Batteries
#46
10-03-2011, 07:35 AM
Wait, you had Red Tops. Yellow Tops are deep cycle. What's the Optima benefit again?
#47
10-03-2011, 09:48 AM
Obviously, you've never shopped in Cody. Only three of those dealers stock batteries, none are open on Sunday, six are closed on Saturday and one location is a private residence. On closer inspection, one isn't even an automotive battery dealer.
Just what in the heck do you base your assertion of "needing a battery is way less" on? Maybe your need for a replacement battery at 2:00 AM on a Sunday is less because you're sleeping and never drive at that time. I have never read any study that shows AGM batteries outlast flooded batteries. They might in Alaska, but certainly not Arizona or Death Valley.
The biggest difference between batteries is warranty. Speak with any battery engineer and you'll find out that within a battery range, all batteries of a given capacity are virtually identical. The one year warranty Duralast is just about the same as the three year Duralast. The difference in price is an insurance premium to cover the extended warranty.
An Interstate battery is no better than a Motorcraft or Walmart or Costco battery. I personally know more people who have made warranty claims on Optimas than any other battery. Sure, AGM is better for mounting upside down or the beating inccured during the Baja 1000, but I try not to catch too much air offroad with my F250. It's too heavy to drive like a prerunner.
My personal experience tells me that a well maintained flooded battery is just as reliable as AGM. I've had two friends with F250s stuck in my driveway with bad Optimas.
Just what in the heck do you base your assertion of "needing a battery is way less" on? Maybe your need for a replacement battery at 2:00 AM on a Sunday is less because you're sleeping and never drive at that time. I have never read any study that shows AGM batteries outlast flooded batteries. They might in Alaska, but certainly not Arizona or Death Valley.
The biggest difference between batteries is warranty. Speak with any battery engineer and you'll find out that within a battery range, all batteries of a given capacity are virtually identical. The one year warranty Duralast is just about the same as the three year Duralast. The difference in price is an insurance premium to cover the extended warranty.
An Interstate battery is no better than a Motorcraft or Walmart or Costco battery. I personally know more people who have made warranty claims on Optimas than any other battery. Sure, AGM is better for mounting upside down or the beating inccured during the Baja 1000, but I try not to catch too much air offroad with my F250. It's too heavy to drive like a prerunner.
My personal experience tells me that a well maintained flooded battery is just as reliable as AGM. I've had two friends with F250s stuck in my driveway with bad Optimas.
There is a big difference in quality on batteries though. The warranty reflects that on most. Many batteries sold a discount stores are made with recycled lead. Higher end batteries are made with "virgin" lead. The problem with the recycled stuff is it's more prone to get sulfate build up quicker and more likely to have parts of plates break off and fall to the bottom of the case, sometimes shorting.
Sorry you don't care for Optimas. A lot of people like them.
This is where you throw logic onto Interstate 15. A fully charged Optima will store and deliver the same amount of power as the the same capacity el-cheapo flooded battery. The only theoretical benefit to an Optima in your scenarios is less damage from deep cycling with no charge for 100 miles.
Wait, you had Red Tops. Yellow Tops are deep cycle. What's the Optima benefit again?
Wait, you had Red Tops. Yellow Tops are deep cycle. What's the Optima benefit again?
#48
10-03-2011, 11:50 AM
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Atlanta, Georgia
Posts: 528
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#49
10-03-2011, 01:02 PM
I'm thinking that Sam's has regional contracts however.
#50
10-03-2011, 01:34 PM
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Atlanta, Georgia
Posts: 528
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#52
10-03-2011, 03:55 PM
#53
10-03-2011, 08:02 PM
I think that i bought them in winter of 06 i dont remember mileage if i had to guess 50-60K.So far they have out lasted my original Motorcrafts its going on winter of 11 and 187K. For the money id have to say i might get another set.
#54
10-03-2011, 08:21 PM
The biggest difference between batteries is warranty. Speak with any battery engineer and you'll find out that within a battery range, all batteries of a given capacity are virtually identical. The one year warranty Duralast is just about the same as the three year Duralast. The difference in price is an insurance premium to cover the extended warranty.
An Interstate battery is no better than a Motorcraft or Walmart or Costco battery.
An Interstate battery is no better than a Motorcraft or Walmart or Costco battery.
). This link Consumer Reports Article - MSN Autos sheds some objective light on batteries. I recently needed a battery for my daughter's Explorer. After comparing prices, warranty etc. I bought the Walmart EverStart with a 3 year free replacement warranty for about $50 less than a comparable Duralast or Interstate. The 5 year old Costco Kirkland batteries in my boat are awesome. I had Optima's in my previous boat that didn't seem any better than the OEM's (before they died). A friend has replaced 2 Optima's in the last 2 years in his boat and now has another bad one... But always wants to tell me how great they are!
Bottom line: Buy whatever battery that works for you but don't be fooled by the misconception of a higher price yielding better quality. I went with Motorcraft on my 06 F350 based on a reasonable price and the 3 year free replacement warranty which was a good value for me
#55
10-03-2011, 11:58 PM
Elder User
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: SoCali!!
Posts: 979
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Original FoMoCo battery gave up yesterday in my parts runner '02 Ranger, it didn't even make it 10 years! They just don't build anything like they used to!
I wasn't going to spend the coin for a Platinum, or even a Motorcraft ($110 list, $83 my cost), Duralast Gold ($103), or an Interstate ($74 my cost), so I ran down to Costco and bought a Kirkland (still a JC), looks just like the DLG, with the same warrantee, FOR $47!!! Perfect for the parts runner, we'll see how long it lives!
I wasn't going to spend the coin for a Platinum, or even a Motorcraft ($110 list, $83 my cost), Duralast Gold ($103), or an Interstate ($74 my cost), so I ran down to Costco and bought a Kirkland (still a JC), looks just like the DLG, with the same warrantee, FOR $47!!! Perfect for the parts runner, we'll see how long it lives!
#56
10-04-2011, 08:25 PM
Join Date: Feb 2011
Location: Atlanta, Georgia
Posts: 528
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for all the help guys, I picked up a couple of yellow Everstarts yesterday. The arguments from XB and others about Walmart store being plentiful and easy to find (and I like to travel, often in rural areas) were definitely persuasive (us lawyers love persuasive arguments, lol). Not to mention, I am in the middle of a FICM repair and just didnt want to spend the $400 on a set of platinums at this point! As I add more electronics, I will more than likely upgrade for sure...
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
02GrayPowerStroke
1999 - 2003 7.3L Power Stroke Diesel
6
01-25-2007 03:29 PM
