5.4 vs. 4.6
Thread Starter
|
Senior User
Joined: Apr 2000
Posts: 128
Likes: 0
5.4 vs. 4.6
I want to make it clear that I am not in the market for a new truck now and these questions are purely for interest sake. First, why doesn't Ford offer a manual transmission with the 5.4 in the F150? Second, how does a 5.4 w/ auto compare power-wise to a 4.6 w/ manual? And third, do the autos with 5.4s seem to be holding up pretty well?
Postmaster
Joined: Jun 1999
Posts: 2,719
Likes: 1
From: Lee's Summit MO
5.4 vs. 4.6
>I want to make it clear
>that I am not in
>the market for a new
>truck now and these questions
>are purely for interest sake.
> First, why doesn't Ford
>offer a manual transmission with
>the 5.4 in the F150?
Good question, Ford didn't ever offer a 5.8L with a manual in the previous F-150's. It possibly has something to do with how they would sale.
> Second, how does a
>5.4 w/ auto compare power-wise
>to a 4.6 w/ manual?
AS far as power goes, I honestly think the 4.6L is a little faster off the line with a manual than a 5.4L with a auto.
> And third, do the
>autos with 5.4s seem to
>be holding up pretty well?
>
Ford offered the E40d and a revised E40d-called the 4R100. From what I can tell, and know, no one is having a problem with any yet.
Pastmaster's 1993 XLT 5.0 E40d 3.55LS Normal Cab/Long bed Loaded from the factory with aid of...MSd 6a ign/s.p. wires, blaster coil, Hypertech Chip, K&N filtercharger, Cat-back dual exhuast w/o mufflers, 3.5", echo tips, Accel distributor cap, Dark Mocha over light mocha. 5% Dark tint, Alpine Cd player/remote, Pioneer speakers.
toydestroyer1(No Email Addresses In Posts!)
>that I am not in
>the market for a new
>truck now and these questions
>are purely for interest sake.
> First, why doesn't Ford
>offer a manual transmission with
>the 5.4 in the F150?
Good question, Ford didn't ever offer a 5.8L with a manual in the previous F-150's. It possibly has something to do with how they would sale.
> Second, how does a
>5.4 w/ auto compare power-wise
>to a 4.6 w/ manual?
AS far as power goes, I honestly think the 4.6L is a little faster off the line with a manual than a 5.4L with a auto.
> And third, do the
>autos with 5.4s seem to
>be holding up pretty well?
>
Ford offered the E40d and a revised E40d-called the 4R100. From what I can tell, and know, no one is having a problem with any yet.
Pastmaster's 1993 XLT 5.0 E40d 3.55LS Normal Cab/Long bed Loaded from the factory with aid of...MSd 6a ign/s.p. wires, blaster coil, Hypertech Chip, K&N filtercharger, Cat-back dual exhuast w/o mufflers, 3.5", echo tips, Accel distributor cap, Dark Mocha over light mocha. 5% Dark tint, Alpine Cd player/remote, Pioneer speakers.
toydestroyer1(No Email Addresses In Posts!)
New User
Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 15
Likes: 0
5.4 vs. 4.6
I found a great looking F-150 XLT the has a 4.6L. Do you think I should get it or get a stock F-150 XLT with a 5.4L?? I have heard that if you put a Holley Thunder supercharger on a 97'-00' F-150 the horsepower would be 30 over a stock Lightning. So whats your opinion??? The Fast or the one that looks REALLY fast but has a 4.6L???
You can e-mail me at wadegotleid@netscape.net if you want to.
You can e-mail me at wadegotleid@netscape.net if you want to.
Elder User
Joined: Nov 2000
Posts: 520
Likes: 0
5.4 vs. 4.6
New Lightning HP is at 380....the F-150 with stock 5.4L Triton is rated at 260 HP, and the best superchargers add max 100 HP, typically more like 80-90 HP, so you're looking at max, very max with just supercharger 360, which is what the 2000 Lightnings are rated at, and now 2001/2 is at 380. I feel Eaton is the best supercharger out there (which the lightning uses). But the Lightning uses more than just a supercharger, so I don't see how you could get close to it with just the supercharger. Plus mose Lightning owners add stuff on after the fact to boost even more HP such as Airaid kits, new chips, etc, and many have their trucks at or above 400 HP.
New User
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 4
Likes: 0
5.4 vs. 4.6
I have a 97 f150 with a 4.6 in it. The engine is getting old and I am thinking about putting a replacement engine in it. My question is this, will a 5.4 fit in instead of a 4.6? Any suggestions on where to locate replacement engines?
Posting Guru
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 1,673
Likes: 0
From: Chicago Area
5.4 vs. 4.6
I believe the 5.4 will fit. The two are basicly the same; looking at the specs it seems that the only difference is in the crankshaft (longer stroke), and the cam (higher lift).
However, these days there are so many variations in controls, etc., that you take a major chance of a problem if you don't do things exactly the same. I certainly would not do this without the help of someone who has successfully done it before.
MrBSS
However, these days there are so many variations in controls, etc., that you take a major chance of a problem if you don't do things exactly the same. I certainly would not do this without the help of someone who has successfully done it before.
MrBSS
