Ecoboost vs diesel half tons
#16
This is more true than I think most people want to admit. Even the mentioned TDI's have gone downhill recently with their IP pump issues.
#17
Here in Maryland diesel prices are 25-30% higher that regular gas. Not sure why, but it is what it is. Therefore diesel vehicles would need to get 25-30% better economy to be a net zero, there. Then you have the DEF, filter changes, etc.. After buying diesel fuel this weekend for the first time for my new Kubota tractor and seeing the diesel mess all over the ground that I struggled to step around, unless I needed the 20k towing capacity, I would go gas. Definately would stay away from diesel for a daily driver. But that's just me, your mileage may vary
#18
Still go 300k if people stop adding tuners and turbos and methanol inj. Diesel is still thechoice for fleets.
#19
Here in Maryland diesel prices are 25-30% higher that regular gas. Not sure why, but it is what it is. Therefore diesel vehicles would need to get 25-30% better economy to be a net zero, there. Then you have the DEF, filter changes, etc.. After buying diesel fuel this weekend for the first time for my new Kubota tractor and seeing the diesel mess all over the ground that I struggled to step around, unless I needed the 20k towing capacity, I would go gas. Definately would stay away from diesel for a daily driver. But that's just me, your mileage may vary
#22
#23
Here in Maryland diesel prices are 25-30% higher that regular gas. Not sure why, but it is what it is. Therefore diesel vehicles would need to get 25-30% better economy to be a net zero, there. Then you have the DEF, filter changes, etc.. After buying diesel fuel this weekend for the first time for my new Kubota tractor and seeing the diesel mess all over the ground that I struggled to step around, unless I needed the 20k towing capacity, I would go gas. Definately would stay away from diesel for a daily driver. But that's just me, your mileage may vary
#24
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: The Great State of Texas
Posts: 6,127
Received 1,447 Likes
on
893 Posts
There are a couple of things lost in all this.
And that is that the diesel is heavier, therefore payload and towing are reduced in diesels 1/2 tn. Maybe not a killer for the average 1/2 owner.
Secondly diesel emissions. I can see this being problematic for the grocery getter crowd. what oil to run in the winter, what to run in the summer? Regen..DEF, EGR...wrench light drive to clean...what!
And that is that the diesel is heavier, therefore payload and towing are reduced in diesels 1/2 tn. Maybe not a killer for the average 1/2 owner.
Secondly diesel emissions. I can see this being problematic for the grocery getter crowd. what oil to run in the winter, what to run in the summer? Regen..DEF, EGR...wrench light drive to clean...what!
Well said... Most .5 ton trucks don't get worked hard very often and spend most of their lives as daily drivers. Add in the fact that a lot of the owners of these trucks are not use to the special needs that a diesel requires and I'll predict a lot of the RAMs Ecodiesel owners will mistakenly pump gasoline into their truck and then it will be game over.
#25
Well said... Most .5 ton trucks don't get worked hard very often and spend most of their lives as daily drivers. Add in the fact that a lot of the owners of these trucks are not use to the special needs that a diesel requires and I'll predict a lot of the RAMs Ecodiesel owners will mistakenly pump gasoline into their truck and then it will be game over.
#26
#27
#28
I saw a guy in a new GM truck in Indy a few years ago trying to drain gas out of his diesel. We were at a BP station. BP puts green pump handle covers on their gas pumps. I have since read a few posts in both the 7.3L forum as well as the VW TDI forums where the unassuming driver pumped the wrong fuel. Survivable in an old school diesel. Death in a new school diesel.
I have always been extremly concerned with this possible "lapse" and ensured I was the only one who every filled up my Passat TDI or OBS 7.3L. And even then, I had a process I went throught to triple check which handle I had in my hand before I squeezed the trigger.
Is it an ignorant thing to do? Heck yes. Does stuff happen? Heck yes.
#29
My company was all excited about putting CNG vehicles in our CA fleet a couple of years or so ago. None exist now, we went away from them quick for this very reason.