Opinions on K&N air filters
#2
There are mixed opinions about K&N air filters on FTE.
Here is my personal opinion on K&N air filters:
I believe that K&N air filters are way over priced! There is NO performance increase in most applications, and there is only a
slight performance increase, if any, with large displacement engines (>400CI) at WOT!!!
The problem with K&N air filters is with the amount of dirt that they pass into the engine. K&N air filters were originally developed for very dusty races like Baja, where the OEM paper
filters would plug up!! The K&Ns would not plug up, same amount
of dirt going into the filter, guess where the dirt goes? You can
verify this with a simple test of holding a K&N up to a light source, and look at the size of the holes in the filter media, compared to a
paper filter. The dirt that an engine ingests with a K&N air filter has been confirmed with UOA tests, showing high levels of silicon
which comes from dirt!! Cummins has issued a statement, and are explicit in saying engine damage can result from the dirt that the K&N air filter passes into the engine.
And last, you bring up a good point, about the possibility of MAF sensor contamination from oil with the K&N air filter.
So, after all of that, I recommend you stay with the OEM paper filter, and change it regularly!!!
Here is my personal opinion on K&N air filters:
I believe that K&N air filters are way over priced! There is NO performance increase in most applications, and there is only a
slight performance increase, if any, with large displacement engines (>400CI) at WOT!!!
The problem with K&N air filters is with the amount of dirt that they pass into the engine. K&N air filters were originally developed for very dusty races like Baja, where the OEM paper
filters would plug up!! The K&Ns would not plug up, same amount
of dirt going into the filter, guess where the dirt goes? You can
verify this with a simple test of holding a K&N up to a light source, and look at the size of the holes in the filter media, compared to a
paper filter. The dirt that an engine ingests with a K&N air filter has been confirmed with UOA tests, showing high levels of silicon
which comes from dirt!! Cummins has issued a statement, and are explicit in saying engine damage can result from the dirt that the K&N air filter passes into the engine.
And last, you bring up a good point, about the possibility of MAF sensor contamination from oil with the K&N air filter.
So, after all of that, I recommend you stay with the OEM paper filter, and change it regularly!!!
#3
I have changed to K&N in two of my cars including my '97 Aerostar 3.0. I've seen mixed remarks about the performance aspect of the K&N's but with the Cummins statement and the passage of all that dirt, I'm switching back to paper.
I recently owned a Taurus Sho which I had installed a cone type K&N filter charger that picked up air inside the covering of the fender well. The car sounded great and was very fast. But when I changed the oil after 6-7000 miles I could not believe how BLACK it was! Now I have reason to doubt the K&N.
Thanks Bob,
Beaned
I recently owned a Taurus Sho which I had installed a cone type K&N filter charger that picked up air inside the covering of the fender well. The car sounded great and was very fast. But when I changed the oil after 6-7000 miles I could not believe how BLACK it was! Now I have reason to doubt the K&N.
Thanks Bob,
Beaned
#4
#5
You are right, that is a long span. I usually change every 3-4000 miles. I just remember on that particular time the oil was blacker than any time, on any of the 30 or so cars i have owned the past 40 years. Maybe it means nothing. This kind of thing is a gray [not black] area when you have so many pros and cons going on.
Thanks, Beaned
Thanks, Beaned
#6
Check out this thread from awhile back. It looks like the
"dirty oil" syndrome has been experienced by several people
using K&N air filters:
https://www.ford-trucks.com/forums/s...hreadid=198260
"dirty oil" syndrome has been experienced by several people
using K&N air filters:
https://www.ford-trucks.com/forums/s...hreadid=198260
#7
Trending Topics
#8
K&N filters will only provide a benefit if that is your engine bottleneck. If you aren't outflowing a clean stocker, than you won't need it. If you are, then it will net you a gain. I have one on my other car, but it's blown and sucking immense amounts of air in, far too much for a normal paper filter.