Actaully it was Car And Driver. It was the Ford's performance that held it back. Other than being overweight they had very good thingsg to say about it, especially the overall build quality. It did beat the Hemi powered Ram by 1 point which says that if Ford could givce this thing a bit more get up, even if it was just a midpack performer, it would have been very close to the Nissan. The F150 tested was almost 400 lbs heavier than the next heaviest, the Ram and had close to 900 lbs on the Tundra.