I ended up the buying a used OEM pair on ebay. I'm still looking for a third one. I really wanted to go with aftermarket, but couldn't find anything that the wife liked as well as the stockers.. And it will be cheaper finding 3 replacements vs 4 aftermarkets, although not much. I've seen a couple different tires that have the "wheel guard" molded into the tire, so I plan to get some. Also, I am thinking about going with the 305/50/20's vs the stock 275/55/20's, which should help-out some..