Do rotors really matter?
Thread Starter
|
Elder User
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 974
Likes: 11
Do rotors really matter?
I can totally see how various brake pads could affect braking performance. Different materials - organic, ceramic, metallic - have different coefficients of friction. But isn't a rotor a rotor? Just a piece of machined steel?
Has anyone on here really, honestly, observed any significant difference from one rotor to another?
Just curious.
Has anyone on here really, honestly, observed any significant difference from one rotor to another?
Just curious.
Hotshot
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 12,353
Likes: 4,388
From: SW VA
If the rotor is drilled or slotted, I can see it performing better than a standard solid rotor...however with solid rotors, I think the big difference would be the thickness/weight and the layout of the cooling fins. A thicker rotor would act as a larger heat sink, with more resistance to warping. Thinner rotors will cool off quicker, but are more prone to warp.
I'm no expert however...but I've noticed big differences changing pads, but never much of a difference changing rotors.
I'm no expert however...but I've noticed big differences changing pads, but never much of a difference changing rotors.
Lead Driver
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 8,477
Likes: 4,972
I can totally see how various brake pads could affect braking performance. Different materials - organic, ceramic, metallic - have different coefficients of friction. But isn't a rotor a rotor? Just a piece of machined steel?
Has anyone on here really, honestly, observed any significant difference from one rotor to another?
Just curious.
Has anyone on here really, honestly, observed any significant difference from one rotor to another?
Just curious.
Also, just FYI, your average rotor is cast iron, not steel.
Moderator
Joined: Jul 2011
Posts: 6,513
Likes: 669
From: Sioux Falls Area
i've had better luck with rotors since i started buying them at NAPA.
thier cooling vane designs are much better and the surfaces are much thicker.
best part is they are the same cost, or sometimes less than the repackaged UBC garbage all the other chains are selling.
if it is a house brand at a big store, it is most likely made by UBC and relabeled as the house brand.... check into it and you will see.
thier cooling vane designs are much better and the surfaces are much thicker.
best part is they are the same cost, or sometimes less than the repackaged UBC garbage all the other chains are selling.
if it is a house brand at a big store, it is most likely made by UBC and relabeled as the house brand.... check into it and you will see.
Post Fiend
Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 6,801
Likes: 7
From: DFW, TX-GoldCanyon, AZ
I can totally see how various brake pads could affect braking performance. Different materials - organic, ceramic, metallic - have different coefficients of friction. But isn't a rotor a rotor? Just a piece of machined steel?
Has anyone on here really, honestly, observed any significant difference from one rotor to another?
Just curious.
Has anyone on here really, honestly, observed any significant difference from one rotor to another?
Just curious.
Suffice to say - I beleive that you get what you pay for.. OEM rotors are typically some of the best quality available but you pay the price for that..
Thread Starter
|
Elder User
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 974
Likes: 11
Thanks for the replies all.
Yes, I mis-spoke when I said rotors are pieces of steel. I knew they are, in fact, iron. It was late at the end of a long day when I posted the thread. My mistake, but good to know there are plenty of good folks on here to correct the mistake!
So based on the replies so far, it's safe to say that "better" rotors are only/primarily better in their resistance to warping. And NOT for their stopping abilities. That makes sense to me.
Yes, I mis-spoke when I said rotors are pieces of steel. I knew they are, in fact, iron. It was late at the end of a long day when I posted the thread. My mistake, but good to know there are plenty of good folks on here to correct the mistake!
So based on the replies so far, it's safe to say that "better" rotors are only/primarily better in their resistance to warping. And NOT for their stopping abilities. That makes sense to me.
Tuned
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 325
Likes: 27
From: Charlottesville VA
I did a lot of research and ended up mailordering OEM ford rotors. I think from TASCA. Big mistake- they showed up and were for 10 lugs, not 8. I had to have them send me shipping labels to return... PITA. At least they paid for it. Since the truck was already apart I ran down to NAPA and picked up rotors from them. They work just fine and were cheaper.
There are at least 3 grades of brake quality at the auto parts store. I always ask for the "best you got" when it comes to brakes.
For pads, I went with EBC yellow stuff. They bite really well, but they put off an amazing amount of dust. My wheels go black in a month. Easily washes off though. Next time I'll sacrifice a little stopping and use the green stuff.
There are at least 3 grades of brake quality at the auto parts store. I always ask for the "best you got" when it comes to brakes.
For pads, I went with EBC yellow stuff. They bite really well, but they put off an amazing amount of dust. My wheels go black in a month. Easily washes off though. Next time I'll sacrifice a little stopping and use the green stuff.
Trending Topics
Post Fiend
Joined: Jun 2014
Posts: 6,801
Likes: 7
From: DFW, TX-GoldCanyon, AZ
I think you have it... It's the conversion of energy that has to happen here.. You have to take the rotational intertia of the wheels - motivated by the weight and momentum of the vehicle, and change that energy into heat. It's the ability to absorb and shed that heat which differentiates POOR-GOOD-BETTER-BEST....
There are some great designs in rotors out there and there are poor ones.. I feel the better designs are the rotors with directional vents and relatively thick friction surfaces... The drilled rotors (holes) are mostly for show these days as most pad materials do not out-gas as those of the 60's-80's once did.. Slotted rotors are also coming into question in terms of their effectiveness.. Still there are manufacturers who will make them and/or use them, because they have a demand from a largely fact-ignorant customer base. Note that ignorance does not imply any degree of stupidity - just points out that we are all capable of ignorance when we have not learned the true facts..
There are some great designs in rotors out there and there are poor ones.. I feel the better designs are the rotors with directional vents and relatively thick friction surfaces... The drilled rotors (holes) are mostly for show these days as most pad materials do not out-gas as those of the 60's-80's once did.. Slotted rotors are also coming into question in terms of their effectiveness.. Still there are manufacturers who will make them and/or use them, because they have a demand from a largely fact-ignorant customer base. Note that ignorance does not imply any degree of stupidity - just points out that we are all capable of ignorance when we have not learned the true facts..
FTE Stories
Ford Trucks for Ford Truck Enthusiasts
Top 10 Fords at 2026 Carlisle Ford Nationals
Joe Kucinski
3 Best / 3 Worst Parts of Modern Ford Ownership
Brett Foote
10 Amazing Upgrades That Solve Common Ford Truck Owner Headaches
Pouria Savadkouei
Every 2026 Ford Engine Explained
Brett Foote
10 Ugly Ford Trucks That We Still Kinda Love
Joe Kucinski
10 Things Every Truck Owner NEEDS (2026 Edition)
Michael S. Palmer
Rezvani's Latest Post-Apocalyptic Monster Is a Ford F-150 Raptor Underneath
Verdad Gallardo
Top 10 Most Expensive Ford Trucks Ever Sold on Bring a Trailer
Joe Kucinski
2027 Ford Super Duty Buyer's Guide (Every Model, Engine, & Package)
Brett Foote
Thread Starter
|
Elder User
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 974
Likes: 11
Not me. I'll GLADLY spend the time to wash the wheels of brake dust in exchange for being able to stop my truck (and my family inside) in as short of distance as possible.
Fleet Mechanic
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 1,800
Likes: 52
From: Southern Colorado
I have used 'cheap Chinese rotors' on many vehicles (including the F350) for many years with no issues. I also am nice to my brakes, plan ahead, and downshift, etc. to avoid getting the brakes blazing hot.
The way I see most people drive (aggressively, with big tires), I'm not surprised that they are constantly replacing brake parts. These are mostly Dodge drivers, however ;-)
The way I see most people drive (aggressively, with big tires), I'm not surprised that they are constantly replacing brake parts. These are mostly Dodge drivers, however ;-)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Travis O'Connor
Excursion - King of SUVs
19
Sep 21, 2015 03:12 PM