Replaced Radiator, still having leak issues, seems to be overpressurized?...
#32
I agree with the recommendations to use worm style clams. The hose ends seem to widen over time and the stock spring clamps aren't enough to hold the coolant inside. That has been my experience anyway.
Have you tried using a vacuum gauge to test for leaks? The procedure is outlined in the tech folder.
Have you tried using a vacuum gauge to test for leaks? The procedure is outlined in the tech folder.
#33
Just by looking at the coolant temps it doesn't appear to be head gaskets to me. ONE indicator is a very rapid rise (and fall) in coolant temps if your head gaskets are blown because the combustion gas heats the coolant. Your data doesn't indicate that. If you went up Saluda grade going into Asheville on I-26 and only hit 193* that's excellent.
This is a valid test. I have it all posted in the Tech Folder also.
Please be VERY careful venting the cap at 20 psig. It is abnormal being that high IMO. A cap in good working order can relieve the pressure slow enough to make it safe, but with the extra pressure and perhaps a cap that is not 100% functional, it is possible that the pressure will relieve suddenly and spray hot coolant.
A normal system can build 3-4 psig again if pushed hard (after venting), but it absolutely should not go much past that.
Please be VERY careful venting the cap at 20 psig. It is abnormal being that high IMO. A cap in good working order can relieve the pressure slow enough to make it safe, but with the extra pressure and perhaps a cap that is not 100% functional, it is possible that the pressure will relieve suddenly and spray hot coolant.
A normal system can build 3-4 psig again if pushed hard (after venting), but it absolutely should not go much past that.
Below the min line, maybe 1/8". It never leaks out of this cap. There is nothing on or around the degas bottle. I have a sticker on mine, which I understand is the 'new' max line.
Did you use new worm style clamps? When I flushed my system the hoses had a tendancy to leak if the old spring style clamps were not in the same exact position on the hoses as when they came off. I changed the spring type to worm style clamps and my leaks went away. Your temps look good to me. If your cap isn't releasing at 16 I don't care if it's new. It's not working properly.
I purchased an OEM cap after originally purchasing a Stant cap and having it pressure checked for 15-16 psi. It appeared to work, but bought the OEM 'click style' just in case. My stant didn't click when it screwed on.
#34
#35
I'm also wondering if there was a manufacturing change made to the correctly spec'd cap unbeknownst to the general public, similar to the oil cooler change.
#36
No, sorry, that 193 was on my 100 mile trip to Charlotte. I'll have to look, I think on the grade you are referring to, my ECT got up to 205 in 3rd Gear driving about 3000rpms. It immediately dropped though, by the time I got about 3 or 4 miles, it was back down to 190.
FWIW--Before dropping a chunk of cash on anything else, it might be worth the coin to invest in a pressure testing kit as was previously suggested. You can pump it up to see where and what's pushing coolant at what pressure and why. It will also tell you what pressure your cap pops at. That would also give you a way to verify that your pressure gauges match. These days it's so freakin hard to know that you're getting a quality instrument.
#37
Nothing wrong with that. IIRC that's about a 7 mile 6 or 7% grade. We used to do our test and tunes there when I lived in Hendersonville.
FWIW--Before dropping a chunk of cash on anything else, it might be worth the coin to invest in a pressure testing kit as was previously suggested. You can pump it up to see where and what's pushing coolant at what pressure and why. It will also tell you what pressure your cap pops at. That would also give you a way to verify that your pressure gauges match. These days it's so freakin hard to know that you're getting a quality instrument.
FWIW--Before dropping a chunk of cash on anything else, it might be worth the coin to invest in a pressure testing kit as was previously suggested. You can pump it up to see where and what's pushing coolant at what pressure and why. It will also tell you what pressure your cap pops at. That would also give you a way to verify that your pressure gauges match. These days it's so freakin hard to know that you're getting a quality instrument.
#38
Should I buy or just rent? I had the cap tested, but I guess it would be a good idea to rent the O'Reilly's cooling system pressure tester. They told me it would be $150 and then I would get my money back when I returned it. I have never used the tester other than for caps. Do I just screw it on to the degas bottle and pump the system up to 16 -18 psi or so and see if it leaks?
Most just screw onto the degas bottle or radiator directly but you may have to plumb it in somehow. I guess it depends on what they have in the kit.
#39
Yeah, they have the kit with the Ford adapters for the degas bottle and degas cap. I will rent it and see what I can come up with.
#40
This is dang near impossible to see, but if you open it up full screen, you can see the coolant leaking from the upper hose. After I got home, I tightened the hose down using a ratchet and 8mm socket and tightened it until it stopped, without cranking down really hard. I would guess it went 1.5 turns more? I was afraid to really drive it after that because I thought maybe it was a good thing that the pressure was leaking instead of blowing this new radiator. I like the pressure test now. Sorry I missed that last time. I'll pump up the system tonight and see what is going on.
#41
I've never driven any length of time with a pressure gauge attached to the cooling system so I don't know how it would respond. The only time I did that was to check for blown headgaskets since the truck was puking out the cap anyway. Since the gauge went over 16 fairly fast the diagnosis was easy. That may be something I need to do just for grins, giggles, and future reference. I personally wouldn't worry about blowing an aluminum radiator at 20 psi. I'd think it would take quite a bit more but I may be thinking wrong. I know that a lot of people don't like spring clamps because they can't crank them down. I like them for the fact that they don't ever loosen up BUT it seems that once they get "seated" in a particular position on an old hose they like to stay in that position. I guess both types have their pluses and minuses
#42
#43
#44
Mark, if the cap is working properly shouldn't it relieve itself? Don't think springs have built in time delays? Should be instantaneous in my op.
#45
I never reach the cap relief point. I run 8-9 psig almost all the time. I can get it to spike to 11-12 psig if I make a WOT run from a standstill. Once I reach 75 mph and hold it, it slowly drops back to 9 psig.
There is quite a bit of instantaneous heat from a WOT run. That heat, and maybe even some flash boiling on the surface of cooling surfaces, causes this momentary spike of 2-3 psig.
There is quite a bit of instantaneous heat from a WOT run. That heat, and maybe even some flash boiling on the surface of cooling surfaces, causes this momentary spike of 2-3 psig.