Synthetic oil a Waste or Worth it?
#31
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: The Great State of Texas
Posts: 6,127
Received 1,447 Likes
on
893 Posts
I just found some Trop Artic Synthetic blend oil 10-30, 5-30, 5-20 at a farm store for 2.55/qt.
i have heard that the same maker for motorcraft also bottles the TropArtic, though, i have not made any attempts to verify this claim.
2.55/qt is pretty good ... knocks a buck per quart of the price of an DIY Oil change. If i find a 5 dollar bill laying on the ground, i pick it up.
these were new bottles marked SN service level.
any thoughts?
i have heard that the same maker for motorcraft also bottles the TropArtic, though, i have not made any attempts to verify this claim.
2.55/qt is pretty good ... knocks a buck per quart of the price of an DIY Oil change. If i find a 5 dollar bill laying on the ground, i pick it up.
these were new bottles marked SN service level.
any thoughts?
I would say if it's a SN rated oil and 5w-20 you're good to go unless you have a Ecoboost which requires a 5w-30.
#32
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: The Great State of Texas
Posts: 6,127
Received 1,447 Likes
on
893 Posts
I used Mobil1 5W-20 Extended performance synthetic oil in my Expy for 70K miles. I was averaging 19-20 on the highway. I've been using the MotorCraft 5W-20 Semi Syn ever since and I now have 84K on the clock and she still gets the same mileage.
I was all about the full synthetics until about a year ago. I started reading some reviews about the Mobil1 products that left me scratching my head and then the Ecoboost torture test came out. Ford beat the crap out of this truck for the equivalent of 170K miles using MC 5W-30 oil then they tore down the engine in front of God and country and revealed NO abnormal wear.
I'm not trying to change anyone's mind and these oil discussions tend to become fairly heated so I'll end here.
I switched back to MC oil and my wallet thanks me.
I was all about the full synthetics until about a year ago. I started reading some reviews about the Mobil1 products that left me scratching my head and then the Ecoboost torture test came out. Ford beat the crap out of this truck for the equivalent of 170K miles using MC 5W-30 oil then they tore down the engine in front of God and country and revealed NO abnormal wear.
I'm not trying to change anyone's mind and these oil discussions tend to become fairly heated so I'll end here.
I switched back to MC oil and my wallet thanks me.
#33
I started off using MotorCraft 5w-20 in my wifes '11 Edge but during the winter months this stuffs pumps terrible allowing the motor to knock over 10 minutes at idle. I switched to Mobil 1 and the engine would only knock for about 1 minute which means the full synthetic flows much better at cold temps which I feel is very important with this 3.5 engine.
I'm assuming you are using a Motorcraft oil filter (does the 3.5 also use the FL820S?--I believe my wife's Sable did) with the silicone anti-drainback valve, but any knocking cause by a bad ADB valve would subside within about a minute. Again, a 10 minute knock on a new engine using the recommended oil would bother me. Is it in the valve train, a piston slap kind of noise, or what?
George
#34
being that they had all the grades I need, i will likely be stocking up.... lord knows i go thru enough freaking oil .... lol
#35
One of the benefits of synthetic oil is that it has extended life; you can go longer between oil changes. However, I've read that a limiting factor here is how good the filtration system in the vehicle is; both the air and oil filter system. It's not doing you any good driving around with oil with life in it that's dirty.
German cars are geared toward going a long milage between synthetic oil changes. The oil filter on my Audi is HUGE. It also uses a Germman brand air filter, which I'm guessing is better then standard.
So if you're thinking of going 10,000 miles between oil changes just because you're putting synthetic into your American vehicle, you may be kidding yourself. Especially with turbos, which really need clean oil.
This is based on what I've researched and been told by Audi trained techs.
German cars are geared toward going a long milage between synthetic oil changes. The oil filter on my Audi is HUGE. It also uses a Germman brand air filter, which I'm guessing is better then standard.
So if you're thinking of going 10,000 miles between oil changes just because you're putting synthetic into your American vehicle, you may be kidding yourself. Especially with turbos, which really need clean oil.
This is based on what I've researched and been told by Audi trained techs.
#36
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: The Great State of Texas
Posts: 6,127
Received 1,447 Likes
on
893 Posts
Strange that you should have any knocking at all, especially for 10 minutes. My wife's old '98 Sable had a 3.0 Duratec, spent its life on 5W30 or 5W20 Motorcraft (either non-syn or semi-syn) oil and never had any kind of knocking problem even in subzero winter startups.
I'm assuming you are using a Motorcraft oil filter (does the 3.5 also use the FL820S?--I believe my wife's Sable did) with the silicone anti-drainback valve, but any knocking cause by a bad ADB valve would subside within about a minute. Again, a 10 minute knock on a new engine using the recommended oil would bother me. Is it in the valve train, a piston slap kind of noise, or what?
George
I'm assuming you are using a Motorcraft oil filter (does the 3.5 also use the FL820S?--I believe my wife's Sable did) with the silicone anti-drainback valve, but any knocking cause by a bad ADB valve would subside within about a minute. Again, a 10 minute knock on a new engine using the recommended oil would bother me. Is it in the valve train, a piston slap kind of noise, or what?
George
The real point I'm trying to make here is not with the issue with Fords 3.5 engine as that's another thread, but is synthetic a waste or worth it. Well for me it's worth it for use with this particular engine in that it idles much quieter, provides improved fuel economy, and flows much faster at cold startup and reduces that cold start knock much better than MotorCraft synthetic blend.
#37
I would recommend the factory recommended Motorcraft Synthetic Blend oil for normal driving. Full synthetic oil's are better but cost more. The important thing is to service your vehicle and change the oil on a regular schedule.
Having said that. I use Amsoil products in my Harley-Davidson twin cam air engine because of the extreme heat and the fact that isn't a liquid cooled engine.
Those that use full synthetic oils are making a mistake when they extended the service period compare to standard engine oil. Synthetic oil does a better job but should be change at the same interval as standard engine oils.
Having said that. I use Amsoil products in my Harley-Davidson twin cam air engine because of the extreme heat and the fact that isn't a liquid cooled engine.
Those that use full synthetic oils are making a mistake when they extended the service period compare to standard engine oil. Synthetic oil does a better job but should be change at the same interval as standard engine oils.
#38
I would recommend the factory recommended Motorcraft Synthetic Blend oil for normal driving. Full synthetic oil's are better but cost more. The important thing is to service your vehicle and change the oil on a regular schedule.
Having said that. I use Amsoil products in my Harley-Davidson twin cam air engine because of the extreme heat and the fact that isn't a liquid cooled engine.
Those that use full synthetic oils are making a mistake when they extended the service period compare to standard engine oil. Synthetic oil does a better job but should be change at the same interval as standard engine oils.
Having said that. I use Amsoil products in my Harley-Davidson twin cam air engine because of the extreme heat and the fact that isn't a liquid cooled engine.
Those that use full synthetic oils are making a mistake when they extended the service period compare to standard engine oil. Synthetic oil does a better job but should be change at the same interval as standard engine oils.
this is hearsay and should be verified by yourself.
that being said, i spent a year and a half working in a different part of the state and drove 160 miles a day to get there and back. Being tired of changing the oil every freaking month (especially in the winter) I started using Castrol Full synthetic and changing it every 3 months. That usually ended up between 10 and 12K miles.
not sayin you should or shouldnt do that ... just saying i did and there were no ill effects. After 220K that motor did develop a lifter issue, but that started at about 120K. One lifter wont hold pressure and needs to be replaced. But like i said, that problem was a long time coming and i do belive it would have happend regardless of oil or change interval.
I still got the car if anyone wants it 94 'scort 1.9, tube headder, h&r sport springs and pleanty of rust
just some food for thought.
#39
One of the benefits of synthetic oil is that it has extended life; you can go longer between oil changes. However, I've read that a limiting factor here is how good the filtration system in the vehicle is; both the air and oil filter system. It's not doing you any good driving around with oil with life in it that's dirty.
German cars are geared toward going a long milage between synthetic oil changes. The oil filter on my Audi is HUGE. It also uses a Germman brand air filter, which I'm guessing is better then standard.
So if you're thinking of going 10,000 miles between oil changes just because you're putting synthetic into your American vehicle, you may be kidding yourself. Especially with turbos, which really need clean oil.
This is based on what I've researched and been told by Audi trained techs.
German cars are geared toward going a long milage between synthetic oil changes. The oil filter on my Audi is HUGE. It also uses a Germman brand air filter, which I'm guessing is better then standard.
So if you're thinking of going 10,000 miles between oil changes just because you're putting synthetic into your American vehicle, you may be kidding yourself. Especially with turbos, which really need clean oil.
This is based on what I've researched and been told by Audi trained techs.
#40
I would verify your change intervals with Ford and your oil maker. I had a guy tell me that Mobil 1 recommended 10K oil changes and he verified that interval with Ford to maintain his warranty. The Ford service dept told him that if he kept recipts and records showing that Mobil 1 was used at 10K intervals, that they would honor the factory warranty.
this is hearsay and should be verified by yourself.
that being said, i spent a year and a half working in a different part of the state and drove 160 miles a day to get there and back. Being tired of changing the oil every freaking month (especially in the winter) I started using Castrol Full synthetic and changing it every 3 months. That usually ended up between 10 and 12K miles.
not sayin you should or shouldnt do that ... just saying i did and there were no ill effects. After 220K that motor did develop a lifter issue, but that started at about 120K. One lifter wont hold pressure and needs to be replaced. But like i said, that problem was a long time coming and i do belive it would have happend regardless of oil or change interval.
I still got the car if anyone wants it 94 'scort 1.9, tube headder, h&r sport springs and pleanty of rust
just some food for thought.
this is hearsay and should be verified by yourself.
that being said, i spent a year and a half working in a different part of the state and drove 160 miles a day to get there and back. Being tired of changing the oil every freaking month (especially in the winter) I started using Castrol Full synthetic and changing it every 3 months. That usually ended up between 10 and 12K miles.
not sayin you should or shouldnt do that ... just saying i did and there were no ill effects. After 220K that motor did develop a lifter issue, but that started at about 120K. One lifter wont hold pressure and needs to be replaced. But like i said, that problem was a long time coming and i do belive it would have happend regardless of oil or change interval.
I still got the car if anyone wants it 94 'scort 1.9, tube headder, h&r sport springs and pleanty of rust
just some food for thought.
There people that claim they get better fuel mileage and performance with higher octane than what the manufacturer recommends but that contradicts the way fuel octane works. If they beleive it I guess that's all that counts.
I would recommend anyone do research and not arbitrarily take the word of a stranger.
#41
Needed for some cars
A little off topic - full synthetic is needed in turbo cars . The bearing on the turbine is in direct contact with exhaust temps. Theses reach extremely high temps and can cause regular oil to "coke" on the bearing when you turn car off and oil sits in it - this is why the turbo manual suggests leaving car idle a bit after a hard run and before turning off . Full synthetic oil resists the "coking" on the bearing . But as far as a non boosted engine , I am not totally sure of benefits to full synthetic .
#42
A little off topic - full synthetic is needed in turbo cars . The bearing on the turbine is in direct contact with exhaust temps. Theses reach extremely high temps and can cause regular oil to "coke" on the bearing when you turn car off and oil sits in it - this is why the turbo manual suggests leaving car idle a bit after a hard run and before turning off . Full synthetic oil resists the "coking" on the bearing . But as far as a non boosted engine , I am not totally sure of benefits to full synthetic .
#43