Quote:
|
Originally Posted by fordmantpw
You seem to be the only one not wanting to accept the fact that Ford engineers know a bit more about trailer towing than you do.
|
I'm not gonna get into the middle of all of this...
I left the part of your quote fordman that I'm not convinced of.
Ford has done an EXCEPTIONAL job of the tow command on the SD's...my bud has one and he boasts about his 9000# travel trailer being ONE with the F350 SRW.
The part I'm not totatlly convinced that Ford engineers know all about trailer braking...in PARTICULAR...I tow with a Hensley Arrow hitch.
It is a high end hitch that very effectively reduces sway. My 9000# 35' hitch to bumper TT tows like...well...an arrow. I can have a semi trailer BLOW by me and sure I get SHOVED to the side but NO out of sync truck/trailer oscillations ensue. The WHOLE unit gets shoved by the BOW-WAVE but that's all.
Now why am I responding to this somewhat 'heated' thread. Well I'm NOT convinced the Ford Engineers know MY needs as a Hensley Arrow owner.
Here's why. While the Hensly Arrow (HA) is a very effective sway control and WD hitch (1400# WD bars)...there IS a condition where the HA can get the driver into trouble...and I'm going to describe that.
If my TT EVER gets to moving FASTER then my TV...the TT will SLAM or BANG into the REAR END of my TV. The HA literature from the mfg SPECIFICALLY instructs that you set up your brake controller to LEAD your TT braking.
What scares me is that with this new algorithm Ford has developed...in the unlikely event you are going into a downhill curve in wet conditions and get BLASTED by a semi or stiff cross wind as you pass a wiind break...the trucks electronics my determine that the TRUCK ONLY needs braking to stabilize...this could be catastrophic for me the HA owner/tower. As what could happen when ONLY the truck brakes are applied in this case the TT could continue to roll as it really isn't rigidly tied as a ball mounted interface is...in this specific scenario...I could lose rear axle traction and jacknife due to the actions taken by some Ford engineer that has no idea of the HA conditions.
Perhaps though the fancy roll stability control (RSC) would then save my bacon that IT got me into...that would be fitting I guess!

...but I would have to certainly change my shorts...
Now the scenario I just described IS REMOTE...but it is REAL for my towing setup. There is another manufacturer out there called ProPride that manufacturers a similar pivot point projection (3P) hitch with floating linkages that is susceptible to this phenom as well...does Ford know about these hitches and these restrictions?
I've very carefully tweaked my Prodigy brake controller to ALWAYS provide TT LEAD BRAKING because I UNDERSTAND my hitch...I'm not totally convinced Ford Engineers are because I go into RV dealerships and THEY have no CLUE about the HA or ProPride...so why would I expect Ford to?...the RV dealerships DEAL with RV's on a daily basis....and they are clueless...
So while this new Tow Command which ties into ABS with roll stability may for 95% of the towing public equate to a better mouse trap...for my HA and my trailer...I'd be afraid as I know what 'could' happen to my TT if I do NOT lead the TT braking under ALL conditions...
Perhaps Ford Engineers fully have taken this into account...and that would be great...I'm doubtfull.
Now that all said...it does sound like Ford is trying to certainly come out with a better mousetrap. Having heard my bud RAVE about the Tow Command on his SD...I KNOW he is sold...I wish more vehicles were offered with integrated brake controllers that actually sensed hydraulic pressure for braking vs accelerometer based aftermarket controllers that are prone to bumps in the road that are then sensed as a decelerating TV...which equates to jerky stops...so Ford should be applauded...I just fear their marketing folks are writing ads to compete with the TOY manufacturers...ahh...marketing.
Hope this helps clarify MY position on this...not looking to get into arguments...I'm just pointing out that the HA and ProPride hitches persent a UNIQUE towing situation with a brake controller.
If anyone is really interested...go over to RV.Net and type in Hensley BUMP into the search engine...it is a LIVELY topic...just don't start a thread about it unless you are really mean and want to drive the Mod's nuts!...KIDDING!!!tt...if you do venture over there...my screen name is crappie_fisherman and one of my 'bump' threads is one of the most recent that got LOCKED DOWN...but the data is contained inside the thread for your reading pleasure...
Thanks for listening.
joe.