Edge vs Escape
Thread Starter
|
Junior User
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts: 78
Likes: 0
From: Houston
Edge vs Escape
I posted this under Edge but want to hear from the Escape owner, also.
Consumer Reports gives higher marks for the Escape than the Edge but both are lower than the competition. The Edge is given low marks for reliability but I have not seen any consumers expression a common problem other than with MFT and the CR history gives good marks for the last 3 years. Are the maintenance and resale value really that bad?
Which to pick? The cargo room is nearly the same although the Edge looks bigger. The Edge is heavier with a V6 better for towing and I would expect ride better and be better in snow and mountainous driving.
While the mpg of the competition 4 banger's is a big plus, they are noisy and probably not as comfortable on cross country trips, especially through mountains. The Explorer appears to have mixed views and also, given low marks by CR and it's a little larger than I really need but haven't completely discounted it.
I'm looking for the best fit 5-7 passenger for long drives, camping, and mountains. MPG is a big factor but I want power to get up mountains and around pokes.
Let me hear your side.
Consumer Reports gives higher marks for the Escape than the Edge but both are lower than the competition. The Edge is given low marks for reliability but I have not seen any consumers expression a common problem other than with MFT and the CR history gives good marks for the last 3 years. Are the maintenance and resale value really that bad?
Which to pick? The cargo room is nearly the same although the Edge looks bigger. The Edge is heavier with a V6 better for towing and I would expect ride better and be better in snow and mountainous driving.
While the mpg of the competition 4 banger's is a big plus, they are noisy and probably not as comfortable on cross country trips, especially through mountains. The Explorer appears to have mixed views and also, given low marks by CR and it's a little larger than I really need but haven't completely discounted it.
I'm looking for the best fit 5-7 passenger for long drives, camping, and mountains. MPG is a big factor but I want power to get up mountains and around pokes.
Let me hear your side.
Logistics Pro
Joined: Jan 2002
Posts: 4,907
Likes: 39
From: suburban atlanta
Unless your passengers have been on a diet, 5-7 people aren't going to fit into an Escape, and likely not into an Edge. The Escape has 5 seat belts, ergo, 5 passenger. The Edge, I think, is the same. I think the Escape has more room, but don't know if it will seat 7 either.
If you want some size, with even decent mpg, take a look at the Flex. They have room, and actually are better on mpg than the Escape. How? I don't have a clue, except their engine is .5l larger, and may be geared for longer legs???
tom
If you want some size, with even decent mpg, take a look at the Flex. They have room, and actually are better on mpg than the Escape. How? I don't have a clue, except their engine is .5l larger, and may be geared for longer legs???
tom
Elder User
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 828
Likes: 0
I posted this under Edge but want to hear from the Escape owner, also.
Consumer Reports gives higher marks for the Escape than the Edge but both are lower than the competition. The Edge is given low marks for reliability but I have not seen any consumers expression a common problem other than with MFT and the CR history gives good marks for the last 3 years. Are the maintenance and resale value really that bad?
Which to pick? The cargo room is nearly the same although the Edge looks bigger. The Edge is heavier with a V6 better for towing and I would expect ride better and be better in snow and mountainous driving.
While the mpg of the competition 4 banger's is a big plus, they are noisy and probably not as comfortable on cross country trips, especially through mountains. The Explorer appears to have mixed views and also, given low marks by CR and it's a little larger than I really need but haven't completely discounted it.
I'm looking for the best fit 5-7 passenger for long drives, camping, and mountains. MPG is a big factor but I want power to get up mountains and around pokes.
Let me hear your side.
Consumer Reports gives higher marks for the Escape than the Edge but both are lower than the competition. The Edge is given low marks for reliability but I have not seen any consumers expression a common problem other than with MFT and the CR history gives good marks for the last 3 years. Are the maintenance and resale value really that bad?
Which to pick? The cargo room is nearly the same although the Edge looks bigger. The Edge is heavier with a V6 better for towing and I would expect ride better and be better in snow and mountainous driving.
While the mpg of the competition 4 banger's is a big plus, they are noisy and probably not as comfortable on cross country trips, especially through mountains. The Explorer appears to have mixed views and also, given low marks by CR and it's a little larger than I really need but haven't completely discounted it.
I'm looking for the best fit 5-7 passenger for long drives, camping, and mountains. MPG is a big factor but I want power to get up mountains and around pokes.
Let me hear your side.
Fleet Mechanic
Joined: Dec 2008
Posts: 1,909
Likes: 133
From: Burleson, Tx
The edge does have more back seat room but the mpg is horrible. We have the Tribute and my best friend has an Edge and we have used both to tow our two sport bikes from Dallas to Chicago and the edge gets about 4 less mpg but it is better ride.
Lead Driver
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 6,804
Likes: 703
From: Tobyhanma, PA
I agree that neither one of those vehicles are going to fit 7 people.
The flex is a nice option for more then 5 passengers. You will obviously need something with a third row.
As for the Escape vs Edge, I vote Escape for the ground clearance. Here in the mountains, ground clearance goes a long way in the winters.
The flex is a nice option for more then 5 passengers. You will obviously need something with a third row.
As for the Escape vs Edge, I vote Escape for the ground clearance. Here in the mountains, ground clearance goes a long way in the winters.
Elder User
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 629
Likes: 2
From: DFW Metromess, TX.
2008 Tribute/Escape
We have a four pot Tribute/Escape with auto. It does well on the highway, but loaded to maximum, that little engine is taxed. If most of your driving is unloaded, with only one or two aboard like us, it's great. We usually get over 30 mpg and have seen 33 a few times on the highway doing 80 mph. Usual duties are around town with an errand or two in mind. City driving with lots of stop and go it's getting about 22-23 mpg and is quite peppy. A buddy has and Edge, it is larger outside and inside. Seats 4 up very comfortably and the V-6 is a help when fully loaded, but not such a good buy for the additional $10K over what we paid for our SUV. MPG is somewhat less than the Tribute. Depends on your driving habits and needs I suppose.
No issues with our Tribute. Nothing on the later Edges either. Earlier examples had some minor recalls. That is all.
No issues with our Tribute. Nothing on the later Edges either. Earlier examples had some minor recalls. That is all.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
