Fan clutch thread?
I'm doing a efan conversion on my truck which I had planned for the summer but other things came up so I plan on doing it in the next couple of weeks. I took some advise earlier on using a 18 inch 2 speed taurus fan and now I gathered enough parts to finish the job.
Here's the list so if anyone has more to offer, please do so.
- 1 oem ford taurus fan 30 amp rating with the shroud
- 2 bosch 50 amp relays
- 2 spools of 10 gauge wire
- 1 flex-a-lite thermostat switch
- miles of conduit covering
- weather proof terminal ends
- couple packs of nylon straps
I plan on using the low speed for the AC/defrost and high speed for cooling which is why I am using 2 relays that are a good and beefy 50 amps. i also plan on soldering all conects so there won't be any chance of a short circuit. So far the total cost has been just under a $100 compared to a kit from troyer that is about $500.
If anyone is interested I will try to take pics and post them on this thread in case anyone else wants to attempt the conversion.
I guess if it did draw that many amps (100) I would have to look at a starter relay as an option.
Last edited by xtrford; Oct 30, 2007 at 09:26 PM.
Haynes also notes the use of "special two-part fan wrench set, obtainable at most auto parts stores, is required" & shows a photo of the tools. I had little trouble using ordinary tools & my '98 4.6 was indeed reverse thread, as was my '92 5.0 & '85 4.9.
Haynes also directs you to "drain cooling system" & "remove the upper radiator hose" in order to remove the fan shroud. I found that the fan shroud was flexible enough to wrestle out w/o touching the antifreeze or hose. You need to lift out the fan assembly & shroud somewhat together.
You "also plan on soldering all conects so there won't be any chance of a short circuit"? Crimp type solderless connectors have proven themselves for decades & are rarely a source of a "short circuit". There is no link between "soldering all conects" & eliminating "any chance of a short circuit". Most shorts result from routing issues, where insulation gets worn through on sharp edges, exposing hot conductor to ground. IMO you would be ill advised to attempt to solder wires onto typical 1/4" flat blade, crimp type, terminals normally found on relays, fan motor contacts, thermostatic controls, switches, etc.
When you recycle a fan off a Taurus take note of the gauge of wire used, nothing any thicker is required, duplicate what had been used. Forget what you can find searching Google & use what FORD knows worked. Also take note of the fuse used to protect the cooling fan circuit & duplicate. That amperage is more than normal "fan draw when it first comes on". No need to try to reinvent the wheel the hard way. FORD already worked these details out for you.
Trending Topics
I have dealt with crimp style and they are OK IMO for interior electrical...they are still subject to moister even with electrical tape (which always comes apart) which is why I don't like them in my engine bay.
I know of the tool you speak of. I did aquire one from a shop via "loan a tool" when I did my old truck....considering the age at the time the threads didn't budge, then I went to the trusty recip saw to finish the job. Hopefully I won't have to do this to my 02.
Last edited by xtrford; Oct 31, 2007 at 09:02 AM.
Ford Trucks for Ford Truck Enthusiasts
the threads didn't budge, then I went to the trusty ricipro saw to finish the job
Readers should also think twice before adopting the "overkill" "peace of mind" method of using "the trusty ricipro saw" to remove a fan clutch!
I am going to do it my way and it seems to burn you somewhat...in the end what do you care?
Many 4x4 guys have used those relays I speak off, they are simply an electronic switch and CAN handle a continuous load of 30 amps, it is very simular to a starter solenoid except you can run a continuous load from them. I have done several wiring jobs and I think am more than capable of takling another e-fan job....and i did it without your haynes bible you so hold high in praise.
So take your own advise simply don't do it the way I am......I never told anyone to do things my way at all. Don't turn this into another thread where you are having another PMS trip and need to vent on FTE.
Last edited by xtrford; Oct 31, 2007 at 10:14 AM.
Now your "generic starter relays" have become "very simular to a starter solenoid"? Aren't all relays "simular"? A solenoid is not "simply an electronic switch" they use an electromagnet to do work-not neccessarily close a switch-that's what a relay does. So far as I can tell, what you deemed my "haynes bible" offers nothing whatsoever on converting to e-fans or substituting anything "simular to a starter solenoid" for anything else. Funny, that you referred to "hanyes" yourself & I suggested that you study the Taurus to reveal the fan's amperage-I don't know or care-you posted your confusion-only tried to help! Starter relays are made for intermittent use-not continuous use, they would very likely overheat during extended use required of e-fans & fail. It is not a question of them being able to handle the piddling amperage of an e-fan, they're made to operate for seconds at a time, rarely even a minute. FORD has a remote mounted, heat sinked, starter relay to help keep cool even in this short use. FORD also uses a starter mounted solenoid, which is an electromagnet that engages the starter gear to spin the ring gear. You'd be wise to lay off the insults, learn the difference between a relay & solenoid, then concentrate on the topic. If you're insulted that anyone might question aspects of your posts you need to grow some thicker hide.
My main purpose for posting was to warn naive members reading this thread that "soldering all conects" was no guarantee against short circuits, solderless crimp connectors have been universally accepted under the hood for decades & attempting to "solder all conects" could lead to problems from melted plastic components.
You seem to be the one suffering "PMS" perennially. I'm merely debunking some of what others might've considered "advise" in your posts. However, by all means stay & "vent on FTE" whenever you like. Some of your ideas are amusing, like using your "trusty ricipro saw" to remove a fan clutch after you failed using the special tools. I'll reserve judging your personality here & continue to post on the topics.
Also, you will find your peticular fan assembly to be pretty current intensive for starting current. Usually 2 times running current. So choose relay capacity accordingly and fuse/ wire size accordingly.
Good idea is to check out the original application controller for what was used and dup it as best you can.
Good luck.
The original controller for this fan was through the pcm of the car where it took it's readings from a sensor. That unfortunatley leaves me to seek aftermarket efan controllers which might lead to experiment from brand to brand, sometimes a the price you pay for doing a mod on a truck.
After everything is said and done I will post any problems I run into. The one thing I can see giving me the most problems is adapting the fan to my shroud. If anyone else other than Clubwagon (first on my official ignore list) have done this before, some help would be appreciated.
I also concur that the starter relay is sunject to heat in extended use. even at that low current. Your 50 amp bosch units are more than adequate. 40 amp is acceptable and 30 would work fine. The fan shoud be around 27 amp running max. hwy or hood open will reduce that. most fans are less than 22 continuos. 10g wire is also about right.
Another thought. If this system where to pull the amperage discussed in this thread, you want to increase the altenator capacity. Adding an e-fan is actually putting the system close to max with all accessories on. Should not be a problem for you. Usually a southern heat with AC issue. Just be aware.
Can't give you a best brand for a controller. I build my own cause the aftermaket ones are too sensitive, limited in adjustments. $$$ for multiple controls etc... But it has been a while since I messed with them.
You may need to add a blocking diode to your list of parts. Depending on your design. One circuit will trigger the other.
Curious about your mounting plans for the fan. Be cautious about strapping to the radiator thru the fins. this will guarantee a short life for the rad.
Just as a note. I live in Kansas and will be removing my fan shortly for the winter. 98 f150 5.4. I pull the shroud and keep the fan in the bed so I can spin it on easliy. Someday I plan to convert this one to e-fans. But for winter I just don't need the fan except on those warmer days with traffic. temps in the 30s the truck only pulls 150 deg below 50. hwy will creep up to 180. So I have to remove it to get a decent heater. Oh, this was a Nevada truck so has all the heafty cooling. In short, you will really like your fans for winter heat.
Good luck.
Everything is going to be fused at a lower amperage, probably around 50 for direct current from the battery and about 20 for the switching. If everything works fine and i don't get fuses blowing I will consider going to the bosch relays.
Does the diode drain the power produced from the fan spinning freely from air flowing through the rad?





