Odd starting issue
#1
Odd starting issue
I'm having some cold weather issues with the truck. In warm weather it starts fine. I replaced all of the glow plugs recently with motorcraft plugs. The batteries have been recently replaced as well, but in cold weather It's very hard to start the truck.
When I switch the ignition on, I see the "wait to start" light go on for a few seconds, and then it goes out. I hear a clicking that occurs every second or so and the indicator lights will dim with the clicking. I assume it's the glow plug circuit? I'll try this twice (to heat the cylinders) and will crank the engine over. It will crank for a bit, start, stumble and then die. Usually it's running on only a few cylinders as the engine shakes like mad and you can tell its not running right. After it dies I try to start it again. However, the engine is very hard to turn over. You can tell the starter is laboring and it sounds like it's fighting against something. I'll sit and wait a few minutes and try again. Eventually I'll get it to turn over to the point where it stumbles until all of the cylinders kick in. I'm sure it's not good for the engine to run unbalanced. I know the batteries are good and it happened in my old set of batteries as well. The plugs are good but the controller may be bad. I'm not sure what is making the engine hard to start after it initially tries to run and then stumbles. Any suggestions? The starter seems fine since it works fine when the engine hasn't been started, or the engine is warm. I plugged in the heater for three hours yesterday and despite the warmer working, I didn't notice a better start.
I'll summarize with the batteries are fine and it does not sound like a dying battery starter. It sounds like a laboring starter only after it starts and stumbles. The first start is always at a good speed.
When I switch the ignition on, I see the "wait to start" light go on for a few seconds, and then it goes out. I hear a clicking that occurs every second or so and the indicator lights will dim with the clicking. I assume it's the glow plug circuit? I'll try this twice (to heat the cylinders) and will crank the engine over. It will crank for a bit, start, stumble and then die. Usually it's running on only a few cylinders as the engine shakes like mad and you can tell its not running right. After it dies I try to start it again. However, the engine is very hard to turn over. You can tell the starter is laboring and it sounds like it's fighting against something. I'll sit and wait a few minutes and try again. Eventually I'll get it to turn over to the point where it stumbles until all of the cylinders kick in. I'm sure it's not good for the engine to run unbalanced. I know the batteries are good and it happened in my old set of batteries as well. The plugs are good but the controller may be bad. I'm not sure what is making the engine hard to start after it initially tries to run and then stumbles. Any suggestions? The starter seems fine since it works fine when the engine hasn't been started, or the engine is warm. I plugged in the heater for three hours yesterday and despite the warmer working, I didn't notice a better start.
I'll summarize with the batteries are fine and it does not sound like a dying battery starter. It sounds like a laboring starter only after it starts and stumbles. The first start is always at a good speed.
#2
Interestingly, the GPs on my 86 6.9l act the same way. I replaced the GPs and the GP controller. I think it may be due to a corroded GP relay.
When I initially turn on the GPs they're only on for 3-4 seconds. If I leave the key in the RUN position the GPs will start to cylce, 1-2 seconds on and then 2-3 seconds off. I usually let them cylce 2-3 times before starting if it's cold. Hopefully someone knows what's up with our wonky GPs.
When I initially turn on the GPs they're only on for 3-4 seconds. If I leave the key in the RUN position the GPs will start to cylce, 1-2 seconds on and then 2-3 seconds off. I usually let them cylce 2-3 times before starting if it's cold. Hopefully someone knows what's up with our wonky GPs.
#3
I would guess that some of your glo plugs are burnt out.. If only 6 /8 are firing it will do this..
Try disconnecting the glo plug relay and shooting 3 short bursts of starting fluid into the intake..
If it fires smooth and easy, without same symptoms then that's the problem..
When mine started to go out it did this.. Rough and smokey till all cylinders got to firing after a minute..
The resistance may be the compression that has built in an otherwise still cold motor.
Just me, but I ditched the plugs many years ago in favor of a dedicated ether straw that runs into the cab plumbed into the hat.
Just one nearly dead battery still fires easy and smooth even in these sub freezing temps. Ether is okay as long as you don't use the glo plugs at the same time.. Controversial topic though and most disagree, in my opinion it's easier on a cold motor, starter, battery.. ect because it doesn't crank but a few seconds..
Could also fix the gp system and put on a relay with on off button and install a ether hose also for a choice of either starting option.
No matter what, when and where I need my motor to start.
Try disconnecting the glo plug relay and shooting 3 short bursts of starting fluid into the intake..
If it fires smooth and easy, without same symptoms then that's the problem..
When mine started to go out it did this.. Rough and smokey till all cylinders got to firing after a minute..
The resistance may be the compression that has built in an otherwise still cold motor.
Just me, but I ditched the plugs many years ago in favor of a dedicated ether straw that runs into the cab plumbed into the hat.
Just one nearly dead battery still fires easy and smooth even in these sub freezing temps. Ether is okay as long as you don't use the glo plugs at the same time.. Controversial topic though and most disagree, in my opinion it's easier on a cold motor, starter, battery.. ect because it doesn't crank but a few seconds..
Could also fix the gp system and put on a relay with on off button and install a ether hose also for a choice of either starting option.
No matter what, when and where I need my motor to start.
#4
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Marlboro Mental Hospital.
Posts: 60,968
Received 3,099 Likes
on
2,161 Posts
#5
If it fires smooth and easy, without same symptoms then that's the problem..
#6
Ether won't cause an engine to fire smoothly. Quick Start ether injection kits were standard equipment on Detroit, Cummins, and Case diesels and when used, engines misfired and ran rough as a cob for a number of seconds, not to mention knock LOUD momentarily due to the pre-ignition. As tjc transport posted, sounds like air intrusion which is a common problem. Especially the rough running when it finally fires.
I agree it sounds like air intrusion the whole start and die thing gives it away
#7
When I switch the ignition on, I see the "wait to start" light go on for a few seconds, and then it goes out. I hear a clicking that occurs every second or so and the indicator lights will dim with the clicking. This part is glow plug issue. I would test them all, just to be sure. As a Controller will still attempt the standard wait to start 10 seconds or so even with 6 dead glow plugs. Ask me how I know that
You can tell the starter is laboring and it sounds like it's fighting against something. I'll sit and wait a few minutes and try again. This sounds like a starter going out. Think old electric RC car, they do great for like 2 mins, then you can walk faster than it can run. Electric motors can often fail like this, as they get weaker they fire off with enormous power due to the full charge of the batteries covering for the lack of genuine motor power. A starter should always sound like it is going to get the engine above stall speed.
Eventually I'll get it to turn over to the point where it stumbles until all of the cylinders kick in. I'm sure it's not good for the engine to run unbalanced. This could be due to a few issues. If say only 4 glowplugs were good. They would fire on only a few cylinders for maybe a second. But This as stated by others sounds like air getting in and cutting off the fuel until the pump can squeeze fuel back through. Unbalanced also is not great, but it is not as bad as you might think.
I know the batteries are good and it happened in my old set of batteries as well. The plugs are good but the controller may be bad. I can't stress enough that you should test light all of the glow plugs to ensure function. As a bad controller usually just fails. Most times in the on position and fries all of the glow plugs. I have personally submitted labor claims at a parts manufacturer for a GP controller failing in 4 months and cooking my plugs.
I'm not sure what is making the engine hard to start after it initially tries to run and then stumbles. Any suggestions? The starter seems fine since it works fine when the engine hasn't been started, or the engine is warm Keep in mind it is harder for a weak starter to start an engine that is somewhat dry. The oil you run is most likely a 15w40 so a start will be slower when cold due to the lack of lubrication. Also compounding that with when the engine is warm, it most likely has had the air forced out, and the glow plug circuit is not required to pull on the batteries further limiting power to a weak starter. This to me is classic Diesel covering up problems until a few crop up. Start with Air intrusion, as it will cripple you first. Then Glow Plugs, finally look at the starter. My 2 cents anyway.
You can tell the starter is laboring and it sounds like it's fighting against something. I'll sit and wait a few minutes and try again. This sounds like a starter going out. Think old electric RC car, they do great for like 2 mins, then you can walk faster than it can run. Electric motors can often fail like this, as they get weaker they fire off with enormous power due to the full charge of the batteries covering for the lack of genuine motor power. A starter should always sound like it is going to get the engine above stall speed.
Eventually I'll get it to turn over to the point where it stumbles until all of the cylinders kick in. I'm sure it's not good for the engine to run unbalanced. This could be due to a few issues. If say only 4 glowplugs were good. They would fire on only a few cylinders for maybe a second. But This as stated by others sounds like air getting in and cutting off the fuel until the pump can squeeze fuel back through. Unbalanced also is not great, but it is not as bad as you might think.
I know the batteries are good and it happened in my old set of batteries as well. The plugs are good but the controller may be bad. I can't stress enough that you should test light all of the glow plugs to ensure function. As a bad controller usually just fails. Most times in the on position and fries all of the glow plugs. I have personally submitted labor claims at a parts manufacturer for a GP controller failing in 4 months and cooking my plugs.
I'm not sure what is making the engine hard to start after it initially tries to run and then stumbles. Any suggestions? The starter seems fine since it works fine when the engine hasn't been started, or the engine is warm Keep in mind it is harder for a weak starter to start an engine that is somewhat dry. The oil you run is most likely a 15w40 so a start will be slower when cold due to the lack of lubrication. Also compounding that with when the engine is warm, it most likely has had the air forced out, and the glow plug circuit is not required to pull on the batteries further limiting power to a weak starter. This to me is classic Diesel covering up problems until a few crop up. Start with Air intrusion, as it will cripple you first. Then Glow Plugs, finally look at the starter. My 2 cents anyway.
Trending Topics
#8
Thanks for all of the replies.
Like I mentioned the glow plugs are brand new. I can double check all of them for continuity and resistance, but I removed the old ones and installed them new with motorcraft replacements.
If a starter is bad, is it better to get it rebuilt rather than risk an aftermarket replacement?
I'll check the glow plugs and try to manually run them before looking into the air intrusion issue after. I only say this because it starts pretty easily in warmer weather, and when it's running rough when cold there's endless white smoke coming out the exhaust before all cylinders fire up. Perhaps cold weather impacts air intrusion, I'm not sure.
Like I mentioned the glow plugs are brand new. I can double check all of them for continuity and resistance, but I removed the old ones and installed them new with motorcraft replacements.
If a starter is bad, is it better to get it rebuilt rather than risk an aftermarket replacement?
I'll check the glow plugs and try to manually run them before looking into the air intrusion issue after. I only say this because it starts pretty easily in warmer weather, and when it's running rough when cold there's endless white smoke coming out the exhaust before all cylinders fire up. Perhaps cold weather impacts air intrusion, I'm not sure.
#9
You can get starter brushes at rockauto..
I myself ordered a set last time I made a purchase, just to have on hand next time they wear out..
also got a spare set of alternator brushes and bearings for when the time comes, new clutch set, tob, new spare injectors and misc. wear parts that require replacement once in awhile..
Can't say how difficult brush replacement is, as I haven't done it yet on this starter, but have on others and I can usually take it apart and replace them in about as long as it takes to take the thing from off the vehicle. Windings keep good unless you crank for a long time and burn it up.. It's usually just brushes that wear out.
If you replace starter brushes be sure to clean out the groves in the stator (I think it's called) the rotating cylinder in the center) and wear breathing protection and gloves.
I can't say that I know for sure, but be careful because dust from hot wear parts, some brushes, brakes, clutches ect may contain asbestos sometimes. I don't Don a full body suit when making repairs, but at least take care not to blow off dust with an air gun and breath heavily while doing so.
Best regards.
I myself ordered a set last time I made a purchase, just to have on hand next time they wear out..
also got a spare set of alternator brushes and bearings for when the time comes, new clutch set, tob, new spare injectors and misc. wear parts that require replacement once in awhile..
Can't say how difficult brush replacement is, as I haven't done it yet on this starter, but have on others and I can usually take it apart and replace them in about as long as it takes to take the thing from off the vehicle. Windings keep good unless you crank for a long time and burn it up.. It's usually just brushes that wear out.
If you replace starter brushes be sure to clean out the groves in the stator (I think it's called) the rotating cylinder in the center) and wear breathing protection and gloves.
I can't say that I know for sure, but be careful because dust from hot wear parts, some brushes, brakes, clutches ect may contain asbestos sometimes. I don't Don a full body suit when making repairs, but at least take care not to blow off dust with an air gun and breath heavily while doing so.
Best regards.
#10
For those that have the most common starter, a Mitsubishi, the brush leads are not soldered but spot welded on. I was going to remove the old brushes, then drill, tap and screw on the new brush leads like on the big diesel Delcos. When I phoned the local auto electric shop he said that generally doesn't work out to well (why I don't know). All things considered, I took it to him, he did a complete rebuild in a couple hours and it was only $104. The grooves between the commutator segments can be cleaned with an ice pick or awl. then the segment surfaces sanded with emery cloth otherwise the brushes will wear prematurely. The grooves in the armature never need cleaning, plus after overhauling starters from semi tractors on down to pickups I'm fairly sure there's no asbestos involved.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post