Whistle under heavy load
#16
Loud whistle noise when towing in warm weather.
I gave up on having Ford try and fix the problem of that LOUD whistle or what ever it is when towing in warm weather.
After close to two years of taking it back for diagnosis and repair, just last week they changed the Turbo and the associated exhaust fittings/pipes so I gave another try. NO Luck. Still made that awful noise.
I gave in and bought a new 2008 F250 6.4L . So far lousy fuel mileage 11/12 mpg.
I hope this motor is better than the last. Good luck to all who have this problem, I will continue to monitor this site to see if anyone can come up with the answer.
Love the info on this site, You guys are great.
MURPHYS
PS.
My wife is writting some nasty letters to Ford right now, (Just letting of steam) We don't really expect a reply.
After close to two years of taking it back for diagnosis and repair, just last week they changed the Turbo and the associated exhaust fittings/pipes so I gave another try. NO Luck. Still made that awful noise.
I gave in and bought a new 2008 F250 6.4L . So far lousy fuel mileage 11/12 mpg.
I hope this motor is better than the last. Good luck to all who have this problem, I will continue to monitor this site to see if anyone can come up with the answer.
Love the info on this site, You guys are great.
MURPHYS
PS.
My wife is writting some nasty letters to Ford right now, (Just letting of steam) We don't really expect a reply.
#17
Sold my 6.0L
I too gave up. In last year my 04 F350 dually has been in shop toooo much, and takes too long to fix. I too had that annoying whistle around 2800 rpms under hot load. I believe it is connected to fan/water pump. My turbo and intercooler was replaced last month (over boost). Still had whistle afterwards. I see too many 6.0 diesels in local shops. Latest problem was engine overheated when fan belt broke while towing up hill in desert. Took me 2 days to replace belt 100 miles from home, then motor used 1.5 gals of water to get home. Been in shop since Aug 7, still not fixed. I trading my stock 51,000 mile F350 in for 08 Dodge 3500 (my first Dodge) with 6.7L. Local Dodge dealer traded with F350 still in shop. AAA happy I sold F350. They said many 6.0 diesels break down. Have first trip to Las Vegas this weekend with Dodge.
I still have a Ford, an F250 5.4L supercharged. When my 6.0L ran it was great, but I need reliability. The first 30,000 miles were problem free. Good luck to you all with your 6.0L. I hope the new 6.4L is better.
I still have a Ford, an F250 5.4L supercharged. When my 6.0L ran it was great, but I need reliability. The first 30,000 miles were problem free. Good luck to you all with your 6.0L. I hope the new 6.4L is better.
#18
#19
Originally Posted by QuarterT
I too gave up. In last year my 04 F350 dually has been in shop toooo much, and takes too long to fix. I too had that annoying whistle around 2800 rpms under hot load. I believe it is connected to fan/water pump. My turbo and intercooler was replaced last month (over boost). Still had whistle afterwards. I see too many 6.0 diesels in local shops. Latest problem was engine overheated when fan belt broke while towing up hill in desert. Took me 2 days to replace belt 100 miles from home, then motor used 1.5 gals of water to get home. Been in shop since Aug 7, still not fixed. I trading my stock 51,000 mile F350 in for 08 Dodge 3500 (my first Dodge) with 6.7L. Local Dodge dealer traded with F350 still in shop. AAA happy I sold F350. They said many 6.0 diesels break down. Have first trip to Las Vegas this weekend with Dodge.
I still have a Ford, an F250 5.4L supercharged. When my 6.0L ran it was great, but I need reliability. The first 30,000 miles were problem free. Good luck to you all with your 6.0L. I hope the new 6.4L is better.
I still have a Ford, an F250 5.4L supercharged. When my 6.0L ran it was great, but I need reliability. The first 30,000 miles were problem free. Good luck to you all with your 6.0L. I hope the new 6.4L is better.
i just think you'll be unhappy with the quality and fitment of the dodge trucks. the engine is their ONLY saving grace, and not enough of one for me to ever buy one, i'd by a gasser before i got a dodge.
#21
Well, I have bad news.
My whistle "went away" one day, while climbing a grade in Southern Oregon, towing my 11K fifth wheel. It got REALLY loud, then all of the sudden it just quit, never to return. Well, not until they screwed with it...
I brought my truck in for a separate annoying issue, that wasn't even as annoying as the whistle. Well, guess what? They put in a new EGR, Exhaust Back Pressure Sensor, and a turbo...
Now that damned whistle is back with a vengence!!! Still only under heavy load, at high RPMs.... ???
I hope this helps narrow the possibilities for you guys. I personally think that it is the turbo, or something related to it. Maybe something that is connected to the turbo???
Anyway, just thought I'd let you all know that I am back it the whistle club.
I think I would have been better off leaving well enough alone, and not worried so much about the newer issue that I probably could have lived with... Arrrrgh.
But I gotta say, I still LOVE this truck! Everything else is just great. And my service department is still dilligently trying to figure it out. No reason to leave Ford as I see it. Yet... Not even close, yet. I'm confident that they will figure it out. That, and the other little annoying thingy. Gotta be patient I suppose.
I'll try to keep you all posted.
Regards, Tim
My whistle "went away" one day, while climbing a grade in Southern Oregon, towing my 11K fifth wheel. It got REALLY loud, then all of the sudden it just quit, never to return. Well, not until they screwed with it...
I brought my truck in for a separate annoying issue, that wasn't even as annoying as the whistle. Well, guess what? They put in a new EGR, Exhaust Back Pressure Sensor, and a turbo...
Now that damned whistle is back with a vengence!!! Still only under heavy load, at high RPMs.... ???
I hope this helps narrow the possibilities for you guys. I personally think that it is the turbo, or something related to it. Maybe something that is connected to the turbo???
Anyway, just thought I'd let you all know that I am back it the whistle club.
I think I would have been better off leaving well enough alone, and not worried so much about the newer issue that I probably could have lived with... Arrrrgh.
But I gotta say, I still LOVE this truck! Everything else is just great. And my service department is still dilligently trying to figure it out. No reason to leave Ford as I see it. Yet... Not even close, yet. I'm confident that they will figure it out. That, and the other little annoying thingy. Gotta be patient I suppose.
I'll try to keep you all posted.
Regards, Tim
Last edited by olfordsnstone; 08-28-2007 at 08:21 PM.
#22
I have the same problem with my 07 F350 Dually. I tow anywhere from 12k to 18k up and down the 5 in California. I do auto transporting, I have been hearing the whistle more and more often. First it was only when I was going up the grapevine. Now I can hear it going up smaller hills. Before it only whistled in high heat, big load, big hill, and about 2800 rpm. Now it happens with just big load and about 2800 rpm even on smaller hills. I had another post and was told it was the fan but never got an answer about a fix. I hope someone can find out how to stop this annoying sound.
Just a thought... if it is the fan making the noise, do you think changing to an electric fan setup will get rid of the problematic annoying noise? I know it's not a real fix, but just a thought.
Kelly
Just a thought... if it is the fan making the noise, do you think changing to an electric fan setup will get rid of the problematic annoying noise? I know it's not a real fix, but just a thought.
Kelly
#23
Originally Posted by badbrad60
Hey, OLFORD did you ever have your exhaust manifold off at all? If in fact the up pipe is cracked on my truck, Im obviously wondering why? I did take off the drivers side manifold to tap for an EGT sensor. Other than that Im not sure how or why it would have cracked other than it just did...My scenario is very similar to yours, but I don't necessarily notice a loss of power.....if I have a loss, it isn't noticeable to me in that towing scenario.
I am taking my truck in this week for a possible replacement turbo. The exhaust side oil seal in turbo is suspected of leaking and puffing white/gray smoke. Crazy they have to replace the entire turbo to swap the seal.....While they have the turbo off I am going to insist that they check the integrity of the EGR uppipe. I'll let you all know what happens ~Brad
I am taking my truck in this week for a possible replacement turbo. The exhaust side oil seal in turbo is suspected of leaking and puffing white/gray smoke. Crazy they have to replace the entire turbo to swap the seal.....While they have the turbo off I am going to insist that they check the integrity of the EGR uppipe. I'll let you all know what happens ~Brad
#24
Feeder. haven't scaled it yet, but I estimate it to be well over 16k when loaded down. Truck always has power to spare with all the mods. I am usually having to back off the gas to get the whistle to shutup. I usually turn off the A/C when climbing nasty hills, but half way up the hill on one of my last trips and turned the A/C on and the whistle stopped....turned it off again and it the whistle returned......
Anyway, truck pulls the camper superbly. ~Brad
Anyway, truck pulls the camper superbly. ~Brad
#25
Originally Posted by kkim124
I have the same problem with my 07 F350 Dually. I tow anywhere from 12k to 18k up and down the 5 in California. I do auto transporting, I have been hearing the whistle more and more often. First it was only when I was going up the grapevine. Now I can hear it going up smaller hills. Before it only whistled in high heat, big load, big hill, and about 2800 rpm. Now it happens with just big load and about 2800 rpm even on smaller hills. I had another post and was told it was the fan but never got an answer about a fix. I hope someone can find out how to stop this annoying sound.
Just a thought... if it is the fan making the noise, do you think changing to an electric fan setup will get rid of the problematic annoying noise? I know it's not a real fix, but just a thought.
Kelly
Just a thought... if it is the fan making the noise, do you think changing to an electric fan setup will get rid of the problematic annoying noise? I know it's not a real fix, but just a thought.
Kelly
#26
Went to the dealer this morning to get some driveline grease and talked to the tech and tech sup about the stupid whistle and he said it is becoming a bigger deal as the word is getting around that people aren't just "hearing" things.
Anyway, a customer has an 05 6.0 and pulls a toyhauler up the same grades that I do and is sick and tired of the "whistle".
He got the techs to hook up the laptop or whatever they use to monitor engine stuff, and were directly able to pinpoint it to the clutch assembly in the fan. They were able to, based on a few parameters tell exactly when the noise would start...and it did everytime under certain variables.
They are going to replace the fan clutch to "appease" the customer, because FORD says at this time there is no "fix" yet.
Apparantly it is a harmonic anomaly and "just happens"
That's lame.....If enough folks bitch about it, then may FOMOCO will make a clutch/fan that doesn't do this??? hmmm ...brilliant.
Anyway, a customer has an 05 6.0 and pulls a toyhauler up the same grades that I do and is sick and tired of the "whistle".
He got the techs to hook up the laptop or whatever they use to monitor engine stuff, and were directly able to pinpoint it to the clutch assembly in the fan. They were able to, based on a few parameters tell exactly when the noise would start...and it did everytime under certain variables.
They are going to replace the fan clutch to "appease" the customer, because FORD says at this time there is no "fix" yet.
Apparantly it is a harmonic anomaly and "just happens"
That's lame.....If enough folks bitch about it, then may FOMOCO will make a clutch/fan that doesn't do this??? hmmm ...brilliant.
#29
6.4 has got the whistle too...
Looks like Ford passed on the whistle the the 6.4 folks...lame.
https://www.ford-trucks.com/forums/6...y-5er-13k.html
https://www.ford-trucks.com/forums/6...y-5er-13k.html
#30