RELAY PROBLEM PLEASE HELP.
#16
No blown fuses
#17
Bottom line, relays fail. There is no deadline or lifespan on them. And hey, the relay is somewhere around $10. Go buy a new one and put it in, then tear the old one apart to see what failed.
Some of the small ice cube relays that I've worked with manufacturers say they "expect" a million operations.
These automotive relays are cheap enough that anybody should have one in their toolbax as a spare, so you might buy two.
Some of the small ice cube relays that I've worked with manufacturers say they "expect" a million operations.
These automotive relays are cheap enough that anybody should have one in their toolbax as a spare, so you might buy two.
#18
True story most would be a Costco battery spuing acid , then washing the battery with baking soda or even better pepsi, I would add a little dio grease and make sure all the contacts are clean.
#19
#20
Actually what happens, in most cases, is the relay does not fail, the contact points inside the relay become pitted or fouled. I have taken several of them apart and cleaned the contacts. Over time a black residue builds up on the contacts. If it is a high current relay, the internal contacts are normally pitted. You have two options: disassemble and clean or replace the relay. The relay that first failed on me and lead me to check the others was the "time delay" relay for the internal lights, radio, running board lights, etc.. Internal lights stayed on all the time.
Ed
Ed
#21
Actually what happens, in most cases, is the relay does not fail, the contact points inside the relay become pitted or fouled. I have taken several of them apart and cleaned the contacts. Over time a black residue builds up on the contacts. If it is a high current relay, the internal contacts are normally pitted. You have two options: disassemble and clean or replace the relay. The relay that first failed on me and lead me to check the others was the "time delay" relay for the internal lights, radio, running board lights, etc.. Internal lights stayed on all the time.
Ed
Ed
tossed into the trash.
Sean
#22
#23
#24
Ed
#25
Not trying to be a smart *** here, but do you throw away a car just because it runs out of fuel? No, you do a failure analysis to find out if it was stupidity, fuel pump, leaking fuel line, etc. That is all I did on the relays and found that I could repair them vice buying new ones or keeping them as spares or as you suggested being stuck out in the boonies. When something breaks, I basically do a failure analysis on everything, except women!
Ed
Ed
If you have a failed relay and band aid fix something, whose to say other components didn't get stressed in its failure process.
To cheap out on a relay could possibly leave you stranded on the side of the road, maybe on a vacation. Also, it could start clattering and take out a $1000 FICM or what ever its controlling. The coil could cause extra load on the system
Like I said, taking it apart just to see how it works or what exactly failed is one thing. Trying to fix one, is begging for a break down.
#26
Not trying to be a smart *** here, but do you throw away a car just because it runs out of fuel? No, you do a failure analysis to find out if it was stupidity, fuel pump, leaking fuel line, etc. That is all I did on the relays and found that I could repair them vice buying new ones or keeping them as spares or as you suggested being stuck out in the boonies. When something breaks, I basically do a failure analysis on everything, except women!
Ed
Ed
#27
If you recall my background. Aviation.
You don't dress relay contacts unless you can't get a replacement
and the relay was designed for the contacts to be dressed.
Once you take a dressing file to them you remove some of the
contact and lessen it ability to transfer any heat. Heat is one of
the reasons they fail. They spark and make ozone and deposits
that increase the resistance of the contact that in turn creates heat.
Big circle.
My time is worth more than a $15 relay. They come out and go
into the trash can. If I do take one apart it's with a hammer.
To me it not worth the time or the risk to fix one. Do you think your FICM
would like fluctuating voltage from a relay that is chattering?
Sean
You don't dress relay contacts unless you can't get a replacement
and the relay was designed for the contacts to be dressed.
Once you take a dressing file to them you remove some of the
contact and lessen it ability to transfer any heat. Heat is one of
the reasons they fail. They spark and make ozone and deposits
that increase the resistance of the contact that in turn creates heat.
Big circle.
My time is worth more than a $15 relay. They come out and go
into the trash can. If I do take one apart it's with a hammer.
To me it not worth the time or the risk to fix one. Do you think your FICM
would like fluctuating voltage from a relay that is chattering?
Sean
#28
My manual says ones the blower and one is the other. I know it was the blower bcus when I switched the relays, my ac wouldn't blow anymore.
#29
If you recall my background. Aviation.
You don't dress relay contacts unless you can't get a replacement
and the relay was designed for the contacts to be dressed.
Once you take a dressing file to them you remove some of the
contact and lessen it ability to transfer any heat. Heat is one of
the reasons they fail. They spark and make ozone and deposits
that increase the resistance of the contact that in turn creates heat.
Big circle.
My time is worth more than a $15 relay. They come out and go
into the trash can. If I do take one apart it's with a hammer.
To me it not worth the time or the risk to fix one. Do you think your FICM
would like fluctuating voltage from a relay that is chattering?
Sean
You don't dress relay contacts unless you can't get a replacement
and the relay was designed for the contacts to be dressed.
Once you take a dressing file to them you remove some of the
contact and lessen it ability to transfer any heat. Heat is one of
the reasons they fail. They spark and make ozone and deposits
that increase the resistance of the contact that in turn creates heat.
Big circle.
My time is worth more than a $15 relay. They come out and go
into the trash can. If I do take one apart it's with a hammer.
To me it not worth the time or the risk to fix one. Do you think your FICM
would like fluctuating voltage from a relay that is chattering?
Sean
I was repairing a CCRM for my nephew's 1993 car. I opened it up and found a bad relay. The coil was open. I triple checked that thing twice, and I was convinced it was open. I de-soldered it and replaced it with a similar relay. After the bad relay was out and sitting on the bench I checked it just for the heck of it, don't you know it had 80 ohms across the coil. It must have been the heat form the solder iron, and messing with the pins. Now, should I trust that relay?
.
#30
Real true story,
I was repairing a CCRM for my nephew's 1993 car. I opened it up and found a bad relay. The coil was open. I triple checked that thing twice, and I was convinced it was open. I de-soldered it and replaced it with a similar relay. After the bad relay was out and sitting on the bench I checked it just for the heck of it, don't you know it had 80 ohms across the coil. It must have been the heat form the solder iron, and messing with the pins. Now, should I trust that relay?
.
I was repairing a CCRM for my nephew's 1993 car. I opened it up and found a bad relay. The coil was open. I triple checked that thing twice, and I was convinced it was open. I de-soldered it and replaced it with a similar relay. After the bad relay was out and sitting on the bench I checked it just for the heck of it, don't you know it had 80 ohms across the coil. It must have been the heat form the solder iron, and messing with the pins. Now, should I trust that relay?
.
It could also be in the coil it's self and will open when back under load.
When you have lived on the line and the FAA looking over your shoulder.
You don't cut corners. Would you want the mechanic that is working on
an ambulance to fix a relay and use it in a critical location like the FICM or
fuel pump only to have it fail on a run?
Sean
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Bigweasel
1987 - 1996 F150 & Larger F-Series Trucks
2
08-19-2017 09:31 AM
aloevera
1999 to 2016 Super Duty
0
01-16-2017 11:57 AM
quality job 1
1980 - 1986 Bullnose F100, F150 & Larger F-Series Trucks
13
05-03-2010 09:46 PM