After much agony of searching for tires, I finally pulled the trigger and ordered 4 - 265/75-R16 Silent Armor Pro-Grade tires from discounttiredirect.com. There was a $50 off until Sat., plus Goodyear had a $40 rebate. As I tend to have OCD over purchases, I kept looking at reviews of these tires, and came across a $100 rebate from Goodyear for any Wrangler tire. You have to become a member of treadlightly.org for $25, and you get a redemption code from them to put on the rebate form they provide. So I saved another 35 bucks.

For anyone that missed out on the original $40 rebate, this one is good until 8/31/2010.

Here is the link to the rebate:
Tread Lightly - Goodyear Rebate for Tread Lightly! Members

 

Thank You!!! Pulling the trigger in a few days!