When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
Can a bad PCV valve contribute to a rough idle? My mechanic is telling me that that is part of the problem, but I can't logically make the connection as to why. Any opinions (for engine info, see sig)?
According to the shop manual it can. I've never noticed a difference when putting a new one on, perhaps because the old one hadn't failed. I suppose it would have to either be plugged up or wide open to have any effect. For $3, I don't worrry as to whether it's bad or not, I just replace it regularly.
Yes it can affect performance, at least on my '96 4.0. It won't idle well, or get good mileage, with a "bad" one. This includes a brand new Fram replacement. Go for the OEM Ford valve. It fits, apparently, and it solved my rough idle problem inexpensively.
Replaced it at lunch, didn't do any good in helping me keep from stalling when I fire the van up, but the other valve didn't rattle at all when I took it out. Still worth th $3 or so I paid for it I'll bet.
Just because the PCV rattles does not mean it is good. The valve and spring wears internally and the valves loose their metering ability. Replace annually...