, out of the blue, my X starts running rough. After the second day it finally throws a code. "misfire on cyl 1 detected".
For trouble shooting purposes I'm planning to swap coils with another cylinder to see if the problem follows the coil. What else would be a logical place to look for an issue? I've got 120,000 miles. If one coil goes out, should I be thinking the other nine are getting sketchy?
And lastly, any gotchas I need to be aware of when changing coils?
Seeing as when I bought my truck at 90,000 miles, I had been recommended to change 8 out of the 10 coils, I think that having a bad one at 120,000 miles is acceptable. I know most people disagree with me on this, but my view is to just change out all 10 if you have a problem with one. They seem to all go out eventually, and how many times do you want to deal with this?
That said, I expect to be able to jump in my truck and drive cross-country on a moment's notice, which is part of why I maintain it in this manner. I don't want to deal with my truck breaking whille I'm on a trip with it.
I would also only buy genuine Ford coils. While I use aftermarket ignition products on distributor ignition setups with good results, I have not had good results on the distributorless components.
When I bought my 10 coils, it was about $500 from one of the Ford parts deaer websites, can't remember which one I used. Changing the coils is not difficult, either.
I agree with Ted but also realize that not all folks may be in a financial position to do that.
Swap the one for now just to troubleshoot. It could be a bad COP or it may just need to be reseated. It has to be a pretty hard fault for it to set the check engine light. Most times a bad COP won't set it.
The second logical thing to do would be to pull the plug. With 120K on it do you know if the plugs are original or if they have been changed? If they are original, I would replace them all as soon as it is feasible.
Yeah, the plugs were changed at the 100k service. I figure if I do the 'replace all coils' route I will do plugs again, making sure they are properly torqued.
I agree with Ted but also realize that not all folks may be in a financial position to do that.
Very true! Sinking $500 into coils may not be an option, in which case go ahead and replace the one!
Swap the one for now just to troubleshoot. It could be a bad COP or it may just need to be reseated. It has to be a pretty hard fault for it to set the check engine light. Most times a bad COP won't set it.
Yep. When my truck had the bad coils it did not set a code. If you have a hard miss, it is almost certainly a bad coil.
The second logical thing to do would be to pull the plug. With 120K on it do you know if the plugs are original or if they have been changed? If they are original, I would replace them all as soon as it is feasible.
So, I went home and stared at my engine and looked in the manual, which is cylinder 1? The manual doesn't say 'front of engine' or something like that. And, it looks like the front cylinder (closest to the radiator), on the drivers side is further forward of the passenger side cylinder. The closest I can figure the passenger side furthest forward should be number 1. Correct?
Secondly, does the fuel injection rail get in the way of extracting the coils?
Number 1 is the "front/right" if you're looking at it from the driver's seat.
I had some misfire problems (twice) due to water intrusion into the plug wells. Threw a code the second time, but it was just a matter of drying things out.
So, I went home and stared at my engine and looked in the manual, which is cylinder 1? The manual doesn't say 'front of engine' or something like that. And, it looks like the front cylinder (closest to the radiator), on the drivers side is further forward of the passenger side cylinder. The closest I can figure the passenger side furthest forward should be number 1. Correct?
Secondly, does the fuel injection rail get in the way of extracting the coils?
Thx,
Archie
Oh, and no problem with injector rails getting in the way. The COP's come out very easily, but you may have to remove some of the other interference. Vacuum hoses, air intake, throttle body cover, etc.
I wanted to thank everybody who has chimed in on this subject....
I swapped coils, we'll see if the problem follows to cylinder 6. It started up fine, and still has the stumble/misfire. I vacuumed out and blew out the plug well, pulled the plug to have a look - looked fine. Reinstalled the plug with anti-seize and torqued to 10 ft-lbs (120 in-lbs).
It threw the same code, after the coil swap. Still cylinder number 1.... so, not the coil. Spark plug, fuel injector? I'd hate to think it could be the wiring harness.
It threw the same code, after the coil swap. Still cylinder number 1.... so, not the coil. Spark plug, fuel injector? I'd hate to think it could be the wiring harness.
Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated,
Archie (running on nine)
I would just replace the spark plug and then see what happens. By the way what kind of spark plugs are they? If they aren't Motorcraft or Autolight I would replace all 10. John
Last edited by shadows4; Feb 29, 2008 at 03:29 PM.
Reason: need more info
What does the #1 plug look like when you pull it right after running the engine? Wet with fuel, or dry? White, discolored, or normal? If wet, it's probably not a fuel problem. If dry/white, maybe too little or no fuel. If that's the case, then look to your injectors first. Kind of a lot of work to replace just one, so you might consider at least five at a time - maybe all of them. I suppose if you have the time and patience, you could swap the #1 injector with another to see if the problem moves. You could also buy just one injector to use as a trouble shooter, but as I said you'll need time and patience with that process...
Just my $0.02
Have a great weekend!
Steve
Originally Posted by X_archie
It threw the same code, after the coil swap. Still cylinder number 1.... so, not the coil. Spark plug, fuel injector? I'd hate to think it could be the wiring harness.
I swapped sparkplugs between 1 and 6, and the code followed to cylinder six. I changed out all the plugs, what a project! At least I know it has been done correctly now. I'm glad it turned out to be the most inexpensive part.
I hope this trouble shooting experience can help other folks out.
Rezvani's Latest Post-Apocalyptic Monster Is a Ford F-150 Raptor Underneath
Slideshow: Called the Fortress, the 850-horsepower pickup combines Raptor underpinnings with military-inspired features, survival equipment, and a starting price of $285,000.