6.0L Power Stroke Diesel 2003 - 2007 F250, F350 pickup and F350+ Cab Chassis, 2003 - 2005 Excursion and 2003 - 2009 van

6.0 - is failure inevitable?

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
  #16  
Old 09-20-2012, 07:18 PM
cheezit's Avatar
cheezit
cheezit is offline
Post Fiend

Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: N. Fort Worth, tx
Posts: 12,123
Likes: 0
Received 19 Likes on 19 Posts
Originally Posted by 69cj
You already started. "advice" LOL. Good luck my friend.
cheers. we all know I cant spell. ive gotten over it. move along nothing to see here.
 
  #17  
Old 09-20-2012, 07:23 PM
texastech_diesel's Avatar
texastech_diesel
texastech_diesel is offline
Token Redneck

Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: Breckenridge, TX
Posts: 9,102
Received 102 Likes on 55 Posts
Originally Posted by mschultz
If the STC fitting is just a matter of time before I am going to be stuck by the side of the road, I'll try to get rid of the truck again this fall.
You'd get rid of a vehicle over a $40 part and a day of wrenching on it yourself?
 
  #18  
Old 09-20-2012, 07:48 PM
cay5628's Avatar
cay5628
cay5628 is offline
Elder User
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Tucson area
Posts: 510
Received 7 Likes on 1 Post
To the OP (Mike), I can see your point exactly, there is some reluctance to keep it if it's gonna strand you (break down), In my case I chose the 6.0 specifically for many reasons, some being I like the engine, it does not use the DPF, yes it has a CAT (*thanks California), but has fewer parts (lower tech) that can go wrong and when/if they do, will cost far less to repair than a 6.4 or 6.7. Sure it does not make the power the others do, but it goes and goes and in my case has been trouble free except for dummy plug o rings.

With any vehicle we pay our money and take our chances, the old adage that you want to buy vehicles only manufactured on Tuesday through Thursday due to Mondays and Fridays being can't believe the weekend is over already (what a hangover Mondays) and can't wait to get out of there on Friday so I can party anecdote. Your point is valid and I hope the 6.0 in your truck proves you wrong and lasts for 400K or more with only quality regular maintenance. Personally I don't think it is inevitable, but then I'm not driving our truck! Getting off my soapbox again. Happy motoring!

-Mark
 
  #19  
Old 09-21-2012, 11:17 AM
BLADE35's Avatar
BLADE35
BLADE35 is offline
Hotshot
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Saratoga Springs,UT
Posts: 18,726
Received 78 Likes on 55 Posts
Originally Posted by texastech_diesel
You'd get rid of a vehicle over a $40 part and a day of wrenching on it yourself?

Now the Hit on buuying a Diffrent truck would be alot more than the cost of the repair in this case


Bryan I think some folks open the Hood and look at it and get alittle overwhelmed/Intimidated and thats understandable if they dont know what there looking at and the thought goes threw there mind where in the hell do I even start
 
  #20  
Old 09-21-2012, 02:30 PM
Bob2626's Avatar
Bob2626
Bob2626 is offline
Freshman User
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Silverdale WA
Posts: 48
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Remember that those who post here are here because they have a problem and those of us who do not post are just looking to see what the problems are.
Bob
 
  #21  
Old 09-21-2012, 03:08 PM
mlytc's Avatar
mlytc
mlytc is offline
Junior User
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: South MS
Posts: 81
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Originally Posted by lupuseven
nearly all 6.0 are extremely reliable as with any vehicle you treat it right it will treat you right. Just that the 6.0 is a bit more finicky then most. Unlike gassers where you can miss an oil change by 10k and it will run somewhat okay. 6.0 from what I have read and understand revolves around the oil with little tolerances for "dirt"

the 6.0 had its bad rep mainly in the beginning when people would put the wrong coolant in, which clogged oil coolers, in turn degraded the oil, which caused injectors and other catastrophic failures. As well as folks not keeping up with maintenance.

another bad rep came from folks putting tuners on the truck and not prepping the engine for the increased HP and torque. not to mention bad canned tunes.

People who have used ones like me just have to do a flush of everything, put the right fluids in. and with the exception of normal wear and tear are pretty much gtg.

head studs are not really mandatory until you put some serious strain on the motor which are usually caused by tuners.

Great truck, if you look at actual people who have had failures themselves you will see why it failed (few exceptions of course). The "well my buddies 6.0 is piece of crap" tells you nothing.

hope this helps,

Clayton
Not to be argumentative, but if the failures were only caused by those that don't take care of their trucks, Ford probably would not have initiated a lawsuit against the maker of the engine and casting sand would not be high on the list of reasons for failure. Mine has been serviced and maintained at the dealership since it was new, they have all the records and 900 miles is the most it has ever gone "over" on an oil change with fluids changed at all recommended times. At 95k, they had to replace the heads and head gaskets and all that entails under warranty and at 100,960 miles the EGR cooler went out and they offered me 0 warranty assistance (the aftermarket warranty I bought excluded emissions components), costing me 3k out of pocket. At 165k, I have just finished 5k worth of work on HG's again (never had a tuner on it until now for the delete), studs, EGR delete and oil cooler, new radiator, some glow plugs and a couple of injectors that were on their way out. Talked to the mechanic the other day and he has stopped using OEM parts and gone to an aftermarket kit and he said that he has almost put himself out of work on the 6.0's by dumping OEM parts. Truth of the matter is buying a 6.0 is a risky undertaking at best and, at worst, a money pit.
 
  #22  
Old 09-21-2012, 04:45 PM
bismic's Avatar
bismic
bismic is offline
Fleet Owner
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 26,114
Received 2,522 Likes on 1,754 Posts
Originally Posted by mlytc
Not to be argumentative, but if the failures were only caused by those that don't take care of their trucks, Ford probably would not have initiated a lawsuit against the maker of the engine and casting sand would not be high on the list of reasons for failure. Mine has been serviced and maintained at the dealership since it was new, they have all the records and 900 miles is the most it has ever gone "over" on an oil change with fluids changed at all recommended times. At 95k, they had to replace the heads and head gaskets and all that entails under warranty and at 100,960 miles the EGR cooler went out and they offered me 0 warranty assistance (the aftermarket warranty I bought excluded emissions components), costing me 3k out of pocket. At 165k, I have just finished 5k worth of work on HG's again (never had a tuner on it until now for the delete), studs, EGR delete and oil cooler, new radiator, some glow plugs and a couple of injectors that were on their way out. Talked to the mechanic the other day and he has stopped using OEM parts and gone to an aftermarket kit and he said that he has almost put himself out of work on the 6.0's by dumping OEM parts. Truth of the matter is buying a 6.0 is a risky undertaking at best and, at worst, a money pit.
Both of these statements are far from being accurate.

The OEM components that are not recommended are the head bolts (studs are recommended), the 05 and up EGR coolers (BPD EGR cooler or delete is recommended), the FICM (which can be cheaply upgraded to a reliable component), and the alternator.

Unless you are upgrading for more power, OEM is best on injectors, head gaskets (and these are good for apprx. 500k hp), EGR valves, glow plugs, transmission, even the turbo IMO.

Although the OEM oil cooler is not better than some of the aftermarket oil coolers, there is nothing wrong with the OEM oil cooler. Nothing wrong with the OEM radiator, charge air cooler, etc.

As far as a money pit goes - apply what this (and other) forum has to offer and there is no need to be worrying - unless the engine has been abused or is a RARE lemon.
 
  #23  
Old 09-21-2012, 06:58 PM
mlytc's Avatar
mlytc
mlytc is offline
Junior User
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: South MS
Posts: 81
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Originally Posted by bismic
Both of these statements are far from being accurate.

The OEM components that are not recommended are the head bolts (studs are recommended), the 05 and up EGR coolers (BPD EGR cooler or delete is recommended), the FICM (which can be cheaply upgraded to a reliable component), and the alternator.

Unless you are upgrading for more power, OEM is best on injectors, head gaskets (and these are good for apprx. 500k hp), EGR valves, glow plugs, transmission, even the turbo IMO.

Although the OEM oil cooler is not better than some of the aftermarket oil coolers, there is nothing wrong with the OEM oil cooler. Nothing wrong with the OEM radiator, charge air cooler, etc.

As far as a money pit goes - apply what this (and other) forum has to offer and there is no need to be worrying - unless the engine has been abused or is a RARE lemon.
Probably should not have thrown that out as a blanket statement, you are correct in that he uses the bpd upgrade (he will not do the delete as he is at a dealership) and the studs. The rest of it, I would imagine, he goes OEM.
Got mine out Tuesday morning from 5k worth of work and between my last post earlier today and this one, it was wreckered back to the shop. Just shut off on me at 75 mph on the highway, my SCT flash tuner showed P2623, if I remember correctly "Injector control pressure regulator open". No surging, no warning, just shut off. Leads me to believe that maybe the pigtail has a broken wire or the pigtail itself may be bad since it has 165k on it and it has been plugged and unplugged several times lately. A relatively minor issue, I'm hoping. As for the money pit statement, I will stand by it as pertaining to mine, because I have done everything that has been recommended and I am over 10k in repairs into it (not counting the replacing of heads and all at 95k under warranty). Some have had good luck with them, I haven't. I am in an agricultural community and have a lot of friends that run the 6.0 and their stories are pretty similar to mine. So when someone asks, I give them my experience and let them decide, I was told before I bought mine and chose to chance it and have been bitten pretty good on it but I can't see going into debt 40-50k on something else.
 
  #24  
Old 09-21-2012, 08:12 PM
bismic's Avatar
bismic
bismic is offline
Fleet Owner
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 26,114
Received 2,522 Likes on 1,754 Posts
Sorry to hear about anyone spending that kind of money, let alone a group of guys like yourselves.

The thing is, that these things can be resolved PROACTIVELY for less than half the cost of fixing them after they break .......

$350 to repair a FICM vs $1000 at ford

EGR cooler AND a new oil cooler kit - MAYBE $1500 by an upgrade shop - WHO KNOWS how much if the oil cooler fails or the EGR cooler fails (a lot more for sure)

STC fitting and Standpipes and Dummy plugs (05 and up) - get them done all at once and save by not having multiple repair events. Same type of cost advantage.

My main point was to shop around and upgrade before failure - will save a lot of money!!

Finding a Ford Tech that will do some work on the side can be an INCREDIBLE advantage to saving money on ANY engine.
 
  #25  
Old 09-21-2012, 09:16 PM
mlytc's Avatar
mlytc
mlytc is offline
Junior User
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: South MS
Posts: 81
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Originally Posted by bismic
Sorry to hear about anyone spending that kind of money, let alone a group of guys like yourselves.

The thing is, that these things can be resolved PROACTIVELY for less than half the cost of fixing them after they break .......

$350 to repair a FICM vs $1000 at ford

EGR cooler AND a new oil cooler kit - MAYBE $1500 by an upgrade shop - WHO KNOWS how much if the oil cooler fails or the EGR cooler fails (a lot more for sure)

STC fitting and Standpipes and Dummy plugs (05 and up) - get them done all at once and save by not having multiple repair events. Same type of cost advantage.

My main point was to shop around and upgrade before failure - will save a lot of money!!

Finding a Ford Tech that will do some work on the side can be an INCREDIBLE advantage to saving money on ANY engine.
The most recent 5k was done by a non-dealership shop at $60/hour compared to dealer rates. I got the stud/gasket kit online ($578) as well as the delete/oil cooler kit online ($870). Still had to get some other parts from the dealership (o-rings, coolant, etc., about $800 worth) and that's when I talked to the mechanic there that had completed the earlier work (warranty and first EGR failure) for me. Got the 2 injectors, the radiator and the glow plugs locally for almost $1000 Would have been close to 7k had he done it. 28 hours labor plus all the parts and brake cleaner, freon and misc things and I did most of the parts running to keep him working. Oh, and sending the heads out to be checked before the re-install. I'm assuming the stand pipes you are talking about are the two pipes used in the HPO system and you can't buy just the o-rings, you have to replace the whole things at $70 each. Everyone I talk to says that it should be right now that I have this completed, so I hope today's episode is just a glitch and not too serious.
 
  #26  
Old 09-23-2012, 01:26 AM
mschultz's Avatar
mschultz
mschultz is offline
Senior User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 410
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Originally Posted by bismic
Sorry to hear about anyone spending that kind of money, let alone a group of guys like yourselves.

The thing is, that these things can be resolved PROACTIVELY for less than half the cost of fixing them after they break .......

$350 to repair a FICM vs $1000 at ford

EGR cooler AND a new oil cooler kit - MAYBE $1500 by an upgrade shop - WHO KNOWS how much if the oil cooler fails or the EGR cooler fails (a lot more for sure)

STC fitting and Standpipes and Dummy plugs (05 and up) - get them done all at once and save by not having multiple repair events. Same type of cost advantage.

My main point was to shop around and upgrade before failure - will save a lot of money!!

Finding a Ford Tech that will do some work on the side can be an INCREDIBLE advantage to saving money on ANY engine.
Ok- here I have to disagree with your advice. Instead of hiring a legitimate shop which has proper tools, workspace, labor rates and service support, you recommend finding someone to do this on the side? Dude, if I lived next door to someone with your experience I'd hire you tonight. But the odds of knowing someone who will do this "on the side" are not that great. I know plenty of solid mechanics- but I get the feeling that it would be best to have someone who has been in and out of a 6.0 a couple of times. And has a cab hoist.

You make it sound like all of this is nothing- just minor maintenance. "Maybe $1500" .... yeah... right... I'll just go out and look for a "Ford tech that will do some work on the side" perhaps he is hanging out at the pub down the street right now wearing his "6.0 tech" patch and perhaps he'll do this behind his house and then if something goes wrong I'll have no recourse at all.

It seems to me that this is actually a $3,000 to $5,000 proposition - in other words, more than a year of depreciation on a new truck.

Do not get me wrong. I like my truck and I may do this work because I do not wish to be stranded with a loaded trailer 300 miles from home- but only because you can not sell a used 6.0 in my area and because spending $3-$5 is better than wholesaling the truck away for $8-$12 and staring over with something else.

And yes, to answer texastech, I would dump the truck for a $40 part and a day of shop labor because once you are in there, you might as well deal with everything else that is wrong. And that is not $40. My time is not free. And paying Ford $3-$5k to fix that which they probably should have recalled is frustrating.

And what makes you think that it will die at home? Do STC fittings only fail when parked at home? Kinda doubt it.

I like my truck. But I doubt it is going to be as reliable, long term, as the Cummins trucks. Of course, my friend was just stranded by his '98 Cummins and he is now awaiting an injection pump and a lift pump for an estimated $3k. So maybe they are all the same.

-Mike
 
  #27  
Old 09-23-2012, 04:20 AM
UGA33's Avatar
UGA33
UGA33 is offline
Lead Driver

Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Cartersville, Ga
Posts: 5,648
Received 129 Likes on 66 Posts
Originally Posted by mschultz
So maybe they are all the same.

-Mike
Bingo.

Putting a 6.0 in a truck for the company I used to work for right now. Died at 190k. After I get done with it, they have an 07 5.9 needing the same thing. 5.9 has 170k miles on it. In some ways, they are all the same when they are not taken care of.
 
  #28  
Old 09-23-2012, 04:22 AM
UGA33's Avatar
UGA33
UGA33 is offline
Lead Driver

Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Cartersville, Ga
Posts: 5,648
Received 129 Likes on 66 Posts
If I would have kept my 6.0, I truely believe I could have put a few 100k miles on it with the stock hardware. I was the original owner and when I yanked the heads off at 92k miles to do studs proactively, the gaskets were in mint condition.
 
  #29  
Old 09-23-2012, 06:53 AM
bismic's Avatar
bismic
bismic is offline
Fleet Owner
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 26,114
Received 2,522 Likes on 1,754 Posts
Originally Posted by mschultz
Ok- here I have to disagree with your advice. Instead of hiring a legitimate shop which has proper tools, workspace, labor rates and service support, you recommend finding someone to do this on the side? Dude, if I lived next door to someone with your experience I'd hire you tonight. But the odds of knowing someone who will do this "on the side" are not that great. I know plenty of solid mechanics- but I get the feeling that it would be best to have someone who has been in and out of a 6.0 a couple of times. And has a cab hoist.

You make it sound like all of this is nothing- just minor maintenance. "Maybe $1500" .... yeah... right... I'll just go out and look for a "Ford tech that will do some work on the side" perhaps he is hanging out at the pub down the street right now wearing his "6.0 tech" patch and perhaps he'll do this behind his house and then if something goes wrong I'll have no recourse at all.

It seems to me that this is actually a $3,000 to $5,000 proposition - in other words, more than a year of depreciation on a new truck.

Do not get me wrong. I like my truck and I may do this work because I do not wish to be stranded with a loaded trailer 300 miles from home- but only because you can not sell a used 6.0 in my area and because spending $3-$5 is better than wholesaling the truck away for $8-$12 and staring over with something else.

And yes, to answer texastech, I would dump the truck for a $40 part and a day of shop labor because once you are in there, you might as well deal with everything else that is wrong. And that is not $40. My time is not free. And paying Ford $3-$5k to fix that which they probably should have recalled is frustrating.

And what makes you think that it will die at home? Do STC fittings only fail when parked at home? Kinda doubt it.

I like my truck. But I doubt it is going to be as reliable, long term, as the Cummins trucks. Of course, my friend was just stranded by his '98 Cummins and he is now awaiting an injection pump and a lift pump for an estimated $3k. So maybe they are all the same.

-Mike
Your pesrpective is off track. Legitimate shop?? Come on, what are you saying?? Only a dealership is a legitimate shop? Are you saying also that owners can't properly fix their engines or upgrade them? There are NUMEROUS shops that are far more experienced with the aftermarket (studs and EGR deletes) than most dealerships. How do you even know who works on your truck when you walk out the door of the shop - at ANY shop. Answer - do your homework.

If you have to drive a few hundred miles to a reputable shop, it may be worth it (and I guarantee you that most people live within that distance to a shop with enough business to determine their reputation).

I said the oil cooler / EGR cooler is $1500. In a shop with experience ...... believe it or not, no skin off my back.

Oh and that "pub statement" sarcasm in a post like this - pointless and inappropriate IMO.

.
.
.

BTW (throwing it out there for more "discussion") - Properly maintained, I do not think that head gasket failures are inevitable. 6.0L owners do not need to live in fear OR blindly believe that they need to "do it all at once" and then blast Ford for causing them to spend $5000 (or more) because they didn't shop around for the best place to have the work done. Same with oil coolers - they can be very reliable with the proper coolant maintenance. If you read the forums carefully you will see people tuned without studs, ignoring coolant/transmission/etc fluid maintenance, wrong oil filters, ignoring the fuel pressure issue or being surprised with bad fuel, not wanting to spend $160 in a gauge set-up ..... (and on and on) ...... only to later have problems.
 
  #30  
Old 09-23-2012, 06:57 AM
metmop's Avatar
metmop
metmop is offline
Senior User
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Orlando, FL
Posts: 294
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes on 0 Posts
Some things to consider when it comes to the 6.0L and cost of repair verse other trucks....

1. The 6.0L and the 6.4L etc... were created to keep up with Federally mandated emissions requirements. All other brands (Dodge, Chevy, etc...) also had to update their engines to satisfy requirements.

2. The price of EVERYTHING has gone up since 2003 when this truck was released. Including but not limited to the cost of shipping (the parts have to get to dealership some how) and the cost of labor. This means a job that cost 3K then probably costs us 5k now..... if not more. So when you talk about the 7.3 never costing this much or how expensive the 6.7 is....
 


Quick Reply: 6.0 - is failure inevitable?



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:50 AM.