Payload rating for towing - Thought experiment
#16
In mind as I say this: Almost nobody gets to the theoretical "full" mark in these. They are a few hundred pounds below or above, but never right on it. The ones that are below will have a hundred pounds more truck to influence the trailer. The ones that are above probably don't notice that they have a hundred pounds more truck to influence the trailer.
Either way, the base truck is X pounds and the optioned truck is X+~100 pounds so not a huge difference anyways. An 8,000-pound XLT CC LB is probably 8,100 pounds when it turns into a Lariat so we're talking 1.25% weight increase. In the F150 range it would be more like a 5,200 pound versus a 5,400 pound CC LB so 3.8% difference. Both seem like negligible differences that most drivers wouldn't notice.
That having been said, when I emergency-stop 1" from whatever I almost hit, I'm going to think "glad this thing didn't weigh any less than it did, that extra traction probably saved me" . . . then . . . "I wonder if it would have had 2" to spare if it had weighed a bit less?"
#17
#18
Join Date: Oct 2015
Location: Somewhere south of Denver
Posts: 18,925
Received 7,149 Likes
on
2,856 Posts
400 lbs does seem a bit much. If I had known it was 400 lbs and leaving it off the build of a Lariat Ultimate was an option (it wasn't in 2017), then yes, I probably would have.
#19
#20
As the name implies the heavy duty payload package is to maximize the GVWR of the truck and the Max tow package is to maximize the GCWR/ TWR of the truck.
#21
HTH,
Jim / crewzer
#22
Hmm, the 400 didn't sound right, but that 64 lbs sounds suspiciously low too. Oh well, I guess a) there's no simple way for me to test this and b) it doesn't really matter.
#23
Now I'm not saying anyone should be towing at 100% max of any trucks trailer ratings. I sure wouldn't. But it's an interesting discussion.
#24
I know it isn't 400, that wold bring my lariat to almost 2000lb payload capacity, which would be nice!!
#25
That makes sense, but for most people using a half-ton truck, there's no way to reach maximum trailer weight without exceeding payload rating. Family of 4 plus a little gear in the bed is easily 800lbs, plus tongue weight of a 12,000lbs trailer (13%) = 1560 lbs = 2360lbs payload, which is higher than the payload rating of the max tow NON HDPP supercrew trucks.
Now I'm not saying anyone should be towing at 100% max of any trucks trailer ratings. I sure wouldn't. But it's an interesting discussion.
Now I'm not saying anyone should be towing at 100% max of any trucks trailer ratings. I sure wouldn't. But it's an interesting discussion.
#26
And many people who tow without four people and and gear in the bed, sure that's that's true as well. I agree. Although, I think for the "average" half ton buyer, most of them are towing travel trailers and bringing family with them.
#27
Payload rating aside, manufacturers should provide some type of guideline to derate maximum tongue weight and TWR based on the less than ideal 10% tongue weight. Example for every 1% of tongue weight above 10% reduce maximum tongue weight rating by 100lbs which will reduce maximum trailer weight as well. Let’s say the 10% rating on a truck is 1200/12,000 the 13% rating would be 900/6925.
#28
Payload rating aside, manufacturers should provide some type of guideline to derate maximum tongue weight and TWR based on the less than ideal 10% tongue weight. Example for every 1% of tongue weight above 10% reduce maximum tongue weight rating by 100lbs which will reduce maximum trailer weight as well. Let’s say the 10% rating on a truck is 1200/12,000 the 13% rating would be 900/6925.
#29
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
carolinaborn82
Conventional (Bumper Pull) Towing; Travel Trailers & Pop-ups
22
08-08-2012 01:50 PM