I remember those too. There was one on a jeep in the shop I took a few classes in and the owner had no squawks. I have read that they actually do a decent job but there is the potential that the paper may disintegrate and then clog things up. I guess it depends on the quality of the paper. Plus some papers now have skin lotions and stuff for your tender behind, whihc I guess isn't so good for engines.
I would stick with regular oil filters, they are good and relatively cheap, plus no one will kill your warranty because you didn't meet factory spec.
Oh yes! The Frantz toilet paper oil filter. It was sold by network marketing, much like Amsoil is sold today.
The problem with these is that they are bypass, not full-flow. This means that oil flow available to the bearings and lifters is reduced and unfiltered, while some of the oil is filtered and dumped back into the pan. I added a bypass filter (spin-on, not Frantz) to the old VW, which had no factory filter at all, but I also added a higher volume oil pump.
I have a "Toilet paper Oil Filter" made by Frantz. It uses an adapter that fits where the spin on filter goes. A small amount of the oil goes up the center of the tube and then filters down inbetween the paper sheets. Toilet paper doesnt disintegrate in oil. Reportedly if there is any moisture in the oil it will absorb it, decreasing acid production. The manufacturer recomends changing the toilet paper roll every 2000 miles and adding another quart of oil. I learned about it from one of the Doc's I work with who uses it in all his vehicles. His 3 year old Navigator has never had the oil changed, but when the oil is wiped on a towel it is clean. I cant go that long, so I change my once a year. I am happy with the results thus far. It was weird however drilling a hole in the oil pan for the drain line. For the older set, this is basically the same system that older tractors use to use. I figure the extra filtration isnt going to hurt, the oil pressure did not change with the valve in the oil pump. But this is not for everyone.
I don't see a reference to a Navigator. I do know that most bypass systems depend on a paper system. FS2500 is based on a paper towel rolls, the others on shorter TP rolls. I also know that my oil changes (60 gal each on 39 engines) at 500 hours show no significant downgrading of oil or additives. I am negoiating now on extending the changes to 1000 hours. BTW 500 hours is equal to about 50000 miles of under load operating. The US Navy did a study on TP bypass filters and concluded that they were very effected and spec them on heavy use engines
I hate ignorant posts about a Frantz filter. "you vehicle won't last" go to bobistheoil.com and look at their bypass filter forum if you want to get educated. Cellulose(paper) gets stronger in oil... It's been proven by millions of miles of driving and UOA's. Many people just change the filter element every 2k miles, send in a sample, add a qt and go...
I have to laugh, back in the 1950's the franz "family" drove a new caddy 300,000 miles w/o an oil change!
While the additives do decrease over time, what the "anti-tp experts" don't know is that Franz has a recommended tp filter change frequency- depending on mileage, usually about every other month, given the 1qt of new oil added to the system, there are more than enough refreshed additives.
Yes, the TP will take the "extreme heat of oil"
No the tp doesn't breakdown and deposit inside the engine (the design was changed in 1987 to completely eliminate even a remote possibility
and if they are really so bad, why does every kenworth diesel truck have a paper- towel bypass filter on it from the factory!...just a bigger version to the tp filter!
They do work,
They are extremely effective
and even remove water from the oil which is the #1 impactor to creating acid inside the oil pan! an importatnt thing for engines driven rarely or short distances!
Member: Never trust a person over 40 who drives a Chevy club
Flatheads ain't so bad!
Certified backyard mechanic I & II
This forum is owned and operated by Internet Brands, Inc., a Delaware corporation. It is not authorized or endorsed by the Ford Motor Company and is not affiliated with the Ford Motor Company or its related companies in any way. Ford® is a registered trademark of the Ford Motor Company.