It's been 20+ years since I lived in the Little Rock area...so I'm of no use there. But after my last experience with a deer/truck contest (truck 1; deer 0) I'll take it to the dealership's bodyshop. The body shop that repaired mine didn't do a great job and some of the parts aren't exactly right. Granted, my insurance was paying for this one...the price could be out of this world if your insurance isn't picking up the bill. I'm surprised Cookie or Joe haven't chimed in on this one. They're allot closer than I am.
Reflections in Cabot does top notch work, but they also charge a top notch price. Southside in Jacksonville is MUCH more affordable, and they do quality work. It may not be show car type work, but it is definitely factory quality.