Black is what Ford put in mine. Very nice rubber floor mats but the color ain't the best in that I have tan interior and med. gray carpet in the floor and tan carpet in the rear cargo area. I think the black is not the color, but I don't thing the gray would look that great either.
I put the Weathertech liners in my truck. They only have the three color options also and none are perfect....I have stone interiour and I went with the tan. I also have the cargo liner from canvasback and it's tan and looks better (color wise) than the floor liners up front.
My main purpose is to protect...so the color thing is not that big of a deal...althought it would be nice if it matched.
i have the black husky liners all the way through the truck. Work well and match my charcoal interior pretty well. My father in law has the tan interior and got the weather tech liners, probably the nicest floor mats for looks and fit and use, but the tan doesnt match the interior all that great, it is a different shade. Black would probably look better than the tan, just my opinion though.
I have black floor mats on black carpet. It is ok, but really shows the dirt. Since I am the only one that has ever been in the SUV, only the drivers floor mat gets any dirt, all the other areas look just like new. Over all the black interior is ok.
I bought a complete carpeted mat set on E-bay from Uncle WoWo's Floor Mats and stuff. They have the best coverage for the rear seats including the second row captains seat configuration. this covers the walkway between the captians seats and 3rd row seating. Price is good and he has 100% feedback. I should have mine in a week or so.
I just recently bought the nifty brand extreme mats for my 04 PSD crew cab. These are rubber formed mats that will catch most mud,liquids, and trash. They fit the truck great. Our sponsors carry these I believe with free shipping in some cases.
My Floor mats came in today for my EL. The carpeted mats look great and fit great. I have the captain seats for the second row. The mats have a T shape to fill the open area. Great product at a great price IMHO. If you are looking for a carpeted type mat, check his product out on E-bay. I cant post pictures so I am of no help there. The berber was 60 extra but worth it. I think it holds the sand better.