Beans or Riffraff intake?
#16
11-01-2010, 10:04 AM
Hotshot
#17
11-01-2010, 10:44 AM
Hotshot
#18
11-01-2010, 12:09 PM
#21
11-01-2010, 03:10 PM
Hotshot
Buy a 6637 from Fleet Filter and it will have a Donaldson sticker on it. Buy a 6637 from Napa and it will have a Donaldson sticker on it. Buy a 6637 from Clay and I'll bet it has a Donaldson sticker on it.
There are only a few companies producing filters anymore, most of them are just re-branded. But Dale @ Tymar will tell you that only the Donaldson is THE Donaldson filter and all the others are just knock offs.
There are only a few companies producing filters anymore, most of them are just re-branded. But Dale @ Tymar will tell you that only the Donaldson is THE Donaldson filter and all the others are just knock offs.
#22
11-01-2010, 04:48 PM
I have researched this a few years back. The Napa 6637 is a Donaldson filter (actually has a Donaldson sticker on it) and no matter where you buy the filter (tymar, beans or Napa) it isn't the water resistant filter. That is either a marketing ploy by Tymar from back in the day or just an internet myth. Donaldson does make a water resistant filter exactly like the 6637 but it is about 3 times the cost of the 6637/tymar filter.
Buy a 6637 from Fleet Filter and it will have a Donaldson sticker on it. Buy a 6637 from Napa and it will have a Donaldson sticker on it. Buy a 6637 from Clay and I'll bet it has a Donaldson sticker on it.
There are only a few companies producing filters anymore, most of them are just re-branded. But Dale @ Tymar will tell you that only the Donaldson is THE Donaldson filter and all the others are just knock offs.
Tim
I could agree with you BUT, then we would both be wrong!
There are only a few companies producing filters anymore, most of them are just re-branded. But Dale @ Tymar will tell you that only the Donaldson is THE Donaldson filter and all the others are just knock offs.
Tim
I could agree with you BUT, then we would both be wrong!
Just as Tim said, they are all the same.
Anyone can "claim" something, but that doesn't mean its true.
Clay could claim that he has the only "true" filter too, and then who would be right?
But, lets just examine Tim's signature here again.
=)
#23
11-01-2010, 05:05 PM
Hotshot
Lets just get one thing clear... I never said Dale was right, nor do I think he is. But give him a call and ask him if the filter you bought at Napa is the same one he sells. Set aside at LEAST 30 minutes, preferrably an hour as he WILL talk your ear off. To make your life even more interesting tell him you built your own intake... better set aside 2 hours if you decide to do that.
#24
11-01-2010, 05:32 PM
PREMIUM SPONSOR
Let me see if I can muddy the water more, LOL.
I have personally bought many pallets of these filters from the manufacturer and they come boxed as Baldwin, Luber-Finer, Donaldson, Napa/Wix, and Fleetrite. Same filter, same manufacturer, same box, different label. Yet none of those are the manufacturer
I have personally bought many pallets of these filters from the manufacturer and they come boxed as Baldwin, Luber-Finer, Donaldson, Napa/Wix, and Fleetrite. Same filter, same manufacturer, same box, different label. Yet none of those are the manufacturer
#25
11-01-2010, 06:38 PM
Replying with tims quote, and I added his signature back in as well.
Just as Tim said, they are all the same.
Anyone can "claim" something, but that doesn't mean its true.
Clay could claim that he has the only "true" filter too, and then who would be right?
But, lets just examine Tim's signature here again.
=)
Just as Tim said, they are all the same.
Anyone can "claim" something, but that doesn't mean its true.
Clay could claim that he has the only "true" filter too, and then who would be right?
But, lets just examine Tim's signature here again.
=)
Lets just get one thing clear... I never said Dale was right, nor do I think he is. But give him a call and ask him if the filter you bought at Napa is the same one he sells. Set aside at LEAST 30 minutes, preferrably an hour as he WILL talk your ear off. To make your life even more interesting tell him you built your own intake... better set aside 2 hours if you decide to do that.
Let me see if I can muddy the water more, LOL.
I have personally bought many pallets of these filters from the manufacturer and they come boxed as Baldwin, Luber-Finer, Donaldson, Napa/Wix, and Fleetrite. Same filter, same manufacturer, same box, different label. Yet none of those are the manufacturer
I have personally bought many pallets of these filters from the manufacturer and they come boxed as Baldwin, Luber-Finer, Donaldson, Napa/Wix, and Fleetrite. Same filter, same manufacturer, same box, different label. Yet none of those are the manufacturer
#26
11-01-2010, 06:42 PM
Hotshot
x2, inquiring minds want to know!
#27
11-01-2010, 07:25 PM
Join Date: Sep 2010
Location: Spring, Texas N. Houston
Posts: 101
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#28
11-02-2010, 09:32 AM
Atta boy. I did the Napa gig but if I were to do it all over again I would go with Clay. You will sometimes think that you can piece it together yourself for cheaper than Clay offers but this is rarely the case. By the time you drive all around wasting fuel to piece it together, then realize you are missing one little thing, you might as well go with Clays deal. Everything you need for the project guarenteed, shipped to your door, with great customer service.
And I agree that they are all the same filter. It's like buying a Napa gold filter or a Wix filter from O'Reillys. They are both Wix filters. They just have different badges on them.
And I agree that they are all the same filter. It's like buying a Napa gold filter or a Wix filter from O'Reillys. They are both Wix filters. They just have different badges on them.
#30
11-11-2010, 03:10 PM
I was doing some searching on this subject. Looks like the donaldson B085046 is water resilient. Subscribing.
https://dynamic.donaldson.com/webc/W...072&item=14069
https://dynamic.donaldson.com/webc/W...072&item=14069
That filter crosses to a Napa 2326. My cost is $83 and list price is $205