Removing catalytic converter legal or not
#46
Reviving and OLD thread vs starting a new one....
Here's my situation, just bought an '02 7.3 w/manual tranny from a Dealership. Vehicle was sold by the dealership on consignment. All of my paperwork on the sale states that I bought the vehicle from them (actual owner's name no where on paperwork). Live in Colorado, some counties have emissions testing while others don't.
My county does have emissions testing. Took it in to get tested yesterday, truck passed on the actual test (runs VERY clean) but upon visual inspection there was no Cat. Engine sticker says the truck has to have a Cat, truck failed as a result.
My question is this ... how culpable is the dealership for selling me a vehicle that was missing required equipment to pass emissions and thus get registered? Their story is that since they didn't actually own the truck, they never did and inspection and thus never knew about the missing Cat. Dealership has offered to split the cost with me to have a cat installed but that means i'm still coming out of pocket hundreds of dollars.
Any advice you experts can give would be great. I really feel that the dealership should pay for the entire install to make the truck right. Wasn't sure if I had a legal leg to stand on.
Thanks for listening.
Here's my situation, just bought an '02 7.3 w/manual tranny from a Dealership. Vehicle was sold by the dealership on consignment. All of my paperwork on the sale states that I bought the vehicle from them (actual owner's name no where on paperwork). Live in Colorado, some counties have emissions testing while others don't.
My county does have emissions testing. Took it in to get tested yesterday, truck passed on the actual test (runs VERY clean) but upon visual inspection there was no Cat. Engine sticker says the truck has to have a Cat, truck failed as a result.
My question is this ... how culpable is the dealership for selling me a vehicle that was missing required equipment to pass emissions and thus get registered? Their story is that since they didn't actually own the truck, they never did and inspection and thus never knew about the missing Cat. Dealership has offered to split the cost with me to have a cat installed but that means i'm still coming out of pocket hundreds of dollars.
Any advice you experts can give would be great. I really feel that the dealership should pay for the entire install to make the truck right. Wasn't sure if I had a legal leg to stand on.
Thanks for listening.
#47
Was it a new/Ford car dealer or side lot? I would think that it is on the dealer, period. It is their responsibility to insure a vehicle is legal. Manual transmission trucks did have a CAT from the factory, autos did not regardless of the state sold (e'99 to '03 7.3). Mine is a Cali truck sold new here and no CAT. Has the sticker to prove it. Guy at a local truck shop lost a sale on a whole new 4" exhaust system because he demanded that I have a CAT installed when it was not needed.
#48
#49
Depends, was the truck sold "as is" or did it come with a warranty. The loophole will be that someone living in an area that does not require a CAT could just have easily purchased it and would not have a problem. If the truck was manufactured without one then you are not required to put one on it. Going by the sticker is another issue as I have seen some recommend to others on here to swap out the stickers to a non-cat sticker so they could try and pass a smog. I read an early reply to this post some years ago that said only 07 and later needed smog but this is not true. I have an 02 that gets smog checked every two years but the problem with CA smog checks are that they are not state wide. Even specific counties may only have a partial smog check zone. I live in Riverside County so the west half gets smog checks while the east half is not required to have them. Another idea may be to contact the original owner and see if he/she had a CAT and if they removed it and/or if they still have it if it did come with one.
#50
BTW, this thread was originated almost six (6) years ago, just sayin'.
#51
#52
This was also in South Carolina where they stopped doing vehicle inspections back in the early 90's. You can buy a new 6.7 and remove all emissions controls off of it with no worries.
#53
Truck was bought from a Ford Dealership....as small family owned one but a Ford dealership nonetheless. Truck was NOT sold with a warranty provided by the dealership but at the time of purchase I did purchase a supplemental warranty with the truck. I'll have to make a call but I doubt the warranty I purchased would cover equipment that was never there.
#54
Truck was bought from a Ford Dealership....as small family owned one but a Ford dealership nonetheless. Truck was NOT sold with a warranty provided by the dealership but at the time of purchase I did purchase a supplemental warranty with the truck. I'll have to make a call but I doubt the warranty I purchased would cover equipment that was never there.
I'm not sure, but I believe all OEM emissions equipment must be on the vehicle and in proper working order too.
Stewart
#56
Truck was bought from a Ford Dealership....as small family owned one but a Ford dealership nonetheless. Truck was NOT sold with a warranty provided by the dealership but at the time of purchase I did purchase a supplemental warranty with the truck. I'll have to make a call but I doubt the warranty I purchased would cover equipment that was never there.
If that doesn't work you can request to talk to someone higher. I'm not sure of the legal aspect but I would think that is something they should have told you since they should have found that on one of the inspections they did on it before putting out front for sale. I don't think it's unrealistic that you should be able to buy a vehicle from a dealership, drive it down the street and have it pass a smog check.
It may not work, but they may ask you for your information. I would think something that's a drop in the bucket for them is worth resolving rather than wasting time haggling over. It's not like they gave a flat tire for a spare.
Just my .02. That's what I would do. As my wife always tells me...you catch more flies with honey.
#57
I'm guessing this situation varies by state. I learned here in Indiana last year when looking at a 2004 F-350 Dually, that a dealer (actual Ford dealer) will not keep/sell a used vehicle if the catalytic has been removed. The truck I was looking at had no cat or muffler. The Car Fax report showed the dealer took it in on trade, and rather than selling it they sent it to auction right away where the local used car lot where I test drove it found it. Called the Ford dealer to inquire WHY they would let it go rather than sell it (nice truck ~$18k) thinking they might have known something seriously wrong with it. They said it was flagged for auction because "no cat", that they can't resell a used vehicle with no cats. I also learned that once that was discovered they don't even continue to inspect the truck for "certified used vehicle" status. They'd make more at auction then spending the money on exhaust restoration to resell.
#58
#59
#60
Thanks everyone for the advise/help/insight. Got the cat put on and my truck passed emissions. So far dealership has paid for 1/2. I'm going to keep contacting them to see if they can meet me a little closer than 1/2 way. I may not make much progress but at least I've got my truck back, it's legal, and I wasn't stuck for the full amount.