Chassis Holes - To fill or not to fill?
#1
Chassis Holes - To fill or not to fill?
I just spent the whole day grinding and drilling off all of the old spring hangers off of the chassis. I am going IFS + IRS, after getting them all off the chassis now looks a lot like swiss cheese in a number of places.
So what have others done, just left them, or welded them over?
It looks like a lot of work to plug all all of them...
I am boxing the front and rear sections but did not intend to box all the way through.
Thanks
Lee
So what have others done, just left them, or welded them over?
It looks like a lot of work to plug all all of them...
I am boxing the front and rear sections but did not intend to box all the way through.
Thanks
Lee
#2
It is my understanding that with both IFS and IRS you want a very stiff frame for the independent suspensions to work properly. Filling extra holes is an appearance feature so it is mainly up to you. Don' forget to add weld nuts inside the boxed areas for items like stabilizer bars, etc. On my 56BW with the Corvette C4 IFS and IRS I have a fully boxed frame and am considering removing two crossmembers and adding a tubular x-member to make it more rigid.
#3
#4
Lee -
Ditto what LEckart said. The holes do not degrade the structural integrity appreciably. If you want to lay mirrors around it when you park it, fill them.
Boxing the entire frame is not appreciably more work than boxing some of it, but the stiffness of the overall structure goes WAY UP when the whole thing is boxed. Box it all! With IFS and IRS, you'll be glad you did. The problem with boxing some of the frame actually creates a problem. While the boxed area is stiffer for obvious reasons, the unstiffened sections wind up seeing more stress and flex more than they did before. In fact, the unboxed areas wind up seeing all the stress (twist) that the entire frame handled before. That can lead to cracks in the frame rail where the boxing ends.
(My Engineering 101 professor would be proud).
Ditto what LEckart said. The holes do not degrade the structural integrity appreciably. If you want to lay mirrors around it when you park it, fill them.
Boxing the entire frame is not appreciably more work than boxing some of it, but the stiffness of the overall structure goes WAY UP when the whole thing is boxed. Box it all! With IFS and IRS, you'll be glad you did. The problem with boxing some of the frame actually creates a problem. While the boxed area is stiffer for obvious reasons, the unstiffened sections wind up seeing more stress and flex more than they did before. In fact, the unboxed areas wind up seeing all the stress (twist) that the entire frame handled before. That can lead to cracks in the frame rail where the boxing ends.
(My Engineering 101 professor would be proud).
#6
#7
Trending Topics
#9
#10
Thanks to all for the replies,
I dont intend laying mirrors under it when its done. It will be used, not become a trailer queen.
I will have a go at boxing the front and see how it goes. If it goes well, I will probably have a go at the whole thing....
I was wondering about the stresses on the unboxed area myself. I have to admit that I have never worked on a truck that sat on a simple rivetted u section frame before. I couldnt beleive it when I first saw it.
I am used to 4x4 Land Rover chassis' that come as a solid box frame as standard.
Thanks
Lee
I dont intend laying mirrors under it when its done. It will be used, not become a trailer queen.
I will have a go at boxing the front and see how it goes. If it goes well, I will probably have a go at the whole thing....
I was wondering about the stresses on the unboxed area myself. I have to admit that I have never worked on a truck that sat on a simple rivetted u section frame before. I couldnt beleive it when I first saw it.
I am used to 4x4 Land Rover chassis' that come as a solid box frame as standard.
Thanks
Lee
#11
#12
trucks that are built for heavy duty use are usually u-section frames to allow flex, so that it will not crack when a whole load of stone is dumped in the back and such it doesnt snap. that is why even on the 2006 super duty its not a fully boxed frame. The boxed frame is used in say, the new f150, to decrease flex in frame to allow the suspension to do its thing, and decrease creaking and groaning of bed and cab. each has its own purpose.