Last edit by: IB Advertising
See related guides and technical advice from our community experts:
Browse all: Exterior Guides
- Why Does My Truck Shake?
Guide to diagnose trouble and recommended solutions
Browse all: Exterior Guides
5.4L at idol nocks and shakes (sometimes)
#106
you saying like change the tensioner and the chain?
Mine seems to make a ticking sound when driving like in a drive thru, but on occasion it will sound terrible like it is going to die. only does this when hot, or after been driving a few miles, and only at idle speeds.
Is fixing this a must? will i cause more damage driving it?
I have a check engine light, but the code it is throwing is for the gas cap.... and this car has the capless gas cap.
#107
Knocking
THANKS!
you saying like change the tensioner and the chain?
Mine seems to make a ticking sound when driving like in a drive thru, but on occasion it will sound terrible like it is going to die. only does this when hot, or after been driving a few miles, and only at idle speeds.
Is fixing this a must? will i cause more damage driving it?
I have a check engine light, but the code it is throwing is for the gas cap.... and this car has the capless gas cap.
you saying like change the tensioner and the chain?
Mine seems to make a ticking sound when driving like in a drive thru, but on occasion it will sound terrible like it is going to die. only does this when hot, or after been driving a few miles, and only at idle speeds.
Is fixing this a must? will i cause more damage driving it?
I have a check engine light, but the code it is throwing is for the gas cap.... and this car has the capless gas cap.
Eventually it'll get worse down the road. Yeah chain and tensioner would be good, there's a kit on Amazon for 200 or 300 very good deal. The knocking will be consistent if not fixed mines was ok for like 2 years before it got consistent
#108
I have the same problem with my 2010 F150 with the 5.4l. I had severe problems and replaced cam phasers, timing chains and guides, vct solenoids, a new oil pump and spark plugs. It now purrs like a kitten until the oil is hot and idling at a red light. It then goes into the shaking and rattling routine. With 270,000 km on the clock, I wanted to monitor the oil pressure, so I installed a mechanical pressure gauge and tapped the line into a fitting soldered into the center of the oil filter. The pressure is 40-50 lbs at 1000 rpm and 60 and more at cruising. But when hot and idling, the rpm will drop to about 500 rpm with oil pressure at 25 to below 20 and that is when the rough idle, knocking and sometimes stalling occurs. I believe I have read that these low oil pressures are considered the new normal by Ford. And with the good pressure at cruising, it may not do any good to replace the bearings. My current solution is to keep the revs up at the lights. I wish I could find a place to mount the gauge inside the cab, rather than on the hood. Is there a chip available to increase the idle rpm? Or an ECU upgrade? That would be the best solution at this time. I will be starting a thread asking for expert advise for a red neck solution I dreamt up this afternoon.
#109
Similar rough idle problem and loss of power
I replaced the VCTs and nothing helped. One mechanic said it needed a new engine, a friend knew a Ford mechanic and he said a lot of people put 20W50 in it and it goes away. First I put 10W40 and it almost solved the rough idle but not completely. I put 20W50 in it and drove it for 45 minutes and it didn't hiccup once.
The symptoms were that it would run fine until it got up to operating temperature, then the idle became very rough and power loss was significant upon acceleration. P0022,P0012, P0300, P0305, P0345....
Can anyone explain why the 20W50 made all these symptoms go away and it runs quietly and powerfully now?
The symptoms were that it would run fine until it got up to operating temperature, then the idle became very rough and power loss was significant upon acceleration. P0022,P0012, P0300, P0305, P0345....
Can anyone explain why the 20W50 made all these symptoms go away and it runs quietly and powerfully now?
#110
The following users liked this post:
#111
I replaced the VCTs and nothing helped. One mechanic said it needed a new engine, a friend knew a Ford mechanic and he said a lot of people put 20W50 in it and it goes away. First I put 10W40 and it almost solved the rough idle but not completely. I put 20W50 in it and drove it for 45 minutes and it didn't hiccup once.
The symptoms were that it would run fine until it got up to operating temperature, then the idle became very rough and power loss was significant upon acceleration. P0022,P0012, P0300, P0305, P0345....
Can anyone explain why the 20W50 made all these symptoms go away and it runs quietly and powerfully now?
The symptoms were that it would run fine until it got up to operating temperature, then the idle became very rough and power loss was significant upon acceleration. P0022,P0012, P0300, P0305, P0345....
Can anyone explain why the 20W50 made all these symptoms go away and it runs quietly and powerfully now?
Thicker oils in the 5.4 improve the oil pressure. This is important because the phasers require enough pressure to function. Minimum pressure for them to work correctly is 25psi at idle (in drive) ideally it's higher like 30+psi. With insufficient pressure one or both banks will phase their cams inconsistently thus throwing the timing off. Phaser function is returned back to normal when the oil pressure is established (higher rpm). Your engine is more powerful now because the phasers have enough pressure to function correctly and both sides are in time.
If this problem was not diagnosed properly it's possible to replace the phasers and VCT solenoids and still have this issue. Many people have spent many thousands of dollars chasing this issue and throwing parts at the engine.
FYI: The oil "gauge" in the cab is wired to a pressure switch, it does not actually measure oil pressure, I think anything over 10-15psi will activate the switch. You will need a real analog gauge to read the actual oil pressure.
This seems to be a 5.4 design flaw. It does seem to be worked around by using heavier oil. I am not sure what the long term effects of running heavy oil will be on the engine. Since phasers only retard timing from normal, you may consider locking the phasers (with a kit) into the normal timing position. This will throw the check engine light but the system can be reprogrammed to not do this. You may lose 1-2 mpg in fuel efficiency, power should be about the same. Essentially you will be disabling the variable cam system and trade some efficiency for reliability. If you did that you should be able to return back to a 5w20 or 5w30 oil.
How is your engine running now? Are you still running 20w50?
- Aaron
#112
What's the solution
Hi,
I have an '07 F150 5.4L 3V that has a horrible knock that I re-reproduce at will (and make go away).
1. Bring engine up to operating temp.
2. Light throttle tip-in bringing RPM's to (but no more than than) 1000rpm.
3. Release throttle (idles back down to ~500rpm).
4. KNOCK and VIOLENT VIBRATION occurs and rpm's drop to ~300rpm.
5. Apply throttle to bring rpm's ~ 1500rpm and release.
6. Knock and vibration gone. Engine purrs back at idle.
I can re-produce this 100% of the time. Now what I do when making parking lot maneuvers (<1200 rpm) is make sure I rev teh engine to at least 1500rpm and it won't invoke the horrible knock/vibration.
When this does occur the oil pressure gauge in the dash is rock steady. Although it could be not repsonding quikcly enough to show a short interval drop in oil pressure. Dealer measured pressure at operating temp to be 30-35 psi.
In addition to this, I also have a hesitation somewhere around 2nd gear. Not much, but noticable.
Cam phasor? VCT? Fuel sending unit module?
I would thought maybe EGR but it's my understadning these engines don't have one.
I have an '07 F150 5.4L 3V that has a horrible knock that I re-reproduce at will (and make go away).
1. Bring engine up to operating temp.
2. Light throttle tip-in bringing RPM's to (but no more than than) 1000rpm.
3. Release throttle (idles back down to ~500rpm).
4. KNOCK and VIOLENT VIBRATION occurs and rpm's drop to ~300rpm.
5. Apply throttle to bring rpm's ~ 1500rpm and release.
6. Knock and vibration gone. Engine purrs back at idle.
I can re-produce this 100% of the time. Now what I do when making parking lot maneuvers (<1200 rpm) is make sure I rev teh engine to at least 1500rpm and it won't invoke the horrible knock/vibration.
When this does occur the oil pressure gauge in the dash is rock steady. Although it could be not repsonding quikcly enough to show a short interval drop in oil pressure. Dealer measured pressure at operating temp to be 30-35 psi.
In addition to this, I also have a hesitation somewhere around 2nd gear. Not much, but noticable.
Cam phasor? VCT? Fuel sending unit module?
I would thought maybe EGR but it's my understadning these engines don't have one.
#113
#114
I replaced the VCTs and nothing helped. One mechanic said it needed a new engine, a friend knew a Ford mechanic and he said a lot of people put 20W50 in it and it goes away. First I put 10W40 and it almost solved the rough idle but not completely. I put 20W50 in it and drove it for 45 minutes and it didn't hiccup once.
The symptoms were that it would run fine until it got up to operating temperature, then the idle became very rough and power loss was significant upon acceleration. P0022,P0012, P0300, P0305, P0345....
Can anyone explain why the 20W50 made all these symptoms go away and it runs quietly and powerfully now?
The symptoms were that it would run fine until it got up to operating temperature, then the idle became very rough and power loss was significant upon acceleration. P0022,P0012, P0300, P0305, P0345....
Can anyone explain why the 20W50 made all these symptoms go away and it runs quietly and powerfully now?
#115
#116
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Longdistancetrucker
1999 to 2016 Super Duty
1
02-18-2012 10:22 AM
fuzzyfanny
1987 - 1996 F150 & Larger F-Series Trucks
6
04-08-2011 03:21 PM