whats everyone think???
stock block
scat crank 4.3 stoke
h beam scat rods
.03 over je pistons hyperutectic (spelling???)
cam comp cam xe262h
stock heads ported ofr low rpms
msd ignition 6btm
msd distributor
weiand steath intake
holley 750 carb
also this is the build up to hold twin turbos but due to cost they will come later
thanks
tony
thanks
tony
thanks
tony
this is the post where the question came up about boosted apps and pistons. im not telling you your wrong rob please dont take it that way most of my build has came off info you have given and i appreciate the replys. i just want to do this right the first time and not spend thousands of dollars on mistakes i could have just researche dand gotten the right answers too.
thanks
tony
Trending Topics
I hate to do this since I like and respect fredirick, but I should have known where you got that info. On this I am going to have to come out and say it, he is wrong. The man is full of really good info and really knows his tuning stuff expecially with the aftermarket injection but on engine internals, not this time. (dang I hate putting it that way, fredirick if you read this please do not get insulted, cause I really don't mean it that way)
NOw let me give you somethings to think about. Also for clarification I am not one of these people that hates hypers, and infact I have and will use them in certian apps. Just not this one.
Hypers only have 2 advantages over forged, price bieng the first and formost, ok whats your engine worth? Whats a turbo worth if a piston grenades and takes it out, which it will do? can you replace everything like the block, turbos, rods, bearings heads etc for the couple hundred you save?
Next frederick is correct in that hypers are more thermal stable than forged, which means they don't expand as much thus you can make the cold piston to wall clearence tighter thus allowing you to run it harder when the engine is cold. Personally I don't see that as an advantage as I don't pound on my engines when they are cold no matter what pistons are in them, and the dangers of running hypers is not worth the ability to start a cold engine and hammer the throttle. Once a forged piston is up to operating temp, it's going to have the same clearences as a hyper does at operating temp so no advantage once warm.
Now to explain some of this, hyperautic pistons are a cast piston just like the factory cheapos that don't take a lot of abuse before causing problems on modified engines. They are not machined or made any different than any other cast piston except for the alloy's in them, and what is that alloy? It's high silicon content, now what is silicon? It's basically glass, and we know that glass is brittle although it is harder than alum and more heat stable (which is where the advantage of hypers comes from). Here is a little test for you, and yes I have done this to prove the point, take a cast, hyper and forged piston. set them on the ground combustion surface up. now take a 28oz hammer and hit each one. What will happen is this, the cast piston will usually break into a couple of pieces (you do have to hit them pretty hard) the forged piston will end up with a dent in it, and the hyper? well it will shatter just like a water glass when you hit it, into a hundred pieces. Now it will take more of a hit than the cast to break but when it does watch out.
Now one very well known fact is hypers are very sensitive to the tune, they can not withstand detonation or pinging. Frederick is as stated above very, very good at this. But what if you have something partially plug the fuel system and lean it out, or what if you have the dist advance stick (it does happen occasionally) and at low rpms you stand on it, and it detonates, or you have it set to run 93 octane fuel and some tanker driver not paying attention accidently drops 87 octane into the storage tank (happens more than people realize ) or you happen to get it hot, or carbon builds up on a piston and creates a hot spot causing detonatioi. The hyper will not take it and will go into pieces scattering pieces of the piston throughout the engine. Last one I had do that to me was #4 on a 302, I found pieces of that piston in cyl 1, 6, and 7. all the pistons on the same side of a dual plane intake. I also found lots of pieces of it in the exhaust. Now your running a turbo, what do you think those pieces of piston are going to do to that turbo spinning at 30,000+rpms when they hit it? Now you could put hyperautic pistons in there and never ever have a problem, or you could have it detonate the first time you drive it. It's just not worth the risk to me, and I would never build one of my engines that way. And if you brought that engine to me I would refuse to use hypers in it if I knew you were going to run forced induction. I frankly will not build something that I wouldn't do to one of my own engines, since it's got my name on it the engine will be build good enough to run in one of my cars. Now I will give frederick credit, he is running them in his so I don't feel he is bieng in anyway hypocritical recommending them, but just wrong to say they are better than forged. But if he ever has one go bad, I gaurentee you that his next post will be about what junk they are.
Now for compression as a note, you are probalby planning on running say 8:1 minimum since your not starting out as a turbo engine but upgrading as money applies, well here is a chart on the KB website showing what your final compression will be and note they don't recommend more than a 12:1 comp final on premium pump fuel. Thats only 8lbs of boost on a 8:1 compresson engine, so this will cause the detonation that will kill those pistons in a heart beat. so the max you could get away with would be 6lbs of boost pretty low actually.
http://kb-silvolite.com/feature.php?action=read&F_id=41
I really just want you to be fully informed before making a decision like that, and I will never recommend something I would not do myself (or I will flat out tell you it's something that won't ever be done on one of my engines.
Sorry for the long post.
Ford Trucks for Ford Truck Enthusiasts
thanks
tony
sorry for the long post guys
thanks
tony
Last edited by littleme13; Aug 20, 2006 at 02:11 AM.
I think your doing the smart move just building it for the turbo's right off the git go. No sense spending money twice and then you just get what you want without the hassle, yes it takes a little longer but worth it IMHO.


