Duramax
Thread Starter
|
New User
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 17
Likes: 0
Duramax
I will admit it I am a CTW (Certified Technical Wennie) but I thought I would add my ruminations about the new Duramax vs. PSD. I studied the issue some and along with some fellow CTW's we have concluded:
It makes little sense to have aluminum (AL) heads given that: AL expands at a different rate then iron (techincally speaking they have different coefficients of thermal expansion) maybe that is why they have that special head gasket, a sandwitch of ceramic material and tradiditional material. The heads are under a lot of stress both mechcanical and thermal and AL has a elastic limit based upon the number of times it expands and contracts. Iron does not such a limit. Maybe that is why GM says the design life is 200,000 miles while Navistar says the PSD has a design life of 300,000 miles. There is no way to get around the elastic limit problem by adding metal or increasing the number of bolts.
What kind of heads do the bid trucks have? Iron
It is interesting to note that GM says the AL heads reduce weight and provide for increased cooloing. Guys this is a HD truck why be concerned about an additional 49 lbs and diesels like it hot.
Early tests say that the Duramax walks away from the PSD pulling a load. OK but lets run that test at 150,000 miles on the engine.
Finally (know everyone is glad to hear that word) GM claims that they tested the Duramax extensively (1,000,000 miles) prior to production. How many road miles are on the PSDs? New and improved is nice but it usually is the enemy of good enough.
It is interesting that GM chose Izuzu over other world class deisel producers like Cummins, CAT, Volvo, Benz, Mack. Or could it be they chose Izuzu because they own 40% of the stock!!
It makes little sense to have aluminum (AL) heads given that: AL expands at a different rate then iron (techincally speaking they have different coefficients of thermal expansion) maybe that is why they have that special head gasket, a sandwitch of ceramic material and tradiditional material. The heads are under a lot of stress both mechcanical and thermal and AL has a elastic limit based upon the number of times it expands and contracts. Iron does not such a limit. Maybe that is why GM says the design life is 200,000 miles while Navistar says the PSD has a design life of 300,000 miles. There is no way to get around the elastic limit problem by adding metal or increasing the number of bolts.
What kind of heads do the bid trucks have? Iron
It is interesting to note that GM says the AL heads reduce weight and provide for increased cooloing. Guys this is a HD truck why be concerned about an additional 49 lbs and diesels like it hot.
Early tests say that the Duramax walks away from the PSD pulling a load. OK but lets run that test at 150,000 miles on the engine.
Finally (know everyone is glad to hear that word) GM claims that they tested the Duramax extensively (1,000,000 miles) prior to production. How many road miles are on the PSDs? New and improved is nice but it usually is the enemy of good enough.
It is interesting that GM chose Izuzu over other world class deisel producers like Cummins, CAT, Volvo, Benz, Mack. Or could it be they chose Izuzu because they own 40% of the stock!!
New User
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 17
Likes: 0
Duramax
Isuzu is actually one of the most prolific producers of diesel-engines in the world. They are used extensively in heavy industry, power-plants, and other high hour critical applications. I didn't believe it myself, until I researched it.
I think truck-trend magazine summed it up the best when they described posters of the Duramax engine at the Navistar plant where the power-stroke is produced. Under the picture is a slogan that says "Who we have to beat.". Obviously, if International takes the Duramax threat seriously, I don't think the aluminum heads have them scoffing.
I think truck-trend magazine summed it up the best when they described posters of the Duramax engine at the Navistar plant where the power-stroke is produced. Under the picture is a slogan that says "Who we have to beat.". Obviously, if International takes the Duramax threat seriously, I don't think the aluminum heads have them scoffing.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
parkland
1999 - 2003 7.3L Power Stroke Diesel
473
Nov 7, 2008 11:42 AM
mtomac
Ford vs The Competition
23
Jan 20, 2005 11:16 PM
