Local HD e4od vs JW econo?
#1
Local HD e4od vs JW econo?
I'm in the middle of trying to sort my trans issues out, and wondering what anybody had for input. my stg 2 inj killed the e4od in it, but I got 7 months and 10k out of it! All I hear is JW or BTS. I've got everything I need for a zf5 swap minus front drive shaft, but can't pull the trigger on the swap. I hear too many pros about a built auto. I'm wondering if I need a full-blown "towmaster" from JW, or a BTS.. I talked to John and he said the Econo HD uses a 6.0 TC and is a good trans behind his 500hp truck, and is a good trans for someone who isn't an idiot behind the wheel.
I don't tow but 2-5 times a year, 3-8k lbs.. daily drive with the occasional b-out, or killing a gasser, you know the drill.
Anybody have an econo HD behind a stg 2 injected 7.3? Reports? I could manage the $3300 for the trans/shipping, but would that be patch compared to a full built BTS or towmaster? I could get the BTS, but if that's the case that I need it, I'll need to park the truck for a few months which i'd gladly do-I don't like having to do things twice!
Thanks!
BTW, truck is a 96, CCLB 4x4, Stg2 160/80, GH tunes, getting a T500 soon. Billet wheel on stock turbo. 3.55gears with 33"s
I don't tow but 2-5 times a year, 3-8k lbs.. daily drive with the occasional b-out, or killing a gasser, you know the drill.
Anybody have an econo HD behind a stg 2 injected 7.3? Reports? I could manage the $3300 for the trans/shipping, but would that be patch compared to a full built BTS or towmaster? I could get the BTS, but if that's the case that I need it, I'll need to park the truck for a few months which i'd gladly do-I don't like having to do things twice!
Thanks!
BTW, truck is a 96, CCLB 4x4, Stg2 160/80, GH tunes, getting a T500 soon. Billet wheel on stock turbo. 3.55gears with 33"s
Last edited by darknight; 11-09-2014 at 04:24 PM. Reason: left out some info!
#2
#3
Econo HD for the money. I have a thread I just did last week when I took my truck to him and got mine. It's a badass built trans. I don't have Stage 2s, but will have Stage 1s and tow fairly often right at 10k. If you saw the internals of the trans, you would have no doubts. Mine has been going great for over a week now. Feels like a new truck and he pulled a working E4OD out of my truck but it was on its last leg.
#4
Econo HD for the money. I have a thread I just did last week when I took my truck to him and got mine. It's a badass built trans. I don't have Stage 2s, but will have Stage 1s and tow fairly often right at 10k. If you saw the internals of the trans, you would have no doubts. Mine has been going great for over a week now. Feels like a new truck and he pulled a working E4OD out of my truck but it was on its last leg.
I'm really tempted to go for the econo hd. I do have stg2's, but stock turbo, stock hpop and fuel.. What warranty did he imply over the standard 1yr that he gives with it?
#5
He just said if something went wrong with anything that he would stand by it under normal use...aka no sled pulling
#7
Trending Topics
#8
I'll talk to Jwoods again this week, he was really pleasant to talk to over the phone, extremely helpful.
#9
#10
#11
Did John mention safe useable HP levels for the EconoHD?
I'm getting really excited with the idea that the econohd might be an option..
#12
He didn't really mention HP other than his 600 HP pulling/race truck has this trans in it, BUT, he knows how to drive and not abuse it. I have been pulling trailers for a long time so I assured him I was not going to be romping in it at stop signs all day, every day. He said it can take some abuse, just not 500 HP of trying to twist the driveshaft out of it. If it were me, I'd be comfortable running 350-400 HP and towing, just not racing or sled pulling or something over 12k. I pull a 10k travel trailer and will be pulling a 4-horse Goose-neck pretty much 2-3 times a week. I would have no problem really getting into it going up a grade. The new trans already has much improved shifting and uses the power band much more efficiently and feels pretty strong. Hope this helps. I would do John's or BTS, but I chose John because he is 2 hours from me, I could drive it to him, get an education, and drive it home. I am confident you'd be pretty happy with it.
#13
He didn't really mention HP other than his 600 HP pulling/race truck has this trans in it, BUT, he knows how to drive and not abuse it. I have been pulling trailers for a long time so I assured him I was not going to be romping in it at stop signs all day, every day. He said it can take some abuse, just not 500 HP of trying to twist the driveshaft out of it. If it were me, I'd be comfortable running 350-400 HP and towing, just not racing or sled pulling or something over 12k. I pull a 10k travel trailer and will be pulling a 4-horse Goose-neck pretty much 2-3 times a week. I would have no problem really getting into it going up a grade. The new trans already has much improved shifting and uses the power band much more efficiently and feels pretty strong. Hope this helps. I would do John's or BTS, but I chose John because he is 2 hours from me, I could drive it to him, get an education, and drive it home. I am confident you'd be pretty happy with it.
#14
#15
I know you guys probably get more seat time thn me; heck, im only home half the year but this thread is a perfect example of why I have a 5spd in this particular truck. I'm not dissing anybody's decision and we're all entitled to our desires but what a hastle it is worrying about that tranny when putting some power adders on. Clutches are so cheep and easy + now pedal feel can be better than stock.. ++ rev matched shifting and it's just like an auto.. In my old 97 cc I had hardly any mods, a superchip 1705, and a strait pipe, 3.55s and 35s. W/out the shift firmness of the programmer it was scary how mushy it shifted.. Granted I was way under geared...
That being said autos are very convenient, a good one can be pretty damn confidence inspiring, and if it's bulletproof than its bulletproof.. To me 3k is a lot of coin..
Anyhow good luck with your purchase, hope you end up getting a decent product!
That being said autos are very convenient, a good one can be pretty damn confidence inspiring, and if it's bulletproof than its bulletproof.. To me 3k is a lot of coin..
Anyhow good luck with your purchase, hope you end up getting a decent product!