I've still got the Pirelli Scorpions on my 09 EL at 45K. Still quiet as anything else I've ever had, no vibration and decent-ish tread. I'll probably only go another 5K or so, as spirited driving has worn the edges more than the center. Truck is primarily on road, some light mud on construction sites, and minimal snow, but I've never been disappointed with traction either. Although they are pricey, I'd definitely consider them again.

Edit: Just saw you're in Toronto and not terribly interested in all season tires. Sometime I suck at paying attention, LOL!