03 superduty mishimoto radiator tranny line problem
#46
I am in the process of installing a suposedly mishimoto radiator in my late build 2004 f 250. My transmission lines do fit but I am also concerned about the small holes at bottom of my fittings going into radiator. No where on my radiator is a serial number or mishimoto name. I Would post pictures but that is beyond my ability.
You want to click on the little icon and then you can browse your device (computer)
for the image you want to post of if you have it already posted somewhere you
can just put the URL in the other space and upload it.
My thoughts on this.
Sounds like one more reason I will not be using anything from them.
First the issue with the T-stats and now this.
Mark K might be the one that can say just how much the size of the
hold will effect the cooling or not. Lets see what he says if we can
get him to stop in.
Sean <BR>
6.0L Tech Folder
#47
I think that's the solution. In the photo of your old radiator there is a metal adapter. I think your new radiator needs that adapter, then the OEM lines crew into that.
#48
His current problem and the concern is the tiny port hole Mishimoto is using now compared to the OEM and the one in the video.
#49
And that's a real possibility. That is WAY too small! It is going to be very restrictive and severely limit your transmission cooling.
#51
#52
#53
#54
Can't comment on the adapter for an O3 as I have an O5, but I can tell you that the transmission cooler "orifice" does seem to be the standard size for the Mishi radiators. I ran one for 6 or 8 months before finally getting Mishi to accept it back as a return because it was was causing my engine to run hot, but the trans never got hot.
To my knowledge it was first documented here:
eBay aluminum radiator help - Ford Powerstroke Diesel Forum
I saw the same thing with mine, but didn't get any pics. Some comments in this thread:
Cooling troubleshooting & radiator comparison - Ford Powerstroke Diesel Forum
Sorry if I've violated some rule on cross-forum posting, I looked and didn't see anything.
To my knowledge it was first documented here:
eBay aluminum radiator help - Ford Powerstroke Diesel Forum
I saw the same thing with mine, but didn't get any pics. Some comments in this thread:
Cooling troubleshooting & radiator comparison - Ford Powerstroke Diesel Forum
Sorry if I've violated some rule on cross-forum posting, I looked and didn't see anything.
#55
I've been in contact with mishimoto about my problem.....the 7/32 hole for the tranny fluid. They have confirmed that this is a machining error. Do not install it in its current condition or you'll have trouble. I'm not very excited about there suggested fix though. They asked me if I could drill it out to the correct size. While it is possible this isn't for the faint hearted. If I attempt this I will do a full write up with proper tools and procedures.
#56
Mark would be the person to comment on transmission temperature, but my uninformed opinion is these transmissions seem to run cooler then many other designs until they do some serious towing. So a compromised cooling ability of the radiator may not show up for many.
Radiator design though has a lot of variations and aftermarket companies often compromise design towards production ignoring some of the wider operating parameters, and they often don't look towards all of the design parameters that can effect conditions. Coming from a career where both OE and aftermarket products were manufactured, it's was interesting to see all the aspects that engineers from manufacturers like Ford go through, whereas the aftermarket side doesn't consider those factors.
In a thread about the Mitso T/S I mentioned I would not be purchasing that item. I thought the company didn't do it's due diligence in researching the housing variations that plagued some installations, and if they did, the T/S would only be sold as a package with a housing it was compatible with.
From this forum and the others, I don't think they did their due diligence here either. Engine cooling isn't as considered as it should be, but the transmission itself is better positioned to handle the compromised design under common driving. The OE design is better thought out for both the engine and transmission full range.
Edit:
After reading Bigblackbuilds post, a manufacturing error like this does nothing to sway my opinion.
Radiator design though has a lot of variations and aftermarket companies often compromise design towards production ignoring some of the wider operating parameters, and they often don't look towards all of the design parameters that can effect conditions. Coming from a career where both OE and aftermarket products were manufactured, it's was interesting to see all the aspects that engineers from manufacturers like Ford go through, whereas the aftermarket side doesn't consider those factors.
In a thread about the Mitso T/S I mentioned I would not be purchasing that item. I thought the company didn't do it's due diligence in researching the housing variations that plagued some installations, and if they did, the T/S would only be sold as a package with a housing it was compatible with.
From this forum and the others, I don't think they did their due diligence here either. Engine cooling isn't as considered as it should be, but the transmission itself is better positioned to handle the compromised design under common driving. The OE design is better thought out for both the engine and transmission full range.
Edit:
After reading Bigblackbuilds post, a manufacturing error like this does nothing to sway my opinion.
#57
After everything I've been through with aftermarket vs OEM during my build I've learned a thing or two. Even though go fast aftermarket goodies are very appealing OEM is the absolute right answer. Fit and finish you can't go wrong. The major exception is of course studs over tty bolt so I'm not bashing any aftermarket goodies. You just have to be smart about it and do your research.
#58
How will you keep machining chips from getting into the cooler? One chip left in the cooler can work it's way into the trans and possibly cause a trans failure.
I agree with that. For probably 90% of the vehicle's life that restriction wouldn't cause a problem. But when you need a lot of cooling, that radiator won't have it.
Mark would be the person to comment on transmission temperature, but my uninformed opinion is these transmissions seem to run cooler then many other designs until they do some serious towing. So a compromised cooling ability of the radiator may not show up for many.
#59
How will you keep machining chips from getting into the cooler? One chip left in the cooler can work it's way into the trans and possibly cause a trans failure.
I agree with that. For probably 90% of the vehicle's life that restriction wouldn't cause a problem. But when you need a lot of cooling, that radiator won't have it.
I agree with that. For probably 90% of the vehicle's life that restriction wouldn't cause a problem. But when you need a lot of cooling, that radiator won't have it.
I think you still have a risk of something curling back in and not getting blown
out of the tank. If it were me and I just paid that much money for something that
should of been right in the first place I think it would go back into the box and they
would be sending me a shipping label and RAM # to go with it.
Sean <BR>
6.0L Tech Folder
#60
Oh hell no on drilling those out. If Mishi is actually suggesting this they are trying to take the cheap way out and asking you to accept all the risk. Not only would I not do that, I wouldn't accept a new one from them either out of fear they'd try to do the same thing and ship you a drilled radiator.