YES! I can hear it right above my head when I am driving with the radio off. It almost sounds like double sided tape has pulled apart and you can hear the tackiness of the tape touching each other. If I push the slightest bit up on the headliner it stops. I had thought it was my daughter car seat rattling but it is deffinetly the headliner. Now it doesn't matter how load the radio is, I swear I can still hear it......I think I can hear it right now